Skip to main content
Mustachio's Pizzeria

Mustachio's Pizzeria

2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
716-874-8909

Order Ahead We open at 11:00 AM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    fresh-baked-pizza

    Fresh Baked Pizza

    Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $15.99

    Gluten Free Pizza

    Cheese & 1 item.

    $14.99

    Gluten Free Pizza
    specialty-pizza

    Specialty Pizza

    Sicilian Pizza

    Oil, garlic, romano, tomatoes dipped in special sauce, onions & your choice of hot or sweet peppers & sausage or pepperoni.

    $20.99

    Sicilian Pizza

    Buffalo Style Pizza

    Hot, medium, or mild diced chicken fingers, pizza sauce or blue cheese base & mozzarella.

    $20.99

    Buffalo Style Pizza

    Spinach Ricotta Pizza

    Spinach, mushrooms, garlic, ricotta, mozzarella & romano.

    $20.99

    Veggie Deluxe Pizza

    Mushrooms, sweet & hot peppers, green & black olives, onions & mozzarella.

    $20.99

    Veggie Deluxe Pizza

    Broccoli Cheddar Pizza

    Melted cheddar, grated romano, onions, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano.

    $20.99

    Broccoli Cheddar Pizza

    Spaghetti & Meatballs Parm Pizza

    Pizza sauce, cooked spaghetti, chopped meatballs, mozzarella & romano.

    $20.99

    Spaghetti & Meatballs Parm Pizza

    White Pizza

    Romano & mozzarella, onions, fresh cut tomatoes, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano. Anchovies upon request.

    $20.99

    White Pizza

    Hawaiian Pizza

    Pizza sauce, ham, pineapple & mozzarella.

    $20.99

    Hawaiian Pizza

    Taco Pizza

    Hot, medium, or mild sauce with mozzarella, cheddar, ground beef, lettuce & tomatoes.

    $20.99

    Taco Pizza
    billys-zas

    Billy's 'ZAs

    CBR Pizza

    Chicken fingers, bacon, ranch, lite onion, mozzarella & cheddar.

    $21.99

    Stuffed Hot Pepper Pizza

    Oil base, homemade cheese-filled hot banana peppers, topped with mozzarella & sausage.

    $21.99

    Stuffed Hot Pepper Pizza

    BBQ Chicken Pizza

    BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella & lite onions.

    $21.99

    BBQ Chicken Pizza

    Chef Andrew's Alfredo Pizza

    Alfredo sauce, broccoli, chicken, mozzarella & cheddar.

    $21.99

    Chef Andrew's Alfredo Pizza

    Meat Lover's Deluxe Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham & bacon.

    $21.99

    Meat Lover's Deluxe Pizza

    Stinger Pizza

    Hot, medium, or mild chicken fingers, oil base, ribeye steak, hoagie cheese & mozzarella.

    $21.99

    Stinger Pizza

    Steak Hoagie Pizza

    Oil base hoagie cheese with a mixture of sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions & ribeye steak topped with romano & your choice of mozzarella or cheddar cheese.

    $21.99

    Steak Hoagie Pizza

    Greek Pizza

    Oil base, tomatoes, black olives, hot peppers, chicken & feta topped with mozzarella or cheddar.

    $21.99

    Greek Pizza

    Supreme Deluxe Pizza

    Our veggie deluxe topped with pepperoni & sausage.

    $21.99

    Supreme Deluxe Pizza

    Hitman Pizza

    Oil base, sausage, capicola, salami, ham, sweet peppers, onions, hot peppers, hot sauce & mozzarella.

    $21.99

    Hitman Pizza

    Grilled Chicken & Mushroom Pizza

    Available with pizza sauce or white style topped with mozzarella cheese. Also great with broccoli!

    $21.99

    Grilled Chicken & Mushroom Pizza
    pizza-by-the-slice

    Pizza by the Slice

    Cheese Pizza Slice

    $3.49

    Peperoni Pizza Slice

    $3.49

    every-day-combo-specials

    Every Day Combo Specials!

    Mini Pak

    Small pizza with cheese & one item plus 10 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings are available at an additional charge.

