My Pi Pizza

Thin Crust Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$11.75

Stuffed Spinach Souffle Pizza

Our lighter version of fresh chopped baby spinach & mozzarella filling with a touch of onion & basil between two delicious crusts.

$19.65

Deep Dish Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$13.00

My Pie Special Pizza

Sausage or pepperoni or spinach with mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.

$17.15

Hawaiian Pizza

A classic combination! Kretchmar’s hickory smoked ham and pineapple with My Pie’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, & grated Romano cheese.

$15.35

Chicken Pesto Pizza

Slow-roasted all-natural chicken breast chunks, fresh baby spinach, My Pie’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Romano, & a fresh homemade basil-pesto drizzled on top.

$15.80

Hawaiian Deep Dish Pizza

Sausage or pepperoni or spinach with mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.A classic combination! Kretchmar’s hickory smoked ham and pineapple with My Pie’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, & grated Romano cheese.

$16.80

My Pie Special Deep Dish Pizza

Sausage or pepperoni or spinach with mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.

$18.70

Chicken Pesto Deep Dish Pizza

Slow-roasted all-natural chicken breast chunks, fresh baby spinach, My Pie’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Romano, & a fresh homemade basil-pesto drizzled on top.

$17.25

Four Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella, provolone, bleu cheese, & Romano with a basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust.

$14.75

Modern ART Pizza

Fresh tomato, artichoke, garlic & mozzarella with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust.

$17.15

Sun Dried Tomato Pizza

Sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, provolone, & Romano cheese with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust.

$15.25

My Pie Mozzarella Garlic Bread

Baked with creamy whipped butter, fresh garlic, and stuffed with mozzarella cheese.

$6.25

Spicy Garlic Bread

Our open-faced cheesy garlic bread with a spice to it!

$3.50

Miss Vickie's BBQ

$1.50

Miss Vickie's Jalapeno

$1.50

Miss Vickie's Salt & Vinegar

$1.50

Miss Vickie's Sea Salt

$1.50

Soup of the Day

Please call the restaurant for today's selection.

$3.45

Shrimp & Sweet Potato Chowder Soup

Served every Friday. A Li'l Guys original Classic shrimp chowder with real chunks of shrimp in a creamy broth with sweet potato & cayenne pepper, bacon & sherry.

$3.95

Dinner Salad

Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing.

$4.50

Caesar Salad

Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing.

$7.25

Chicken Caesar Salad

Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing.

$10.25

Mandarin Orange Salad

Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette.

$9.75

Cobb Salad

Tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing.

$9.75

Chef's Salad

Homemade slow-roasted turkey, Kretschmar's hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing.

$9.75

Traditional Potato Salad

Our special version of the classic made with Hellmann’s mayo, Dijon mustard, fresh hard-boiled eggs & crisp celery.

$2.85

Pasta Salad

Tri-color rotini, aged balsamic vinaigrette, feta, kalamata olives, & red onions.

$2.85

Pesto Penne

Our best seller! Penne with a fresh basil pesto, mozzarella, & sun-dried tomatoes.

$2.85

Build Your Own Grand Daddy Sandwich

*we carefully prepare gluten free sandwiches, but please be aware that “gluten-free bread sandwiches” are prepared in a non-gluten free environment.

$8.50

Ruebenesque Sandwich

Our own home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket with sauerkraut, 1000 Island dressing, and Swiss cheese baked on rye.

$11.50

Baked Turkonator Sandwich

Turkonator with Swiss cheese.

$9.95

Ultimate Homemade Rueben Sandwich

Only on fridays & saturdays. The first sandwich made with homemade-from-scratch, baked-to-order bread. That’s right! We bake the bread when you place your order with the best homemade corned beef, bavarian sauerkraut, & swiss cheese. 1000 island on the side.

$11.95

Chicken Caesar Florentine Sandwich

Roasted chicken breast topped with spinach & mozzarella, baked on tomato focaccia with Caesar dressing.

$9.75

TKRB Sandwich

Homemade turkey & roast beef with Swiss & cheddar baked on French bread with LTO and thousand island.

$9.95

Hot Ham & Swiss Sandwich

Kretschmar’s hickory-smoked ham with Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & Hellmann’s Mayo on French bread.

$9.25

Tuna Melt Sandwich

Solid white albacore tuna salad-ized with Hellmann's mayo topped with cheddar on French bread.

$9.95

Baked Turkonator Sandwich

Turkonator with Swiss cheese.

$9.95

The Turkonator Sandwich

Turkey breast with LTO, and homemade honey mustard sandwiched on French bread.

$9.25

Pesto Turkey Sandwich

Turkey breast, LTO, provolone cheese, pesto-mayo served on tomato-focaccia.

$9.95

Damen Avenue Club Sandwich

Turkey breast with bacon, munster cheese, LTO, and mayo on French bread.

