Skip to main content
The Classic New York Pizza Joint

The Classic New York Pizza Joint

2042 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
631-840-6179

Closed until 11:00 AM

Full Hours

Opening at 11:00 AM

pizza
Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$13.50

Cheese Pizza

Gluten Free Pizza

$12.95

Gluten Free Pizza

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

$12.95


Sicilian Pizza

$18.95


Brooklyn Pizza

$21.95


Grandma Pizza

Thin Sicilian crust brushed with olive oil & garlic, fresh mozzarella, and spotted with chunky San Marzano tomato sauce.

$21.95


Drunken Grandma Pizza

$21.95


White Pie

A sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.

$22.95


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.

$26.95


BBQ Chicken Pizza

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.

$26.95


Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Mozzarella cheese, bacon, chicken, and yummy ranch dressing.

$26.95


Chicken Vodka Pizza

$26.95


Chicken Marsala Pizza

$26.95


Chicken Francese Pizza

$26.95


Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pie

$26.95


Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Grilled breaded chicken meets a delectable tomato sauce, all covered in crispy gooey fresh melted mozzarella and parmigiano, and hints of aromatic basil on a crisp yet tender homemade crust.

$24.95


Fried Calamari Pizza

$26.95


Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza

$24.95


Spinach & Artichoke Pizza

$23.95


New York Pizza

Square thin crust, fresh mozzarella, with sweet tomato sauce.

$21.95


Margherita Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil.

$21.95


Giovanni Special Pizza

Chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil.

$26.95


Stefano Special Pizza

Mushroom cream, with a touch of cognac sauce, covered with sundried tomato, truffle oil, and shaved parmesan cheese.

$26.95


Old Fashioned Pizza

Provolone, marinara sauce, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.

$22.95


White Parma Pizza

Prosciutto, arugula, shaved parmesan , and a touch of truffle oil.

$25.95


Calabrisella Pizza

Hot sopressata, two types of mozzarella, and a touch of honey.

$24.95


Eggplant Oreganata Pizza

Grilled eggplant, fresh mozzarella, a touch of marinara, oreganata bread crumbs, pecorino romano cheese and basil.

$23.95

appetizers
Appetizers

Chicken Wings

Whole chicken wings deep-fried.

$9.75

Chicken Wings

Fried Calamari

Fried squid (calamari) is quickly deep fried, keeping it crunchy on the outside and simply perfect on the inside. Kick it up a notch with a squeeze of lemon.

$11.50


Baked Clams

$12.50


Chicken Fingers with Fries

Breaded and fried chicken strips.

$11.00


Mozzarella Sticks

Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Served with a side of marinara sauce.

$7.50

Mozzarella Sticks

Sicilian Rice Ball

$5.95

Sicilian Rice Ball

Garlic Bread

Bread, topped with garlic, herb seasoning, baked to perfection.

$3.95

soups
Soups
Served with bread.

Lentil Soup

Freshly cooked savory lentil soup.

$5.95


Minestrone Soup

Italian vegetable soup made with tomato broth and pasta.

$5.95


Pasta Fagioli Soup

Ditalini pasta, white cannellini beans, olive oil, onions, and seasonings simmered to perfection!

$5.95


Stracciatella Soup

Meat broth and small shreds of an egg-based mixture.

$5.95


Tortellini en Brodo Soup

$5.95

salads
Salads

Garden Salad

Mixed greens, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, carrots, and peppers.

$7.95


Caesar Salad

Romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing.

$8.95


Greek Salad

Mixed greens, kalamata olives, peppers, tomato, and feta cheese.

$9.95


Caprese Salad

Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic glaze over mixed greens.

$11.95


Stefanos Salad

Belgium endives, walnuts, cranberries, gorgonzola cheese and green apples.

$12.95

Stefanos Salad
sides
Sides

Meatballs

Ground meat rolled into small spheres, prepared with bread crumbs, minced onion, eggs, butter, and seasoning.

$4.95


Sausage

Who says sides are limited to just veggies? Get more meat & order a side of sausage.

$3.95


Sauteed Broccoli

Quick and easy sauteed broccoli is the perfect weeknight side dish. Broccoli so flavorful and tender, even the kiddos will ask for more!

$4.95


Sauteed Spinach

Quick and easy sauteed spinach is the perfect weeknight side dish. Spinach so flavorful, even the kiddos will ask for more!

$5.95


Sauteed Broccoli Rabe

$6.95


Garlic Knots

A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.

$2.50

Garlic Knots
rolls-calzones-pinwheels-strombolis
Rolls, Calzones, Pinwheels & Strombolis

Baked Calzone

A giant half moon pizza pocket stuffed with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$6.75

Baked Calzone

Fried Calzone

$6.75


Meat Stromboli

With Italian meats, green peppers, tomatoes, and onions.

