Top Pizza Restaurants in Lexington, VA Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Lexington: a local guide

Even though the town of Lexington is rather far away from New York City, that does not mean that Lexington residents do not love a good New York City slice! There are many pizzerias here in Lexington that provide their customers with authentic New York City pizzas miles away from the actual city.

New York City-style pizzas are made especially to have a thin crust, savory tomato sauce, and lots of melty mozzarella on top. The crusts are made very thin so that they get nice and crispy in the oven. If they are too thin, however, they can easily become soggy from the sauce. The key is to have the right ratio of sauce to the thinness of the crust.

A New York City pizza is completed with a thick layer of shredded mozzarella that is melted and cooked until it is golden brown on the top. Once the cheese is melted to perfection, the pizza is ready to go!

Best Delivery Pizza in Lexington

If you have had a long day and do not feel like cooking lunch or dinner, ordering food at your house is a great way to take a load off and relax. The best food to order? Pizza! The best place in Lexington to order pizza from? Salerno Woodfired Pizza and Taphouse! Salerno is a delicious restaurant with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options!

Salerno has all the classics of an Italian restaurant; pasta, calzones, and pizza! With a build your option, customers can pick and choose what they want from a variety of toppings. Salerno also has fun specialties with even more fun names like the Hot Mess (ricotta, mozzarella, bacon, jalepeños, caramelized onions, and garlic) and the Fat Dragon (tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, Italian sausage, roasted tomatoes, and peppers).

Lastly, Salerno has modern twists on old classics. For example, take their Honey BBQ Chicken pizza, with a honey bourbon BBQ sauce, grilled glazed chicken, bacon, and onions. It is nothing like a standard BBQ chicken pizza and it is awesome!

Best Takeout Pizza in Lexington

If takeout pizza is more your style and you find yourself in Lexington, then you should check out Frank's Pizza and Subs. Plus, Frank's Pizza and Subs has two locations, one in Lexington and one in Fairfield so you can get yummy pizza in either town! Frank's Pizza and Subs is a great place to get classic pizzeria food.

From traditional pizzas to calzones to sub sandwiches, Frank's has it all. Frank's specializes in traditional pizza styles, with toppings of the customers' choice and standard ingredients. Frank's is a classic pizzeria.

Frank also has tasty side dishes that can complete your meal, such as side salads, full-size salads, traditional Italian antipasto, french fries, chicken wings, and more! If you have a sweet tooth, they sell cannolis! If you are over 21, they sell beer pitchers, bottles and mugs, wine, draft beer!

Best Pizza Near Lexington

Buena Vista

In Buena Vista, a bit of a drive due East of Lexington, you will find the pizzeria Original Italian Restaurant. This small and cute restaurant is a perfect place to grab a bite to eat. It is a true hidden gem in Buena Vista and locals love it. It has a darling atmosphere with friendly staff, tasty food, and overall great vibes! They have delicious pizza and other classic Italian dishes.

Clifton Forge

If you find yourself pretty far outside of Lexington, you might stumble across Bella's Pizza Pasta and Subs in Clifton Forge, Virginia. Fans of this pizzeria rave about the fresh ingredients, amazing flavors, and super friendly wait staff. Customers love the calzones and pizzas, which are made to order and always fresh! It is a great place to have lunch or dinner and enjoy some good food!


In Mechanicsville, about a 20-minute drive due East of Lexington, you will find 360 Pizzeria, voted the best pizza in their area! They offer lunch specials from 11 am to 3 pm and have a build your pizza option, specialty pies, side dishes, and a gluten-free menu! Plus, they have a kids menu that is sure to have something for even the pickiest kids!

show more iconSee More


Slicechevron right iconVirginiachevron right icon Pizza Places in Lexington, VA