Skip to main content
Papa J's Pizza

Papa J's Pizza

395 Shanley St, Buffalo, NY 14206
716-894-0594
New

Order Ahead We open at 4:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    deals-and-coupons

    Deals and Coupons

    DealFeatured

    Small Cheese Pizza & Single Wings

    $27.99

    Deal

    Cold Sub Of The Month

    $7.99

    frenzy-pizza-monday-specials

    Frenzy Pizza Monday Specials

    Only available Monday

    Personal 9" Cheese Pizza Special

    $9.90

    Large 17" Cheese Pizza Special

    $20.90

    Personal 9" Specialty Pizza Special

    $13.20

    Large 17" Specialty Pizza Special

    $25.30

    Small 13" Cheese Pizza Special

    $15.40

    Sheet 18" x 26" Cheese Pizza Special

    $34.10

    Small 13" Specialty Pizza Special

    $19.80

    Sheet 18" x 26" Specialty Pizza Special

    $38.50

    taco-tuesday-special

    Taco Tuesday Special

    Only available Tuesday

    Beef Taco Special

    $3.30

    Chicken Taco Special

    $3.30

    weck-wing-wednesday-specials

    Weck & Wing Wednesday Specials

    Only available Wednesday

    Beef On Weck Special

    $8.80

    weck-wing-wednesday-pick-up-only-specials

    Weck & Wing Wednesday Pick Up Only Specials

    Only available Wednesday for pickup

    Wings Special

    Limit is 2 orders or up to 20 wings// not available for delivery

    $11.00

    friday-special

    Friday Special

    Only available Friday

    Fish Fry Special

    $18.70

    pizza

    Pizza

    Best seller

    Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $12.10

    Best seller

    Cheese Pizza large

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $26.40

    Cheese Pizza (SHEET

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $45.10

    Cheese Pizza small

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $18.70

    specialty-pizza

    Specialty Pizza

    White Pizza

    $15.40

    Breakfast Pizza

    $15.40

    Taco Pizza

    $15.40

    Veggie Pizza

    Vegan cheese optional.

    $15.40

    Hawaiian Pizza

    $15.40

    Meat Lovers Pizza

    $15.40

    Chicken Finger Pizza

    $15.40

    Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

    $15.40

    Steak Pizza

    $15.40

    Stinger Pizza

    $15.40

    pizza-by-the-slice

    Pizza By The Slice

    Cheese Pizza Slice

    $4.95

    Specialty Pizza Slice

    $6.05

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    $5.50

    breakfast-everyday

    Breakfast Everyday

    Breakfast Sandwich

    $11.00

    French Toast Sticks

    $7.70

    Breakfast Pizza

    $15.40

    appetizers

    Appetizers

    Pizza Logs

    $11.00

    Best seller

    Cajun Fries

    $7.45

    Jalapeno Poppers

    $8.80

    Fried Cauliflower

    $8.80

    Best seller

    Mozzarella Sticks

    $8.80

    Taco In A Box

    $19.80

    Fried Mushrooms

    $8.80

    Garlic Bread with Cheese

    $8.80

    Tater Tots

    $6.60

    Eggrolls

    Chicken, steak, or seafood.

    $17.60

    Best seller

    Fries

    $6.35

    Eggroll Combo

    1 each: chicken, steak, and seafood.

    $18.70

    Onion Rings

    $6.60

    Loaded Fries

    Beef or bacon.

    $15.40

    Food Combo Platter

    3 Pizza logs, 3 Jalapeno poppers, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 fingers, fries, beef taco.

    $26.40

    Loaded Tots

    Bacon or beef.

    $15.40

    salads

    Salads

    Dinner Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, onions, croutons.

    $8.80

    Taco Salad

    $15.40

    Caesar Chicken Salad

    $15.40

    Antipasto Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, onions, crotons, cheese, ham, turkey, salami, green & black olives, pepperoni.

    $19.80

    chicken-wings

    Chicken Wings

    Chicken Wings

    Served with celery & blue cheese.

    $19.80

    Country Style Fried Chicken Wings

    Available in lemon pepper & cajun.

    $22.00

    Chicken Wings From The Pit

    Served with celery and blue cheese.