    $32.99

    Super Pak

    Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 30 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available at additional charge.

    $62.99

    Fab Pak

    Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 10 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings are available at an additional charge.

    $39.99

    Royal Pak

    Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 50 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available at additional charge.

    $75.99

    Special Pak

    Large pizza with cheese & one item and double fingers with fries. Specialty sauce is available for an additional charge.

    $49.99

    Party Pak

    Sheet pizza with cheese & one item and 50 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available for an additional charge.

    $89.99

    Family Pak

    Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 20 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available at additional charge.

    $49.99

    soups

    Soups

    Homemade Chili

    $7.99

    Homemade Chicken Noodle Soup

    $7.99

    salads

    Salads

    Italian, Ranch, Caesar, French, Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, Lite Italian, Raspberry Vinaigrette & Greek.

    Kevin's Catering Famous Strawberry Caesar Salad

    Romaine, strawberries, blueberries, red onion & the famous dressing!

    $13.99

    Kevin's Catering Famous Strawberry Caesar Salad

    Taco Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, hot pepper, black olives, taco meat, cheddar, mozzarella, salsa & sour cream.

    $10.99

    Chef Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, celery, mozzarella cheese.

    $7.99

    Chef Salad

    Greek Chicken Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot pepper, black olives, feta & Greek dressing.

    $10.99

    Julienne Salad

    Turkey, ham, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, mozzarella cheese.

    $10.99

    Grilled Chicken Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, mozzarella cheese.

    $10.99

    Grilled Chicken Salad

    Antipasto Salad

    Salami, ham, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, provolone & mozzarella cheese.

    $10.99

    Antipasto Salad

    Chicken Finger Salad

    Hot, medium or mild chicken, lettuce, tomato, celery, onions, cheddar & mozzarella.

    $10.99

    Chicken Finger Salad

    Tuna Salad

    Tuna, lettuce, tomato, onion, celery & mozzarella cheese.

    $10.99

    Turkey Club Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella, cheddar, turkey, and bacon.

    $10.99

    side-orders

    Side Orders

    Bread Staches

    Breadsticks flavored with garlic, butter & spices with a side of pizza sauce.

    $5.99

    Garlic Bread

    $2.59

    Seasoned Curly Q Fries

    $5.49

    Garlic Bread with Mozzarella

    $4.99

    French Fries

    Steak cut.

    $5.49

    French Fries

    Garlic Bread with Tomatoes & Mozzarella

    $5.49

    Cheesy Fries

    Nacho cheese.

    $7.99

    Cheesy Fries

    Garlic Bread with Spinach & Mozzarella

    $5.49

    Poutine

    Steak fries, gravy, topped with melted mozzarella.

    $8.99

    Chips

    $1.59

    Onion Rings

    $6.99

    Onion Rings

    Dipping Sauce

    Hot sauce, blue cheese or ranch.

    $1.29

    Battered Cauliflower

    Served with dipping sauce.

    $7.49

    Battered Cauliflower

    Homemade Coleslaw

    $2.99

    Battered Mushrooms

    Served with dipping sauce.

    $7.49

    Homemade Macaroni

    $2.99

    Battered Pickle Chips

    Served with dipping sauce.

    $7.49

    Homemade Potato Salad

    $2.99

    Battered Broccoli Cheddar Bites

    Served with dipping sauce.

    $7.49

    Salad Dressing

    $0.99

    Deluxe Potato Skins

    Skins with cheddar cheese, bacon, sour cream.

    $9.99

    Deluxe Potato Skins

    Gravy

    $2.49

    Mac N Cheese

    $9.99

    Nachos with Cheese

    Jalapenos on request.

    $3.99

    Mozzarella Stix

    Stix with spaghetti sauce.

    $6.99

    Mozzarella Stix

    Nacho Cheese

    $1.29

    Pizza Logs

    With pizza sauce.

    $7.49

    Jalapenos

    $1.29

    Jalapeno Poppers

    Poppers with dipping sauce.

    $6.99

    Jalapeno Poppers

    Salsa

    $1.29

    chicken-wings

    Chicken Wings

    Hot, medium, or mild. Served with bleu cheese & celery.

