Nick's Italian

1100 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Currently ClosedFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Nick's Italian a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

New York style pies.
  • Cheese Pizza$14.75
    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
  • One Topping Pizza$15.75
  • Two Toppings Pizza$16.75
  • Margherita Pie$17.75
    Marinated tomato, fresh mozzarella, torn basil, breadcrumbs.
  • The “Don” Pie$19.25
    Spicy soppresatta, genoa salami, prosciutto, roasted piquillos, pepperoncini salad.
  • Hawaiian Pie$18.75
    Ham, fresh pineapple, béchamel, jalapeño.
  • Arugula Pie$17.75
    Caramelized onion, fontina, arugula, tomatoes, balsamic.
  • Local Sausage Pie$18.75
    Peperonata, calabrese chilies, fontina cheese, herbed goat cheese, spinach.
  • The Greek Pie$18.75
    Salami, shaved romaine, feta, olives, tomato, red onion.
  • Crispy Calamari Pie$18.75
    Tomato sauce, mozzarella, arugula, cherry pepper aioli.
  • Crispy Eggplant Pie$17.75
    Ricotta, spicy tomato sauce, basil, parmesan.
  • Wild Mushroom Pie$19.00
    Béchamel, herbed goat cheese, Brussel sprouts, black truffle oil.
  • The T.C. Pie$18.75
    Rock shrimp, pineapple, garlic, cilantro, pickled Fresno.
  • The DAK Pie$18.50
    Ham, gruyere, béchamel, rosemary, shaved red onion.
  • Pesto Chicken Pie$18.75
    Pesto, chicken, sundried-tomato, fontina, kalamata.
  • Bronx Bomber Pie$19.25
    Caramelized onion, béchamel, two types of pepperoni, chive.
  • The Baller Pie$18.75
    Meatballs, rapini, crispy onion rings.
  • Gluten Free Cheese$11.00
    Udi’s (Denver) gluten-free pizza crust, add toppings from D.I.Y.
  • Risotto Al Pomodoro$17.75
    Tomato confit, goat butter, crispy garlic, add crispy prosciutto.
  • Ricotta Gnocchi$12.25 +
    Meat sauce, pecorino.
  • Rock Shrimp$14.25 +
    House-made cavatelli, zucchini, heirloom tomato.
  • Bucatini Carbonara$11.75 +
    Pecorino, bacon, mint.
  • Torchio A La Vodka$14.25 +
    Grilled chicken, tomato basil cream, zucchini.
  • Frito Misto$10.75
    Green beans, cauliflower, zucchini, lemon aioli.
  • Fried Mozzarella$9.25
    Fresh mozzarella, marinara.
  • Crispy Calamari$10.75
    Cherry bomb butter & aioli.
  • Chicken Wings$10.75
    Agrodolce, garlic salt.
  • Meats & Cheese$11.75
    Italian meats, cheeses, giardiniera.
  • Burrata Caprese$10.75
    Oven dried tomatoes, basil, pesto, Saba.
  • Brussels Sprouts “Caesar”$8.75
  • Mushroom Arancini$9.75
    Fontina, celery, truffle aiöli.
  • House Salad$6.75 +
    Market greens, garbanzos, onion, italian dressing.
  • Caesar Salad$6.75 +
    Romaine, croutons, parmesan.
  • Greek Salad$7.25 +
    Cucumber, feta, kalamatas, onion, greek dressing.
  • Kale Salad$12.75
    Pinenuts, pecorino, currants, lemon vinegar.
  • Apple Salad$12.75
    Gorgonzola, watercress, celery, candied pecans.
  • Meatballs$6.25
  • Italian Sausage$5.75
  • Parmesan Fries$4.75
  • Sauteed Zucchini$4.75
  • Garlicky Green Beans$4.50
  • House Made Giardiniera$3.50
  • Garlic Bread$3.50
    With marinara.