    $22.00

    chicken-fingers

    Chicken Fingers

    Chicken Fingers

    Served with celery and blue cheese.

    $17.60

    cold-subs

    Cold Subs

    All subs come with lettuce, tomato, cheese, & a toasted roll.

    Ham Sub

    $9.90

    Chicken Finger Sub

    $9.90

    Turkey Sub

    $9.90

    Meatball Bomber Sub

    $9.90

    Salami Sub

    $9.90

    Tuna Sub

    $9.90

    Cappicola Sub

    $9.90

    Pizza Sub

    $9.90

    Stinger Sub

    $12.10

    Cheeseburger Sub

    $11.00

    Steak Sub

    $9.90

    Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

    $11.55

    BLT Sub

    $10.45

    Italian Sausage Sub

    $10.45

    Cheese Sub

    $7.70

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    $9.90

    Royal Sub

    Italian sausage & capicola.

    $11.00

    Turkey Club Sub

    $10.45

    Assorted Sub

    Ham, turkey, salami.

    $9.90

    Italian Parm Sub

    $10.45

    Roast Beef Sub

    $9.90

    hot-subs

    Hot Subs

    All subs come with lettuce, tomato, cheese, & a toasted roll.

    Ham Sub

    $9.90

    Chicken Finger Sub

    $9.90

    Turkey Sub

    $9.90

    Meatball Bomber Sub

    $9.90

    Salami Sub

    $9.90

    Tuna Sub

    $9.90

    Cappicola Sub

    $9.90

    Pizza Sub

    $9.90

    Stinger Sub

    $12.10

    Cheeseburger Sub

    $11.00

    Steak Sub

    $9.90

    Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

    $11.55

    BLT Sub

    $10.45

    Italian Sausage Sub

    $10.45

    Cheese Sub

    $7.70

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    $9.90

    Royal Sub

    Italian sausage & capicola.

    $11.00

    Turkey Club Sub

    $10.45

    Assorted Sub

    Ham, turkey, salami.

    $9.90

    Italian Parm Sub

    $10.45

    Roast Beef Sub

    $9.90

    hoagie-subs

    Hoagie Subs

    All hoagies comes with hoagie sauce, onions & cheese.

    Chop Chicken Hoagie

    $17.60

    Chop Burger Hoagie

    $16.50

    Chop Turkey Hoagie

    $17.60

    Steak Hoagie

    $17.60

    tacos

    Tacos

    Beef Taco

    $7.70

    Chicken Finger Taco

    $8.80

    Chicken Taco

    $7.70

    Veggie Taco

    $5.50

    Steak Taco

    $8.80

    Fish Taco

    $8.80

    char-broiler

    Char Broiler

    All serves with fries.

    Hamburger

    $14.30

    Fried Bologna Sandwich

    Onions & mustard.

    $13.20

    Cheeseburger

    $15.40

    Charbroiled Chicken Breast

    Lettuce & tomato.

    $14.30

    Sirloin Steak Sandwich

    $15.40

    Roast Beef on Weck

    $14.30

    Papa J'S Pigtail Sandwich

    Italian sausage coil with hot peppers, onions, & cheese.

    $15.40

    fish-fry-everyday

    Fish Fry Everyday

    Served with homemade macaroni salad, coleslaw, bread & fries.

    Fish Fry

    $18.70

    Fish Sandwich

    Lettuce, tomato & tarter sauce.

    $14.30

    Shrimp Dinner

    $18.70

    Shrimp with Fries

    $16.50

    1/2 Fish & 1/2 Shrimp

    $24.20

    desserts

    Desserts

    Chocolate Cake

    $5.50

    Carrot Cake

    $5.50

    Cheesecake

    $5.50

    Fried Dough

    $8.80

    pop

    Pop

    Soda

    $3.05

    Water

    $2.20

    pick-up-pop

    Pick Up Pop

    Only available for pickup

    Soda

    $3.05

    Papa J's Pizza - View Menu & Order Online - 395 Shanley St, Buffalo, NY 14206 - Slice

    SliceNYBuffalo14206 Papa J's Pizza
    Price: $$