Skip to main content
Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett

Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett

105 N Randolph St, Garrett, IN 46738
260-264-9519
New
Closed
pizza-your-way
Pizza Your Way

One Topping Pizza

Our homemade pizza dough rolled and covered with our special pizza sauce. Select thin and crispy or hand tossed thick crust.

$11.00

One Topping Pizza

Two Topping Pizza

$12.00

Two Topping Pizza

Three Topping Pizza

$13.00

Three Topping Pizza

Add Chicago style medium

Make it Chicago-style double crust.

$4.00


Add large Chicago style

Make it Chicago-style double crust.

$5.00

carnival-treats
Carnival Treats
Our Carnival Treats are perfect to satisfy those late-night sweet tooth cravings we all get from time to time :)

Elephant Ear

12" homemade dough rolled and smothered with butter, brown sugar, and cinnamon then baked to golden crispy brown and topped with your choice of chocolate syrup, Raspberry syrup, or both!

$4.99

Elephant Ear

Sicilian Cannoli

Our house Cannoli hand filled with a decadent and smooth slightly sweet and creamy filling made from ricotta cheese.

$4.95

Sicilian Cannoli

Double Chocolate Chip Cookie

An incredible fresh baked double chocolate chop cookie.

$0.75

Double Chocolate Chip Cookie
pizza
Pizza
Homemade dough & sauce. 100% mozzarella cheese. Gluten friendly pizza available on Medium thin crust only.

Deluxe Pizza

A blend of the finest ingredients found anywhere in the world. This mouth watering pizza is loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives & mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzarella cheese and you've got the pizza everyone will love.

$15.79


Railroader Pizza

A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The All Meat Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese. Great for the serious meat lover!

$15.79


The Vegetarian Pizza

The healthy escape to pizza. Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers, plum ripe tomatoes all covered with a generous portion of pure mozzarella cheese. Banana and jalapeno peppers upon request.

$15.79


Timmy's Train Wreck BBQ Pizza

The ultimate BBQ pizza! Hickory smoked pulled pork, sweet banana peppers, onions, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

$15.79


The Cowboy Pizza

The western specialty pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.

$15.79


BBQ Chicken Pizza

Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet BBQ sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese round out this culinary masterpiece that's sure to addict even the slightest chicken enthusiast!

$15.79


Timmy's Buffalo Style Pizza

If you like hot you're going to love our most popular spicy dish. Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses. It's guaranteed to keep the taste buds awake!

$15.79


Crazy Dough Two Topping Pizza

Pizza for one made delicious! This single serving pizza is like a snowflake, no two are ever the same. Actual shape and size may vary, but load these little guys up with your choice of toppings and results are always the same, the best individual pizza on the planet!

$6.49


Crazy Dough Specialty Pizza

Pizza for one made delicious! This single serving pizza is like a snowflake, no two are ever the same. Actual shape and size may vary, but load these little guys up with your choice of toppings and results are always the same, the best individual pizza on the planet!

$7.49

chicago-style-pizza
Chicago Style Pizza
Double crust & secret spice.

Deluxe Chicago Style Pizza

A blend of the finest ingredients found anywhere in the world. This mouth watering pizza is loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives & mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzarella cheese and you've got the pizza everyone will love.

$19.79


Railroader Chicago Style Pizza

A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The All Meat Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese. Great for the serious meat lover!

$19.79


The Vegetarian Chicago Style Pizza

The healthy escape to pizza. Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers, plum ripe tomatoes all covered with a generous portion of pure mozzarella cheese. Banana and jalapeno peppers upon request.

$19.79


Timmy's Train Wreck BBQ Chicago Style Pizza

The ultimate BBQ pizza! Hickory smoked pulled pork, sweet banana peppers, onions, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

$19.79


The Cowboy Chicago Style Pizza

The western specialty pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.

$19.79


BBQ Chicken Chicago Style Pizza

Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet BBQ sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese round out this culinary masterpiece that's sure to addict even the slightest chicken enthusiast!

$19.79


Timmy's Buffalo Style Chicago Style Pizza

If you like hot you're going to love our most popular spicy dish. Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses. It's guaranteed to keep the taste buds awake!

$19.79

appetizers
Appetizers

Garlic Bread with Cheese

Our fabulous homemade Italian white bread with garlic butter, cheese & Greek seasoning.

$3.99

Garlic Bread with Cheese

Crazy Dough with Cheese

Hand stretched pizza dough with garlic butter, cheese & Greek seasoning.

