Michael's Pastaria

143 Franklin Avenue, Nutley, NJ 07110

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Michael's Pastaria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Plain Cheese Pizza$8.75 +
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Sicilian Pizza$11.50 +
Famous Thinny Thin Pizza$8.75 +
Paper thin, well done, no crust with a crown of crispy cheese to the end.
Margherita Pizza$9.50 +
Fresh plum tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Michael's Pizza$11.95 +
Broccoli rabe, sausage, parmigiana and home-made mozzarella.
Gina Maria Pizza$11.25 +
Tomato sauce, home-made mozzarella, pamigiana, eggplant, spinach and garlic.
Special Mushroom Pizza$10.50 +
Fresh tomato, olive oil, portabella, white cap, shitaki, mozzarella and basil.
Puttanesca Pizza$10.25 +
Tomato sauce, home-made mozzarella, parmigiana, capers.
Nicky Boy's Italian Style Hot Dog Pizza$10.95 +
Potato, peppers, onions and hot dogs.
Vegetable Pizza$12.50 +
Onions, garlic, spinach, mushrooms, peppers, broccoli, olives and tomatoes.
Meat Lovers$11.25 +
Sausage, meatball, pepperoni and ham.
Zingada Pizza$11.25 +
A little spice in your life, finely dived pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, meatball, hot cherry peppers topped with aged cheese well done and thin cheese to the end.
Everything Pizza$14.50 +
Buffalo Chicken Pizza$11.25 +
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza$12.95 +
Hawaiian Pizza$11.95 +
Pineapple, ham and fresh mozzarella.
Grandma Irm's Pizza$11.50 +
Mariana and mozzarella.
Bianca Pizza$10.25 +
Mozzarella and ricotta.
Mussels Mrinara$10.25
In white win garlic sauce.
Clams Casino$9.75
Stuffed with onions and peppers and topped with bacon.
Clams Oregenata$9.75
Stuffed with seasoned breadcrumbs.
Eggplant Rollatini$9.75
Fried eggplant rolled with ricotta and topped with mozzarella.
Fried Calamari$11.50
Lightly batter fried served with hot or sweet sauce.
Hotsy Totsy Shrimp$12.95
Hot sauce with garlic and marinara. sweet sauce.
Spedini Romano$8.50
Mozzarella and prosciutto batter fried served with anchovie sauce.
Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers$8.50
Home-made mozzarella and peppers drizzled with extra virgin olive oil.
Mozzarella Caprise$9.50
Home-made mozzarella, tomatoes and basil drizzled with extra virgin olive oil.
Mozzarella in Carozza$8.25
Skewered bread and mozzarella, batter fried, served with marinara sauce.
Portabello Mushroom & Roasted Peppers$9.50
Over tri-color salad with balsamic.
Long Hot Peppers with Crumbled Sausage & Potatoes$12.25
Ginger Calimari$13.25
Crab Cakes$14.25
Rice Balls$9.50
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe$9.95
Sauteed Long Hot Peppers$9.25
Scungilli Salad$12.95
Stuffed Artichoke$10.25
Chicken Fingers with French Fries$8.25
Stuffed Mushroom with Sausage and Herbs$8.75
Buffalo Wings$8.25
French Fries$4.75
Mozzarella Sticks$7.25
Garlic Bread with Cheese$5.50
Garlic Bread$4.25
Chicken Pastina Soup$3.50 +
Escarole & Beans Soup$3.50 +
Pasta Fagioli Soup$3.50 +
Spinach Stracciatella Soup$3.50 +
Tossed Salad$6.25
All White Tuna over a Tossed Salad$9.25
Chef Salad$8.75
Ham, turkey & Swiss.
Caesar Salad$6.75
Grilled Chicken over Caesar Salad$8.75
Breaded Chicken Cutlet over Tossed Salad$8.75
Grilled Shrimp over Tossed Salad$16.50
Steak House Salad$15.95
Steak Caesar Salad$15.95
Tri Color Salad$8.95
Chopped Salad$8.25
Comes with mixed dressing.
Gina Marie Salad$11.25
Mozzarella, roasted peppers, over tossed salad.
Plain Calzone$8.75 +
Plain Stromboli$8.75 +
One Topping Calzone$10.50 +
One Topping Stromboli$10.50 +
#2. Sweet Sopressata, Capicola, Provolone, Fresh Tomatoes Sandwich$8.25
With house dressing.
#3. Broccoli Rabe, Provolone, Sun-dried Tomatoes Sandwich$8.25
With extra virgin olive oil.
#4. Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Broccoli Rabe Sandwich$8.25
With extra virgin olive oil.
#5. Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Broccoli Rabe Sandwich$8.25
With balsamic.
#6. Prosciutto, Provolone, Sun-dried Tomatoes Sandwich$8.25
With balsamic.
#7. Genoa Salami, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers Sandwich$8.25
With house dressing.
#8. Capicola, Prosciutto, Provolone, Roasted Peppers Sandwich$8.25
With balsamic.
#9. Ham, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomatoes Sanadwich$8.25
With house dressing.
#10. Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers Sanadwich$8.25
With balsamic.
#11. Fresh Mozzarella, Sun-dried Tomatoes Sanadwich$7.95
With extra virgin olive oil.
#12. Eggplant, Provolone, Sun-dried Tomatoes Sandwich$8.25
With extra virgin olive oil.
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich$8.25
Shrimp Parmigiana Sandwich$10.25
Fried Flounder Sandwich$10.25
With lettuce, tomato & tartar sauce.
Vegetarian Panini$9.95
With provolone, spinach, asparagus, portabello mushrooms & sun-dried tomatoes.
Veal Parmigiana Sandwich$10.25
Veal Francaise Sandwich$10.25
With long hots.
Grilled Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich$8.25
With peppers & onions.
Amanda Wrap$8.75
Grilled chicken, provolone, broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomatoes onions, portabella mushrooms on a melted whole wheat wrap.
Meatball Sub$7.95
Grilled Chicken Sub$8.25
With broccoli rabe and provolone.
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub$8.25
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sub$8.25
Grilled Chicken Sub with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo$8.25
Philly Cheese Steak Sub with Peppers & Onions$8.25
Ham & Cheese Sub$7.95
Salami & Cheese Sub$7.95
Ham, Salami & Cheese Sub$8.25
Turkey & Cheese Sub$7.95
Capicola, Salami & Cheese Sub$8.25
Cheese Sub$7.50
Swiss, American, provolone.
Tuna Salad Sub$8.50
Chicken Salad Sub$8.50
Egg Salad Sub$7.50
Baked Ziti$9.00 +
Fettuccini Fileto de Pomodora$9.00 +
Fettuccini Alfredo$9.50 +
Totellini Alfredo$9.95 +
Fusilli Puttanesca$9.00 +
Linguini Marechiara with Shrimp & Clams$16.50
Lingiuni with Clam Sauce$9.75 +
Red or white.
Lobster Ravioli in an Asparagus Vodka Sauce$18.50
Orecchietta with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage$10.00 +
Penne Alla Vodka with Peas & Prosciutto$9.00 +
Ricotta Ravioli with Marinara Sauce$12.50
Rigatoni Bolognese$9.00 +
Spaghetti with Meatballs$9.75 +
Spaghetti Carbonara$9.50 +
Spaghetti Aglio Olio with Diced Tomatoes$9.00 +
Spinach Ravioli in a Tomato Basil Sauce$14.50