Skip to main content
Gristmill

Gristmill

289 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
718-499-2424

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Gristmill a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
sourdough-round-pizza
Sourdough Round Pizza

Red Pizza

Tomato sauce, grana, parm.

$14.00


Cheese Pizza

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, grana, parm. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$18.00


Pepperoni Pizza

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, burnt honey.

$24.00


Arugula Pizza

Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, lemon, sesame.

$19.00


Potato Pizza

Crispy kale, mozzarella, cherry bomb vinegar.

$22.00


Mushroom Pizza

Ricotta, maitake, shiitake, thyme, lemon.

$25.00


Squash Pizza

Straciatella, carrot, leek, garlic chives.

$17.00

small-plates
Small Plates

Chicken Liver Mousse

Apple butter, dulce de leche, sourdough toast.

$9.00


Brussel Sprouts

Cider Hungarian wax pepper vinaigrette, russett apple.

$13.00


Smashed Potatoes

Dijonnaise, pickled shallot, dill, chives.

$12.00


Carrots

Pickled, roasted, raw.

$13.00


Greens

Baby greens, carrot & radish, toasted sesame vinaigrette.

$13.00


Kale Caesar

Kale, parm, breadcrumbs, anchovy.

$13.00

breads
Breads

Garlic Knots (Four Star Farm)

Cacio e pepe + everything.

$5.00


Cornbread (Four Star Farm)

Chive butter.

$6.00


The Loxness Knotster (Catsmo Artisan Smokehouse)

Smoked salmon, cream cheese, ricotta, dill.

$6.00

larger-plates-to-share-or-not
Larger Plates To Share or Not

Board Game

Coppa, truffle cheese, reading cheese, chicken liver mousse, apple butter, honey, cranberry mostarda, pickles, sourdough toast.

$28.00


Burger

Cheese, sourdough whey roll, burnt onion-chive aioli.

$28.00


Fried Chicken

Kohlrabi daikon apple slaw, spicy honey, chimichurri aioli.

$24.00

drinks
Drinks

Housemade Soda

$6.00


Grocers Bottling Co. Soda

$5.00

SlicePizza Places in Brooklyn, NY Gristmill
Price: $$