Milwaukee’s history of Italian immigration dates as far back as the Civil War era. The largest influx of Italian immigration came from Sicily around the 1890s and with it, came the rich Italian culture and cuisine from which pizza has developed throughout the years into what it is now - a long-standing family favorite!
Here in Milwaukee, pizza is so deeply loved and in such high demand with locals well-versed in the variety of creative options found here, that they made their own style.
The simple yet perfect Milwaukee-style pizza consists of a thin style crust topped with the ultimate trio of toppings: sausage, mushroom, and onion.
A creation so delicious it is a favorite amongst locals, and once you try it, it will no doubt be a favorite of yours too! Expertly made by a number of highly reviewed pizzerias, the only thing left to do is get stuck in!
If time is of the essence and you can't wait to get your hands on and sink your teeth into a delicious slice of pizza, then Beto's Pizza is the place for you. With the fastest delivery of any pizzeria in Milwaukee along with a 5-star rating, it doesn't get much better than this. This pizzeria features a wide array of pizza styles and topping options, ranging from classic and simple to flavor-packed. Beto’s Pizza has a range of options to suit anyone’s palette including the option to build your own if somehow nothing else has caught your eye. But with creations such as the Aztec Pizza, topped with pepperoni, shrimp, bacon, and jalapenos, the chance of that is very slim.
Coming in as Milwaukee’s Favourite pizzeria, Zaffiro’s Pizza and Bar comes highly acclaimed. Family run by Sicilian Immigrants since their opening in the 1950s, their top quality thin-crust pies have become a statement piece of the pizza scene in Milwaukee. Here the favorite toppings remain classic and perfected throughout the ages - the best trio combination of sausage, onion, and mushroom. While this is a popular option found in almost any pizzeria you may find yourself in while in Milwaukee, no one does it quite as well as Zaffiro’s- now offering delivery or curbside pickup.
Although harboring a smaller population, Milwaukee’s neighboring city Wauwatosa also favors the classic Milwaukee-style pizza, adorned with the favorite trio of sausage, onion, and mushrooms. However, classic does not mean boring for this city. And their most highly reviewed restaurant ‘Balistreri’s Italian/ American Ristorante’ features several flavor-packed gut buster menu options! For example, the appropriately named Everything but the Kitchen Sink comes topped with…. Well, almost everything. Another decadent option includes The Works, a delicious mix of sausage, mozzarella cheese, olives, onions, green peppers, and pepperoni. Leaving Wauwatosa with an empty stomach sure seems like a tricky task!
Running in south Milwaukee since 1963, ‘Barbiere’s Italian Inn’ comes highly recommended and reviewed. Opened by Sal Barbiere, this restaurant continues to be family-run with the simple family value of ‘Family, superb food and quality ingredients’. And their home-style pizzas sure live up to that promise. With options to fit any time of day including: Luncheon- half portion pizza. A La Carte- full portion pizza Dinner – full portion coming with a side of minestrone soup or small antipasto salad and an ice cream. All pizzas come with a side of their delicious famous garlic bread as well as all the toppings your heart desires.
Oak Creek is home to just over 36,000 people. It’s not hard to find a pizza lover or two among that crowd! The crowd in question has deemed Trattoria Di Carlo as their favorite pizzeria, showering this establishment in positive reviews into the near thousands. And it is no surprise why. Making all their pizzas from scratch, including gluten-free options, this restaurant is a formidable choice. Offering a great selection of toppings, sauces, and crust style, this build-your-own pizza is made by the best. The options are endless. Opt for the classic Di Carlo pizza sauce, or something more spicy like their buffalo or pink sauce. Regardless of choice, all are sure to leave your pizza packed with flavor, paired perfectly with Chef Carlo’s special selection of salami, prosciutto, and provolone cheese for the extra dash of perfection.
Q: 🍕What restaurant features the best deep dish style pizza in Milwaukee WI?
Q: 🍕What place provides the best stuffed pizza in Milwaukee WI?
Q: 🍕Where can the best thin crust pizza be found in Milwaukee WI?
Q: 🍕What restaurant features the best veggie-style pizza in Milwaukee WI?