    Chicken Wings

    $16.99

    Chicken Wings

    Boneless Wings

    Hot, medium, or mild. Served with bleu cheese and celery.

    $15.99

    Boneless Wings
    specialty-wings

    Specialty Wings

    Hot garlic parm, garlic parm, honey dijon, BBQ, Cajun, extra hot, char-broiled BBQ, Italian, Gen Tso's, mango habanero, sweet chili, sriracha, teriyaki, hot BBQ, Chiavetta's, A1 wing sauce.

    Specialty Wings

    Hot garlic parm, garlic parm, honey dijon, BBQ, cajun, extra hot, char-broiled BBQ, Italian gen Tso’s, mango habanero, sweet chili, sriracha, teriyaki, hot BBQ, Chiavetta's, A.1 wing sauce.

    $18.99

    Specialty Wings
    chicken-fingers

    Chicken Fingers

    Hot, medium or mild served with blue cheese & celery.

    Chicken Fingers

    Hot, medium or mild served with bleu cheese and celery. Specialty sauces available for an additional cost.

    $17.99

    Chicken Fingers with Fries

    Hot, medium or mild served with bleu cheese and celery. Specialty sauces available for an additional cost.

    $18.99

    Chicken Fingers with Fries
    calzones-stromboli

    Calzones & Stromboli

    Pizza Roll

    Large dough stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, sweet peppers, mozzarella & a side of pizza sauce.

    $21.99

    Stromboli

    Mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet peppers & ham wrapped in dough with a side of sauce. No substitutions.

    $15.99

    Stromboli

    Calzone

    Up to 3 items. Dough filled with mozzarella and ricotta cheese served with a side of spaghetti or pizza sauce.

    $16.99

    Calzone
    deli-sandwiches

    Deli Sandwiches

    Piled high deli-style meats with lettuce, tomatoes. White American cheese and onions on request. Served on a Costanzo's hard roll with a pickle spear.

    Roast Beef Sandwich

    $9.99

    Capicola Sandwich

    $8.99

    Ham Sandwich

    $7.99

    Hard Salami Sandwich

    $7.99

    Corned Beef Sandwich

    $8.99

    Cheese Sandwich

    $7.99

    Turkey Sandwich

    Oven-roasted.

    $8.99

    Tuna Sandwich

    $8.99

    hot-sandwiches

    Hot Sandwiches

    Steak & Cheese Sandwich

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $11.99

    Italian Sausage Sandwich

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $10.99

    Chicken Finger Sandwich

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $11.99

    Cheeseburger Sandwich

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $10.99

    B.L.T. Sandwich

    A lot of bacon!

    $10.99

    Roast Beef Sandwich

    With gravy.

    $11.99

    Turkey Club

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $10.99

    Turkey Sandwich

    With gravy.

    $11.99

    Chicken Breast Fillet Sandwich

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $10.99

    Hot Capicola & Cheese Sandwich

    $9.99

    Fried Bologna Sandwich

    American cheese & sauteed onions.

    $8.99

    Beef on Weck Sandwich

    $10.99

    Fish Sandwich

    With lettuce & tomatoes.

    $10.99

    submarines

    Submarines

    On a white or wheat oven-toasted roll. All subs include white American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes. Onions on request. Choices of mayo, miracle whip, pepper Jack, provolone, Swiss, mustard, ketchup, oil.

    Roast Beef Sub

    Our own slow oven-roasted.

    $9.99

    Italian Assorted Sub

    Hard salami, capicola & ham.

    $8.99

    Italian Assorted Sub

    Tuna Sub

    $8.99

    Tuna Sub

    Ham, Turkey & Roast Beef Sub

    $9.99

    Corned Beef Sub

    $8.99

    Corned Beef Sub

    Capicola Sub

    $8.99

    Ham Sub

    $7.99

    Ham Sub

    Hard Salami Sub

    $7.99

    Turkey Sub

    Oven-roasted.

    $8.99

    Cheese Sub

    $7.99

    Ham & Turkey Sub

    $8.99

    Bologna Sub

    $7.99

    hot-submarines

    Hot Submarines

    The "Statche" Sub

    Steak, hot stuffed peppers, lettuce & tomato or fried mushrooms & onions.