Gluten-free option is available.
  • Marinara Pasta$10.25
    Choose spaghetti, penne rigati, or bucatini.
  • Bolognese Pasta$14.50
    Choose spaghetti, penne rigati, or bucatini.
  • Fresh Pesto Pasta$12.75
    Choose spaghetti, penne rigati, or bucatini.
  • ACG Pasta$12.75
    Choose spaghetti, penne rigati, or bucatini.
  • Nick’s Burger$13.25
    Co grass-fed, aged cheddar, parmesan fries, special sauce.
  • Chicken Scallopini$16.75
    Choose marsala or picatta with orzo, spinach.
  • Pork Chop Milanese$18.75
    Lemon-butter sauce.
  • N.Y. Steak$26.75
    Chianti sauce, plus choose one side: parmesan fries, pasta, garlicky green beans, sauteed zucchini.
  • Porchetta$17.75
    Creamy polenta & rapini. Only available on Saturdays.
  • Spaghetti & Meatballs$14.75
  • Lasagna$16.00
    Braised meat, spinach, ricotta.
  • Chicken Parmesan$16.75
    Spaghetti marinara.
  • Eggplant Parmesan$15.75
    Spaghetti marinara.
  • Braised Lamb$17.75
    Cavatelli, rapini, herbed ricotta, lemon oil.
  • Rock Shrimp Scampi$18.75
    Linguini, lemon, butter, basil, baby heirlooms.
  • Nick’s Tiramisu$6.75
  • Skillet Cookie A La Mode$7.25
  • Affogato$5.75
  • Gelato$5.75
    Salted caramel, pistachio, vanilla.
  • Sorbet$5.75
  • Soda$1.95
    Coca Cola, Diet Coke, Dr. Pepper, Ginger Ale, Barq’s root beer, Fanta Orange.
  • San Pellegrino Sparkling Water$3.00
  • Acqua Panna Natural Spring Water$3.00
  • San Pellegrino Aranciato Rossa$2.50
    Blood orange.
  • Limonata$2.50
  • Homemade Strawberry Lemonade$2.50
  • Iced Tea$1.95
  • Lunch Special Pizza$10.00
    Salad, slice and a drink.
  • Lunch By The Slice Pizza$5.00
    Cheese, vegetable, pepperoni.
  • Make It A Double$9.75
    2 slices & soda.
  • Lunch Garlic Bread$2.25
    With marinara.
  • Lunch Crispy Calamari$10.50
    Cherry bomb butter & aioli.
  • Lunch Burrata$10.75
    Oven-dried tomatoes, basil pesto, Saba.
  • Lunch House Salad$8.75
    Market greens, garbanzos, onion, italian dressing.
  • Lunch Italian Salad$9.00
    Market greens, garbanzos, onion, italian dressing.
  • Lunch Caesar Salad$9.50
    Romaine, croutons, parmesan.
  • Lunch Greek Salad$9.50
    Cucumber, feta, kalamatas, onion, greek dressing.
  • Lunch Kale Salad$13.00
    Pinenuts, pecorino, currants, lemon vinaigrette.
  • Lunch Chicken Scallopini Salad$12.50
    Lemon butter sauce, fennel, and citrus salad.
With Zapp’s chips.
  • Lunch Italian Grinder$11.25
    Ham, salami, cappicola, provolone, banana peppers.
  • Lunch Sausage & Peppers Grinder$11.25
    Pepperonata, provolone.
  • Lunch Meatball Grinder$11.25
    Buffalo mozzarella, marinaria, basil pesto.
  • Lunch Caprese Grinder$11.25
    Tomato, buffalo mozzarella, pesto mayo.
  • Lunch Eggplant Parmesan Grinder$11.25
    Mozzarella, marinara.
  • Lunch Nick’s Burger$11.25
    CO grass-fed, aged cheddar, special sauce, parmesan fries.
  • Lunch Chicken Parmesan$12.00
  • Lunch Eggplant Parmesan$11.25
  • Lunch Lasagna$13.25 +
  • Lunch Pasta Marinara$8.75
  • Lunch Pasta Pesto$9.00
  • Lunch Pasta with Meat Sauce$10.75


SliceRestaurants in Fort Collins Nick's Italian
Price: $$