Benny's Pizzeria

1802 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230

Currently ClosedFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Benny's Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Regular Pie$20.00
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Bennys Original Pie$21.00
Homemade mozzarella tomato sauce topped with Parmesan.
Ala Vodka Pie$27.00
Homemade mozzarella in vodka sauce.
Bianca Pie$27.00
Homemade mozzarella, Parmesan, ricotta and a touch of garlic (no sauce).
Spinach Tomato Pie$28.50
Roasted tomatoes, fresh spinach with a touch of garlic.
Margharita Pie$27.00
Homemade mozzarella, fresh tomato sauce and basil
Mushroom Pie$28.50
Wild mushrooms topped with roasted garlic and three cheeses (no sauce).
Pepper Pie$27.00
Peppers spinach & onions with tomato sauce (mildly spicy).
Pasta Pizza Pie$33.00
Vodka sauce and cheese on pasta.
Cheeseless Vegetable Pie$28.50
Mixed peppers roasted tomatoes and fresh tomato sauce.
Grandma Pie$32.00
Mixed Mozzarella, tomato sauce topped with parmesan.
Deep Dish Pie$27.00
Thick dough with tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.
Tomato Basil Deep Dish Pie$28.50
Roasted tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, fresh basil and a touch of garlic.
Regular Pizza Slice$3.00
Margarita Pizza Slice$4.00
Mushroom Pizza Slice$4.25
Deep Dish Pizza Slice$4.50
Original Pizza Slice$3.50
Vodka Pizza Slice$4.25
Tomato Basil Deep Pan Pizza Slice$5.75
Eggplant Rollatini$9.00
Ricotta Mozzarella and Parmesan topped with tomato sauce.
Fresh spinach, tomatoes and cheese in a tortilla. (options: mushroom, eggplant, zucchini, onion or pepper).
Cheese Quesadilla$6.99
Melted mozzarella with a side of quesadilla sauce.
Diet Quesadilla$6.99
Fresh spinach, tomatoes and mushrooms (less cheese).
Stacked Eggplant Florentine$9.00
Fresh spinach, Eggplant, ricotta, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese topped with tomato sauce.
Sauteed Vegetables$9.00
Stuffed Portabella$8.50
Stuffed with roasted red peppers, tomatoes, spinach, Fresh Mozzarella & Pesto.
Mozzarella Sticks$7.00
Cheese sticks with a side of marinara sauce.
Regular Fries$3.50
Cheese Fries$5.50
Gravy Fries$8.00
Melted cheese & hot gravy.
Pasta Fagioli Soup$6.50
French Onion Soup$6.50
Caesar Salad$9.00
Lettuce, hamotzi croutons and 6-hour parmesan cheese.
Greek Salad$9.00
Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, black olives and feta cheese.
Make Your Own Salad$7.50 +
Romaine or spinach salad; includes four toppings (non-premium).
Garnished with garden vegetables or fries. Served all day.
Cheese Omelette$7.50
Filled with melted mozzarella.
Italian Omelette$7.50
Fresh basil, roasted tomatoes and mozzarella.
Greek Omelette$7.50
Feta cheese, olives and onion.
Sam's Omelette$7.50
Sauteed spinach with feta cheese.
Marinara Omelette$7.50
Sauteed spinach and cheese topped with marinara.
Choice of plain or whole wheat.
Tuna Wrap$6.99
Tuna with light mayo wrapped with lettuce and tomatoes.
Primavera Wrap$7.99
Fresh spinach, zucchini, mushroom, tomatoes with mozzarella cheese.
Vegetable Wrap$7.99
Green and red pepper, red onion, broccoli with mozzarella cheese.
Caprese Wrap$7.99
Homemade mozzarella, fresh tomato, basil, extra virgin olive oil and lettuce.
Veggie Burger Wrap$7.99
Served with lettuce, tomatoes & Mozzarella Cheese.
Tuna Panini$8.00
Tuna salad with lettuce and tomato.
Caprese Panini$8.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, tomato and pesto.
Vegetable Panini$8.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, olives and pesto sauce.
Eggplant Parmigiana Panini$8.00
Parmesan cheese, mozzarella, eggplant and tomato sauce.
Primavera Panini$8.00
Grilled portabella mushroom, roasted red peppers, red onion with pesto mayo.
Greek Panini$8.00
Feta cheese, tomatoes, olives and pesto sauce.
All pasta are served with Parmesan cheese unless requested otherwise.
Chefs Pasta$10.00
Fresh spinach, tomatoes and capers in a white wine sauce.
Pasta Primavera$10.00
Eggplant, onion, peppers and cherry tomatoes (choice of white or red sauce).
Aglio Olio$10.00
Mushroom & Spinach in garlic olive oil.
Penne Di Pomodoro$10.00
Fresh plump tomatoes, homemade mozzarella & fresh basil.
Penne Ala Funghi$10.00
Wild mushrooms in cream sauce.
Zucchini, eggplant, fresh tomato & broccoli in a white wine sauce.
Fresh garlic, parsley, red pepper, white wine & tomato sauce (spicy).
Pasta Puttanesca$10.00
Capers, black olives, fresh basil in tomato sauce.
Penne Ala Vodka$10.00
Cream sauce and fresh marinara.
Eggplant Parmesan$10.00
Breaded eggplant, mozzarella cheese in tomato sauce.
Baked Penne$10.00
Ricotta, Parmesan, mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Benny's Pasta$10.00
Capers, fresh garlic, tomato, basil in a light red sauce
Pasta Con broccoli$10.00
Sauteed garlic, broccoli, fresh basil and Parmesan.
Alfredo Sauce Pasta$10.00
Cream and Parmesan.
Marinara Sauce Pasta$10.00
Fresh garlic and basil in tomato sauce.
Sauteed mushrooms in a light red caper sauce.
All fish dishes are served with sauteed vegetables or fries.
Grilled Salmon$12.00 +
Half orders available till 4 pm.
Soda$1.50 +