    $13.99

    Roast Beef Classic Sub

    Our garlic bread with mushrooms & mozzarella.

    $11.99

    "Stinger" Sub

    Steak, chicken finger, lettuce & tomato.

    $12.99

    Pizza Sub

    Pepperoni, mozzarella & pizza sauce.

    $10.99

    "Bully" Sub

    Steak, sausage, lettuce & tomato.

    $12.99

    White Pizza Sub

    Just like our White Pizza.

    $10.99

    Steak & Cheese with Fried Peppers & Onions Sub

    $11.99

    Veal Parmesan Sub

    Veal, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.

    $10.99

    Steak & Cheese with Fried Mushrooms & Onions Sub

    $11.99

    Sausage Parmesan Sub

    Italian sausage, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.

    $10.99

    Steak & Cheese with Lettuce & Tomato Sub

    $11.99

    Meatball Parmesan Sub

    Meatballs, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.

    $10.99

    Steak & Spinach Sub

    Lettuce, tomato or fried peppers & onions.

    $11.99

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Chicken, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.

    $11.99

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Chicken & Spinach Sub

    Lettuce & tomato or fried peppers & onions.

    $11.99

    Eggplant Parmesan Sub

    5-6 pieces of eggplant, spaghetti sauce, and mozzarella.

    $10.99

    Hitman's Delight Sub

    Fried hot & sweet peppers, onions, italian sausage, ham, salami, capicola, cheese & hot sauce.

    $11.99

    Chicken Finger Sub

    Provolone & bleu cheese, lettuce & tomato.

    $11.99

    Baked Reuben Sub

    Corned beef, kraut, swiss cheese, thousand island dressing.

    $11.99

    BLT Sub

    A lot of bacon! Lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Rib Sub

    Rib, bbq sauce, mozzarella cheese.

    $10.99

    Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub

    Chicken, ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Royale Sub

    Italian sausage & capicola, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Turkey Club Sub

    Turkey, bacon, cheese, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Italian Sausage Sub

    Lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Grilled Chicken Sub

    Lettuce & tomato - try with BBQ or dijon. Extra for bacon and ham.

    $10.99

    Fish Sub

    Battered haddock, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    California Dream Sub

    Chicken breast, bacon, swiss, ranch, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Cheeseburger Sub

    3/4 lb. Of black angus, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Tuna Cheddar Melt Sub

    Tuna, lettuce, cheddar & tomato.

    $10.99

    Cheeseburger Royale Sub

    3/4 lb. Of black angus, ham, cheese, lettuce & tomato.

    $10.99

    Piglet Sub

    Sausage, ham, bacon, lettuce & tomato.

    $11.99

    Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

    Lettuce & tomato.

    $11.99

    Fried Bologna Sub

    American cheese & sauteed onions.

    $10.99

    Baked Roast Beef Sub

    Lettuce, tomato & mozzarella or cheddar.

    $11.99

    super-hoagies

    Super Hoagies

    All hoagies include fried sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms, hoagie cheese & special sauce.

    Super Steak Hoagie

    $12.99

    Super Turkey Hoagie

    $12.99

    Super Sausage Hoagie

    $12.99

    Super Chicken Hoagie

    $12.99

    Super Steak & Sausage Hoagie

    $14.99

    Super Cheeseburger Hoagie

    Try adding lettuce & tomato.

    $12.99

    wraps

    Wraps

    White or wheat. All wraps include lettuce, tomatoes, white american cheese & pickles. Onions upon request. Excludes beef on weck.

    Ham Wrap

    $8.99

    Turkey Club Wrap

    $10.99

    Assorted Wrap

    $8.99

    Steak Wrap

    $10.99

    Turkey Wrap

    $8.99

    Turkey Wrap

    Chicken Breast Wrap

    $10.99

    Capicola Wrap

    $8.99

    Chicken Finger Wrap

    $10.99

    Hard Salami Wrap

    $8.99

    Greek Wrap

    Chicken breast, feta, black olives, hot banana peppers & greek dressing.

