Middleton, known as The Good Neighbor City, is a small town with rich history, located in Dane County in Wisconsin. Featuring many nature parks, museums, and many bars and pubs, this city represents a tourist attraction to many Americans. Another thing that makes Middleton such a frequented place by tourists is a large number of breweries and distilleries, where you can taste great beer or wine and learn more about the process of making them.

For more than 50 years, Middleton has celebrated neighborly spirit by hosting the annual Good Neighbor Festival during the summer. This is the perfect chance for locals to gather and enjoy good food, live music, carnival rides, and welcome new citizens to the city. However, if you are traveling here during the rest of the year, be assured that you will still find unique places to have fun exploring outstanding dishes. There are plenty of Italian and American restaurants in the area that serve delicious pizza, pasta, burgers, and anything else you could possibly crave.

Middleton is Known for Neapolitan Pizza

Although Naples is nowhere close to Middleton, locals seem to adore this authentic Italian pizza and always prefer it over the classic American pizza types. Neapolitan pizza has a thin and crispy dough puffed up around the sides. It also uses traditional raw San Marzano tomato sauce with a specific tanginess, fresh mozzarella cheese, and basil. Once out of the oven, it gets a drizzle of olive oil, so it’s no wonder Neapolitan pizza is a top choice among Middleton locals.

Neapolitan pizza is usually made up of very few ingredients. As a result, it is typically served without any other toppings that could take from the intense flavor of the sauce. This basic form of Neapolitan pizza with tomato sauce and cheese is a Margherita pizza. Many pizzerias in Middletown have left their mark on this old-fashioned Italian recipe by adding various toppings and sauce, therefore giving the Neapolitan pizza a welcome twist.

Best Delivery Pizza in Middleton

Established in 2005, Roman Candle Pizzeria is a family-run restaurant that has gained popularity thanks to their hand-tossed dough baked in a deck oven. They cover the dough in homemade tomato sauce, exquisite meats from nearby farms, fresh cheeses, and locally-sourced vegetables. All of Roman Candle Pizzeria’s menu items are entirely made from scratch to make sure you get the best dining experience in the city of Middleton.

Locals are thrilled about Roman Candle Pizzeria’s dishes, considering it is one of the best pizza places in town. The Cheese Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza are made according to the classic New York-style pizza recipe. At the same time, the Chicken and Spinach Pizza uses grilled chicken bites, fresh spinach, and mozzarella to create a healthier alternative. If you want to spice things up a bit, try out the beloved Algo Malo Pizza, as It contains caramelized onions, walnuts, beets, garlic, blue cheese, and arugula. It may sound like a weird combination of toppings, but the taste will not disappoint and will have you coming back for more.

Best Takeout Pizza in Middleton

Villa Dolce is known for bringing something new to Middleton and standing out from other basic restaurants in the area. For more than 16 years, Villa Dolce has offered locals authentic Italian pizza made using their traditional recipe. As the pizzeria’s owners were born and raised in Italy, they know what separates a great Italian pizza from a regular one. T and high-quality milk to make the creamiest gelato you have ever tried.

The restaurant’s atmosphere is also out of the ordinary. It has a beautifully decorated and relaxing interior, where you can unwind with family or friends after a long stressful day. It’s not a bad spot to wait for your takeout order, either. One of the most popular pizzas on Villa Dolce’s menu is the Shrimp & Goat Cheese Pizza. It is a tasty blend of cilantro marinated shrimp, roasted tomatoes, and peppers caramelized onions, as well as goat cheese and fresh mozzarella. Another must-try dish is the Wild Mushroom Pizza, made with mushrooms, garlic, rosemary, and chianti demi-glaze.

Best Pizza Near Middleton

Madison

The state capital of Wisconsin, Madison, is a quintessential city that features five beautiful lakes and a lot of nature parks. There are plenty of outdoor activities and water sports for tourists to try. On this note, you can also find many high-quality restaurants that offer waterfront dining.

Salvatore’s Tomato Pies is a very popular pizzeria in Madison, loved for its pizza with unique topping combinations that always taste delicious. Some of the most popular items on their menu are the Fig and Bacon Pizza, El Mapache Loco Pizza, and the Carbonara Pizza.

Waunakee

Waunakee is a small village in Dane County, also known as The Only Waunakee in the World. It was incorporated in 1893, and nowadays, it is a popular tourist destination for those who want to enjoy nature at one of the many parks or beaches.

Looking for New York-style pizza in Waunakee? Then Zoe’s Pizzeria is the place for you. Their Mac & Cheese Pizza is a local favorite, along with the classic Pepperoni Pizza and Margherita Pizza.

Verona

Verona is a small city located southwest of downtown Madison, famous for its many nature trails, brewing companies, and wineries. As the place features a lot of parks, Verona is a great town for families.

Sugar River Pizza is one of the most popular restaurants in the area, thanks to its thin-crust pizza topped with fresh ingredients. The most ordered items on their menu are the Taco Pizza, Asian Chicken Pizza, and Amazon Pizza.