What one would expect is that the folks in Watertown would be more inclined towards New England pizza (commonly known as Greek pizza) because the early settlers in the city were from this region. However, that’s not the case. On the contrary, the folks here are among those won over by the allure of New York pizza, making this style of pizza the one they fancy above all others. Don’t be alarmed if you hear them refer to their New York-style pizza as cheese pizza – it’s the adopted name here. Like any other New York-style pizza, the crust is generally thin – even though it’s thicker on the edges than at the core – and can be enjoyed on the go. The crispy and chewy pie also features tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, as well as plenty of toppings. In other words, you’ll get classic NY pie here that lives up to the reputation and taste.

Best Delivery Pizza in Watertown

One restaurant stands out among all the pizzerias in Watertown when anyone wants pizza delivered to them in the city and that’s no other than Rosati’s Pizza on Market Way. In fact, the pizza place is a household name in the city with their prompt delivery, delicious pizza combos, and consistent service excellence. Everyone that loves pizza in the city knows this and is proud of the team at the restaurant. From the food – which is cooked by experienced chefs with fresh and high-quality ingredients – to the quick delivery which means you never have to wait long before you can have your meal, Rosati’s has set the standard of what pizza delivery should be in the city. They have pie options too so you can go for thin-crust pies, gluten-free pies, deep-dish pizza, or double dough. Place an order for one of your choosing on Slice right away.

Best Takeout Pizza in Watertown

Takeout pizza doesn’t come any better than what you’ll get at Phil’s Pizza Palace in Watertown. When you arrive at the restaurant the first time, there’s a very good chance you’ll be deceived into thinking it’s just another regular pizza joint because of how small and cozy the place looks, but don’t be fooled. The pie that comes out of that pizzeria is top-drawer stuff. Takeout regulars here never have a bad meal, no matter how simple or complicated their order is because the team always pays attention to every detail in your order so as to truly satisfy them. In case you don’t have a favorite meal here and want to give it a shot, you should go for any of these two popular pies – House Special Pizza or Everything Special Pizza. From the moment you pick up your order and head out, you’ll know you’re in for a treat. Prepare to grab a bite in your car.

Best Pizza Near Watertown

Johnson Creek

One of the first settlers in the village of Johnson Creek was the same person that founded Watertown – Timothy Johnson – however, this village was named after the creek where it’s located. The community is popular as “The Crossroads with a Future” and has good spots for relaxation and nature observation. As for the pizza, you’ll get top-of-the-line pies at Pine Cone Travel Pizza – the type that will keep reminding you of the time you spent in the village.

Oconomowoc

If you’re looking for delish pizza in Oconomowoc, head over to Summit Avenue and locate Rocky Rococo Pizza & Pasta for the best pies in the city. Besides the amazing pie, you’ll find here, there’s room for good recreation too, especially if you’re here with your bike because bike trails abound in the area. Still, there’s room for other activities, so you can go hiking or visit the city’s museum and galleries to learn about its history.

Lake Mills

Arrive in Lake Mills ready for a good adventure because you’ll have you fill here with family and friends, especially as there are plenty of spots for you to visit. Depending on your interests, you can kickstart your day by visiting the Aztalan State Park, the Glacial Drumlin State Trail, Lewis Station Winery, or the historic Lake Mills Golf Club. When it’s pizza time here, the place to go is Timber Creek Pizza Co on East Lake Street.