You will always get a well-prepared pizza anytime you order on Slice from one of the many New York-style pizzerias in Martinsburg. The town has renowned pizzerias which have served the residents with tasty pizzerias for decades. The style was introduced in the mid 20th century by Italian immigrants and New York visitors who found Martinsburg as a good place to settle and start a pizza business. New York-style pizza is a thin crust pizza which is served best with just cheese or cheese and pepperoni. The crust should be hand-tossed and restaurants get extra points if they are tossed in the air with flair. The style is a variation on Neapolitan-style pizza that was started in New York by Italian immigrants in the early 1900s. It’s this delicious pizza that is now popular around the country and worldwide.

Best Delivery Pizza in Martinsburg, West Virginia

King's New York Pizza – Martinsburg is a classic Italian restaurant offering tasty New York-style pizza and other dishes. Serving Martinsburg since 1998, the family-owned pizzeria shares the Colandrea family’s recipes and traditions with the restaurant diners. The sauce is a secret recipe that has been passed down through generations. King’s New York Pizza has a large list of pizza specialties, the ultimate of which is the King Kong Stuffed Pizza with sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and ground beef. The Cheese Steak Pizza is also popular with mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, and, of course, steak. In addition to New York-style pizza, they serve Sicilian pizza, cauliflower crust pizza, and gluten-free pizza. The strombolis and hot subs are an ideal companion to one of their salads or soups.

Best Takeout Pizza in Martinsburg, West Virginia

The Pizza Shop is one of the best places to enjoy a delicious takeout pizza in Martinsburg. This pizzeria is especially great for vegetarian options. For instance, you can choose the sauceless White Pizza with mozzarella, parmesan, and ricotta. If the white pizza doesn't work well, you can order the Veggie Pizza which has tomato sauce and more toppings of tomatoes, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and olives. No matter what pizza you order from The Pizza Shop, your tastebuds will be happy. If you are someone who has trouble making up their mind, the appetizer sampler is ideal. With nuggets, mozzarella sticks, wings, and onion rings, you get to try it all. When you swing by to pick up your takeout order, it will be ready on time and be hot and fresh. The staff are pleasant and efficient and the prices here won’t break the bank.

Best Pizza Near Martinsburg

Falling Waters

Ovidio's New York Pizza has served Falling Waters residents for many years with delectable New York-style thin crust pizzas at reasonable rates. Their gourmet pizza selections are plentiful and feature vegetarian delights like Ovidio’s Garden Pizza and carnivore creations like the Pepperoni Lovers Pizza. You can also enjoy appetizers and a kid’s menu here.

Ranson

When you are in Ranson, you should order from Andy's Pizza. The pizzeria uses a wood-fired oven to prepare its pizza and you can get your pizza by delivery or takeout. You can get an individual cheese slice or splurge with one of their tasty whole pies. Andy's Pizza also offers breaded wings, burgers, desserts, and salads.

Inwood

King’s Pizza Pronto has served Inwood residents with delectable Margherita and white pizzas since 2019, so it’s relatively new. It has quickly earned repeat business due to its amazing food. Opt to build your own pizza or choose one of their specialties like the Meat Lovers or Buffalo Chicken Pizza. To round out their menu, you’ll find options for appetizers, wings, and tantalizing desserts.