$10.95

Beefaholic Sandwich

Homecooked roast beef with Dijon, lettuce, and red onion on French bread.

$9.25

Beef & Swiss Sandwich

Slow-roasted choice bottom round with horseradish sauce, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and red onions on French bread.

$9.95

The Perfect Corner Sandwich

Double portion of our home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket on rye with Dijon.

$10.75

Corned Beef a Liscious Sandwich

Home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket with LTO, 1000 island on French.

$10.75

An American Ham Sandwich

Kretschmar’s hickory-smoked ham, with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & Hellmann’s mayo on our Hawaiian bread.

$9.25

Chuckie's Delight Sandwich

Solid white albacore tuna with Hellmann's Mayo on multi-grain wheat with lettuce and tomato, sorry Charlie!

$9.25

Egg Salad a Rama Sandwich

Light & fluffy egg salad on our Hawaiian bread with lettuce, tomato & red onions.

$8.50

Chicken Salad a Rama Sandwich

Our slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, walnuts, LTO and, of course, Hellmann’s mayo on Hawaiian bread.

$8.50

Chicken Focaccia Sandwich

Roasted chicken breast with a pesto-mayo, mozzarella, LTO on tomato focaccia.

$9.75

The Franco Italian Sandwich

Genoa salami with provolone on French bread with spicy giardiniera, balsamic vinaigrette, lettuce, tomato & red onions.

$9.75

The Porker Sandwich

Kretschmar’s ham, Genoa salami & pepperoni with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & balsamic vinaigrette on French bread.

$9.75

Veg o Rama Sandwich

Cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese & hummus on wheat bread.

$8.50

Lil Guy Turkey Breast Sandwich

With homemade honey/dijon mustard. Grade A natural turkey breasts.

$2.75

Lil Guy Roast Beef Sandwich

With Dijon, tender, homemade & slow-roasted choice flat bottom round.

$2.75

Lil Guy Corned Beef Sandwich

With Dijon. Cured in store for 7 days, slowly cooked for 12 hours.

$3.30

Lil Guy Salami Sandwich

With Dijoin. Genoa aged salami.

$2.55

Lil Guy Ham Sandwich

With Hellmann's mayo. Kretschmar's smoked.

$2.55

Lil Guy Tuna Salad Sandwich

Simple and superb, made with solid white albacore, the best! Tossed with Helmann's mayonnaise.

$2.75

Lil Guy Chicken Salad Sandwich

Slow-roasted chicken breast with granny smith apples, nuts & mayo.

$2.55

Lil Guy Egg Salad Sandwich

Gently tossed so it’s devilishly tasty.

$2.55

Garlic Bread

Baked with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, and stuffed with vegan mozzarella cheese.

$7.00

Vegan Delight Sandwich

Sriracha hummus, fresh mushrooms, cucumbers, spinach, carrots, tomato & red onion on 9-grain bread.

$8.50

Build Your Own Sandwich

$8.50

Vegan Orange Salad

Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette.

$4.95

Spinach Special Thin Crust Pizza

Fresh spinach, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$19.95

Sausage Special Thin Crust Pizza

Vegan sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$20.95

Thin Crust Make Your Own Pizza

Start with a vegan cheese pizza and add any additional vegan ingredients you'd like.

$13.75

Spinach Special Deep Dish Pizza

Fresh spinach, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$21.95

Sausage Special Deep Dish Pizza

Vegan sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$22.95

Deep Dish Make Your Own Pizza

Start with a vegan cheese pizza and add any additional vegan ingredients you'd like.

$15.00

Kid's PB & J Lil' Guy

$0.95

Kid's Toasted Cheese Lil' Guy

$0.95

Kid's Milk

2% milk.

$2.15

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$1.95

Peanut Butter Cookies

$1.95

Brownies

$3.25

Cheesecake

$4.50

Chef Richie's Chocolate Insanity

5 different chocolate confections in one: 1) flourless chocolate cake with 2) a chocolate truffle filling, 3) coated in a chocolate ganache 4) surrounded by a semi-sweet chocolate tower, and 5) drizzled with white chocolate.

$10.95

Strawberry Banana Smoothie

Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.

$4.75

Strawberry Blueberry Smoothie

Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.

$5.25

Strawberry Raspberry Smoothie

Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.

$5.25

Blueberry Banana Smoothie

Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.

$5.25

Peach Banana Smoothie

Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.

$4.75

Mango Banana Smoothie

Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.

$4.75

Make Your Own Smoothie

Pick 2 fruits & a juice.

$4.75

Soda

$1.52

San Pellegrino Blood Orange

$2.21

San Pellegrino Grapefruit

$2.21

Soft Drinks

$3.92

Sprecher's

Choice of rootbeer, cream soda, orange dream.

$2.31

Boylan's Black Cherry

$2.27

Apple Juice

$2.20

Pomegranate Cherry Juice

$2.20

Water

$1.45