$5.95


Veggie Stromboli

Sauce, mushrooms, sweet green peppers, onions & fresh mozzarella cheese.

$5.95


Chicken Roll

Strips of breaded chicken topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$6.95

Chicken Roll

Buffalo Chicken Roll

Chicken, bleu cheese, and hot sauce.

$6.95


Sausage & Pepper Roll

$6.95


Eggplant Roll

Eggplant slices and parmesan cheese.

$6.95


Spinach Roll

Roll stuffed with spinach and mozzarella.

$6.95


Ham & Cheese Roll

$6.95


Pepperoni Pinwheel

A delicious spiralized version of pepperoni pizza. An NYC pizza parlor classic you can enjoy at your table.

$3.95

Pepperoni Pinwheel

Broccoli Pinwheel

$3.95

Broccoli Pinwheel
heroes
Heroes

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Boneless breast of chicken with marinara sauce, parmesan & melted mozzarella.

$9.95


Meatball Parmigiana Hero

With marinara sauce, meatballs and parmesan cheese.

$9.95


Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

Topped with eggplant slices, parmesan cheese and marinara sauce.

$8.95


Veal Parmigiana Hero

$10.95


Sausage Parmigiana Hero

$9.95


Shrimp Parmigiana Hero

With shrimp and parmesan cheese.

$10.95


Sausage & Peppers Hero

$8.95


Peppers & Egg Hero

$7.95


Potato & Egg Hero

$7.95


The Godfather Hero

Salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onions.

$10.95


Chicken Caprese Hero

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red pepper, and pesto.

$10.95


Chicken Antico Hero

Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, and balsamic glaze.

$10.95


Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Hero

$11.95

baked-pasta
Baked Pasta

Baked Ziti

Ziti with mozzarella and tomato sauce baked to perfection in our oven.

$11.95


Baked Ziti Siciliano

$13.95


Baked Stuffed Shells

$12.95


Baked Ravioli

$12.95


Baked Tortellini

$12.95


Lasagna

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

$12.95

specialty-pasta
Specialty Pasta

Penne Alla Vodka

Pasta in vodka sauce.

$14.95


Rigatoni Bolognese

$15.95


Fettuccine Alfredo

Fettuccine tossed in our creamy homemade alfredo sauce.

$12.95


Pasta Primavera

Pasta and fresh vegetables tossed in our signature sauce.

$13.95


Broccoli Rabe with Sausage

$14.95


Rigatoni Genovese

Pesto sauce with a touch of cream.

$14.95


Rigatoni Toscano

Spinach, mushrooms, and shrimp in a pink sauce.

$16.95


Pasta with Linguini Clam Sauce

Red or white

$15.95


Pasta with Broccoli Garlic & Oil

$12.95


Spaghetti with Meatballs

Spaghetti topped in our homemade meatballs.

$14.95

Spaghetti with Meatballs

Pasta with Garlic & Oil

Delicious pasta covered in silky garlic oil.

$9.95


Pasta with Marinara Sauce

Pasta tossed in our homemade marinara sauce.

$10.95

entrees
Entrees
All entrees served with a choice of pasta or salad.

Chicken Parmigiana

Lightly fried, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$16.95


Chicken Francese

Egg battered, sauteed in a white wine, lemon, and butter sauce.

$16.95

Chicken Francese

Chicken Marsala

Sauteed in a marsala wine sauce with shiitake mushrooms.

$16.95


Chicken Scarpariello

Sauteed chicken breast with sausage, cherry peppers

$17.95


Chicken Milanese

Lightly fried chicken cutlet, chopped mozzarella, tomato, basil, onion, and balsamic glaze

$17.95


Chicken Cacciatore

Chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms, onions, and peppers in a light tomato sauce

$17.95


Veal Parmigiana

Lightly fried veal cutlet with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$18.95


Veal Franchese

Egg battered and sauteed in a white wine, lemon, and butter sauce.

$18.95


Veal Milanese

Lightly fried chicken cutlet over mesclun salad.

$18.95


Eggplant Parmigiana

Lightly fried eggplant, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$14.95


Eggplant Rollatine

Stuffed with ricotta, ham, and mozzarella, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$16.95


Shrimp Parmigiana

Lightly fried shrimp, baked with marinara sauce and mozzarella.

$18.95


Shrimp Scampi

Sauteed in white wine, garlic, fresh herbs, and lemon.

$18.95

SlicePizza Places in Bay Shore, NY The Classic New York Pizza Joint
Price: $$