    $10.99

    Greek Wrap

    Tuna Wrap

    $8.99

    Beef On Weck Wrap

    Roast beef, horsey sauce, pepper jack, pretzel salt & caraway seeds.

    $10.99

    Beef On Weck Wrap

    Vegetable Wrap

    $8.99

    Stinger Wrap

    Steak and chicken finger.

    $11.99

    tacos-pastelitos

    Tacos & Pastelitos

    All tacos include soft shell, lettuce, tomatoes & cheese. Excludes fajitas.

    Ground Beef Taco

    $6.99

    Ground Beef Taco

    Steak Fajita Burrito

    Fried sweet peppers & onions, cheddar & sub cheese.

    $9.99

    Chicken Taco

    $9.99

    Chicken Fajita Burrito

    Fried sweet peppers & onions, cheddar & sub cheese.

    $9.99

    Steak Taco

    $9.99

    Stinger Taco

    Steak & chicken finger.

    $11.99

    Chicken Finger Taco

    $9.99

    Pastelitos

    Beef & cheese.

    $3.99

    Roast Beef Taco

    $9.99

    mac-cheese

    Mac & Cheese

    Mac & Cheese

    $8.99

    dinners

    Dinners

    Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers

    Peppers on garlic points.

    $15.99

    Veal Parmesan

    Breaded veal, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Bar-B-Que Ribs

    Includes coleslaw, fries & roll.

    $17.99

    Chicken Parmesan

    Breaded chicken, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Grilled Chicken Dinner

    Boneless chicken breast, salad & fries.

    $14.99

    Baked Penne

    Penne pasta, mozzarella & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Cheese Ravioli

    Jumbo ravioli, two meatballs & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Fish Dinner

    Two pieces of haddock fish, salad & fries.

    $14.99

    Fish Dinner

    Stuffed Shells

    Jumbo shells, two meatballs & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Shrimp Dinner

    Breaded butterfly shrimp with fries & cocktail sauce.

    $14.99

    Spaghetti

    With two meatballs & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Roast Beef With Gravy Dinner

    Served on Costanzo's roll with gravy, salad & fries.

    $14.99

    Spaghetti Parmesan

    Two meatballs, mozzarella & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Turkey With Gravy Dinner

    Served on Costanzo's roll with gravy, salad & fries.

    $14.99

    Eggplant Parmesan

    Breaded eggplant, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.

    $14.99

    Beef on Weck Dinner

    Served with salad and fries.

    $14.99

    desserts

    Desserts

    Cookies

    Huge! Chocolate chips, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, macadamia nut & white chocolate.

    $2.49

    Brownie

    Gluten free.

    $4.99

    Iced Lemon Loaf Cake

    $4.99

    Salted Caramel Brownie

    $4.99

    Chocolate Banana Swirl Loaf Cake

    $4.99

    Belgium Waffle

    $4.99

    Iced Pumpkin Swirl Loaf Cake

    $4.99

    Apple Pie Logs

    With caramel sauce dip.

    $7.99

    Cinnamon Coffee Cake

    $4.99

    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    Coke products.

    $2.79

    Red Bull

    $3.99

    Flavored Iced Tea

    $2.89

    Water

    $1.99

    Powerade

    $2.89

    Slush Puppie

    $1.50

    Monster Energy Drink

    $3.99

    every-day-lunch-specials

    Every Day Lunch Specials!

    Only available 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM

    1/2 Cold Sub Lunch

    Plus pop or french fries.

    $10.49

    Two Pizza Slices Lunch

    Plus pop or french fries.

    $8.99

    1/2 Hot Sub Lunch

    Plus pop or french fries.

    $11.49

    5 Wings Lunch

    Plus pop or french fries.

    $10.99

    Large Beef Taco Lunch

    Plus pop or french fries.

    $8.99

    subs-wraps-catering

    Subs & Wraps Catering

    Served cold.

    Sub Platter Catering

    $59.99

    Wrap Platter Catering

    $59.99

    Mustachio's Pizzeria - View Menu & Order Online - 2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217 - Slice

    SliceNYBuffalo14217 Mustachio's Pizzeria
    Price: $$