$3.99

Crazy Dough with Cheese
hickory-smoked-wings
Hickory Smoked Wings

Wings

Hickory smoked chicken wings with your choice of sauce.

$8.99

Wings
strombolis
Strombolis

Stromboli

Sausage, banana peppers, onions, cheese & pizza sauce. Baked on our fabulous homemade Italian white bread.

$6.99

Stromboli
rolls
Rolls

Sausage Roll

More than one gigantic foot of Italian sausage, juicy onions, and a mound of mozzarella cheese wrapped up in our freshest pizza dough. Served with our own BBQ sauce.

$9.99

Sausage Roll

Pizza Roll

Build your own treat with your choice of two of any of our delicious pizza toppings on the same fresh pizza dough, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$9.99

Pizza Roll
italian-submarines
Italian Submarines

Grinder

This irresistible sandwich is topped off with ham, salami, lettuce, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese & pizza sauce on our fabulous homemade Italian white bread. If you want a sandwich with tons of meat you will love our grinder.

$6.99

Grinder

Ham & Cheese Sub

Thin tender, juicy sandwich will fill your appetite. It is loaded with tender ham, mozzarella cheese & pizza sauce. Customize this tasty sandwich with additional fresh toppings for a small charge.

$6.99

Ham & Cheese Sub

Chicken Club Sandwich

Smoked chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes & ranch dressing.

$6.99


Timmy's Cordon Blu Sub

Smoked chicken, ham, bacon, mozzarella cheese & ranch dressing.

$6.99


Buffalo Chicken Sub

Smoked chicken smothered in buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, onions & ranch dressing.

$6.99

barbque
Bar-B-Que

Pulled Chicken BBQ Sandwich

$8.49


Pulled Pork Sandwich

$8.49


Texas Style Beef Brisket Sandwich

$9.49


Rib Tips

Make it a complete dinner with any 2 sides for an additional charge.

$9.99


Ribs, Ribs, Ribs!

Make it a complete dinner with any 2 sides for an additional charge.

$13.99


Pulled Pork Nachos

Nachos Chips covered with our national award winning BBQ pulled pork with onions, banana peppers, jalapeños, mozzarella and nacho cheese. 10/10 munchie certified!

$12.82

Pulled Pork Nachos
by-the-pound
By The Pound

Pulled Pork By The Pound

Our Hickory smoked pulled pork smothered in our national award-winning BBQ saucer

$13.99

Pulled Pork By The Pound

Pulled Chicken By The Pound

Our hickory-smoked chicken smothered in our national award-winning BBQ sauce.

$13.99

Pulled Chicken By The Pound

Beef Brisket By The Pound

Award winning Smoked BBQ beef brisket Delicious!

$17.99

Beef Brisket By The Pound
bbq-sauce-by-the-pint
BBQ sauce by the pint
1 pint of our National award-winning BBQ sauce

1 pint BBQ sauce

1 pint of our National award-winning BBQ sauce

$7.00

1 pint BBQ sauce
sides
Sides
Cole slaw potato salad chips apple sauce

Smoked Mac and Cheese

Smoked shells covered in our special blend of creamy cheese with bacon and ham. 4 oz cup

$2.00

Smoked Mac and Cheese

Coleslaw

A slightly tangy, rich coleslaw.

$1.50

Coleslaw

Potato Salad

Red skin Amish style potato salad

$1.50

Potato Salad
drinks
Drinks
Sodas and water

Pepsi can

1 can of Pepsi

$0.99

Pepsi can

Diet Pepsi

1 can Diet Pepsi

$0.99

Diet Pepsi

Mountain Dew

1 can Mountain Dew

$0.99

Mountain Dew
extras
Extras
Cups of BBQ sauce, Ranch Dressing, Garlic Butter, Blue Cheese, Pizza Sauce

BBQ Sauce

An individual serving cup of our made in house BBQ sauce.

$0.50

BBQ Sauce

Ranch Dressing

An individual serving cup of our creamy ranch dressing.

$0.50

Ranch Dressing

Garlic Butter

Our homemade garlic butter. This is not sauce. Our made in-house garlic butter is whipped creamy like butter.

$0.50

Garlic Butter

Blue Cheese

A creamy, rich blue cheese dressing.

$0.50

Blue Cheese

Pizza Sauce

Our special recipe pizza sauce

$0.92

Pizza Sauce
SliceINGarrett46738 Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett
Price: $$