hero

Penny's Pizza

3289 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217

Currently ClosedFull HoursNo MinimumPickup (15 - 30 min)Are you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Penny's Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
pizza
Cheese Pizza$10.00 +
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza$11.00 +
specialty-pizza
White Pizza$12.50 +
Garlic sauce, cheese, onions & tomatoes.
Taco Pizza$12.50 +
Taco meat, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and black olives with taco sauce and sour cream on the side.
Vegetarian Pizza$12.50 +
Choice of sauce and 3 veggie toppings.
Greek Pizza$13.50 +
Garlic sauce, spinach, tomato, black olives, onions, feta cheese, mozzarella.
Hawaiian Pizza$12.50 +
Choice of sauce, mozzarella, ham & pineapple.
Chicken Finger Pizza$13.50 +
Choice of sauce or bleu cheese, chicken fingers, cheddar cheese, mozzarella.
Grilled Chicken Pizza$13.50 +
Choice of sauce or bleu cheese, grilled chicken, cheddar cheese & mozzarella.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza$13.50 +
Homemade buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, cheddar cheese & mozzarella.
BBQ Chicken Pizza$13.50 +
Choice of BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, pineapple, cheddar cheese & mozzarella.
Steak Pizza$14.50 +
Choice of sauce, sweet or hot peppers, onion, cheddar cheese & mozzarella.
Stinger Pizza$16.50 +
Choice of sauce, steak, chicken fingers, cheddar cheese & mozzarella.
Supreme Pizza$14.50 +
Choice of sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, sweet or hot peppers, mozzarella.
Meat Lovers Pizza$13.50 +
Choice of sauce, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mozzarella.
pizza-by-the-slice
Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza Slice$2.50
salads
Choice of dressing: Italian, Greek, ranch, raspberry vinaigrette, bleu cheese.
Antipasto Salad$6.25 +
Chef Salad$4.00 +
Julienne Salad$5.75 +
Taco Salad$5.75 +
Chicken Finger Salad$5.75 +
Grilled Chicken Salad$6.25 +
Grilled Souvlaki Salad$6.50 +
wings
Hot, medium or mild. Specialty sauces: BBQ, honey BBQ, honey garlic, garlic, gold sauce. honey BBQ parmesan, garlic parmesan, hot BBQ, hot garlic, Penny's sauce.
Wings$10.00 +
Includes bleu cheese and carrots.
Specialty Wings$10.25 +
Includes bleu cheese and carrots.
Boneless Wings$7.50 +
Includes bleu cheese and carrots.
Chicken Fingers$6.50 +
Includes bleu cheese and carrots.
Chicken Fingers Special$8.00
4 fingers with fries.
side-orders
Onion Rings$3.50
French Fries$3.00 +
Mozzarella Sticks$4.50
Pizza Fingers$6.00
Hot Poppers$6.00
Broccoli Bites$6.00
Breaded Mushrooms$4.50
Garlic Bread$2.50
Garlic Bread with Cheese$3.50
Greek Fries$5.50
Greek oil & feta cheese.
Penny Fries$6.50
Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon & ranch dressing.
Loaded Fries$6.00
Cheddar cheese & bacon.
Penny's Sample Platter$9.50
5 battered mushrooms, 2 hot poppers, 2 pizza fingers, 2 mozzarella sticks, 2 broccoli bites and onion rings.
sandwiches
Include lettuce, tomato, choice of cheese, and choice of oil, mayo, ketchup or mustard.
Hamburg Sandwich$3.25
Cheeseburger$3.75
Cheeseburger with Bacon$4.25
Chicken Finger Sandwich$4.25
Grilled Chicken Sandwich$4.75
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich$4.75
cold-subs
Includes lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese, oil, mayo or Miracle Whip on a Costanzo roll. Provolone & wheat rolls upon request.
Ham Sub$4.50 +
Salami Sub$4.50 +
Capicola Sub$4.50 +
Assorted Sub$4.50 +
Turkey Sub$4.50 +
Turkey & Bacon Sub$5.00 +
Tuna Sub$4.50 +
Tuna & Bacon Sub$5.00 +
BLT Sub$4.50 +
hot-subs
Includes lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese, oil, mayo or Miracle Whip on a Costanzo roll. Provolone & wheat rolls upon request.
Steak Sub$6.50 +
Sliced ribeye.
Steak Hoagie$6.50 +
Choice of sweet or red peppers.
Steak & Sausage Sub$6.25 +
Choice of sweet or hot peppers.
Italian Sausage Sub$6.00 +
Royal Sub$6.00 +
Sausage & capicola.
Cheeseburger$5.25 +
Cheeseburger & Bacon$6.00 +
Chicken Finger Sub$5.50 +
Stinger Sub$6.50 +
Chicken finger and steak.
Grilled Chicken Sub$6.00 +
Grilled Chicken Hoagie$6.50 +
Choice of sweet or hot peppers.
Chicken & Broccoli Sub$6.50 +
Buffalo Chicken Sub$6.00 +
Chicken Souvlaki Sub$6.50 +
Penny's Special Sub$6.00 +
Assorted cold cuts & sausage.
baked-subs
Includes lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese, oil, mayo or Miracle Whip on a Costanzo roll. Provolone & wheat rolls upon request.
Pizza Sub$5.00 +
Meatballs Sub$5.25 +
Cheese Sub$4.75 +
Chicken Parmesan sub$5.50 +
Sausage Parmesan Sub$5.50 +
tacos
Large soft shell.
Beef Taco$3.00
Steak Taco$6.25
Chicken Finger Taco$4.50
Grilled Chicken Taco$4.50
wraps
Tomato basil, herb & garlic or plain.
Greek Wrap$6.00
Choice of wrap filled with grilled chicken, lettuce tomato, onion, feta cheese and Greek dressing.
Chicken Finger Wrap$6.00
Choice of wrap filled with chicken fingers, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, lettuce & tomato.
Grilled Chicken Wrap$6.00
Filled with grilled chicken, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses, lettuce, tomato and choice of dressing.
Steak Wrap$7.00
Filled with steak, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses, lettuce, tomato and steak oil.
Veggie Wrap$5.50
Filled with fried mushrooms, black olives, fried sweet peppers, lettuce, tomato, cheddar & mozzarella cheeses with choice of dressing.
Ham & Turkey Wrap$5.50
Filled with ham, turkey, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and choice of dressing.

FAQ