The Gristmill

The Gristmill

144 Main St, East Rockaway, NY 11518

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give The Gristmill a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Brick Oven Pizza
12'' personal pizzas. All of our brick oven pizzas can be made into calzones.

Margherita Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, basil, evo, tomato sauce.


The Sophia Siciliana Pizza

Ricotta cheese, garlic, grated romano, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, arugula, an balsamic glaze.


The Sicilian Pizza

Prosciutto, shaved parmesan, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, arugula.


Clam Tastic Pizza

Chopped clams, white seafood sauce, seasoned bread crumbs.


Messina Pizza

Fresh burrata mozzarella, roasted peppers, red onion, baby arugula, and fig glaze.


Napolitano Pizza

Broccoli rabe, garlic, crumbled sausage, hot cherry peppers, and mozzarella.


The GMC Pizza

Southern fried chicken, country gravy, smoked gouda, mozzarella, hot sauce, and pickled reds.


The Meat Lover's Pizza

Crumbled speck, sausage, prosciutto & ham cappy, savory sauce and mozzarella.



Steamed Littleneck Clams

Pancetta, celery, Calabrian chilis, garlic herb broth, and toasted crumbs.


Brick Oven Wings

Cherry peppers, garlic-herb butter, pecorino, charred lemon.


Chicken Meatballs

Spinach, white wine shallot sauce, and prosciutto dust.


Stuffed Baby Eggplant

Mozzarella, provolone, romano, herb, toasted crumbs and savory sauce.


Grilled Octopus

Chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, pickled reds, dill, crispy potatoes, charred lemon, evo, capers.


Warm Savory Goat Cheese Cake

Heirloom tomato salad, pistachio crust, balsamic glaze and toast points.


Crab Salad Napoleon

Roasted peppers, scallions, plum tomatoes, crispy wonton skins, basil oil, and sriracha aioli.



Burrata Salad

Arugula, grilled peaches, grilled asparagus, capers, peppadews, pickled reds, evo, lemon, balsamic glaze.


Grilled Romaine Salad

Cukes, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, red onion, pepperoncini, roasted peppers, toasted almonds, feta - dill vinaigrette.


Baby Spinach Salad

Strawberries, crispy chickpeas, smoked gouda, peppadews, red onion, and buttermilk ranch.



Grilled Asparagus


Sauteed Broccoli Rabe


Handcut French Fries


Picatta Risotto


Mac & Cheese


Between The Dough
sandwiches served with hand-cut french fries.

The Gristmill Burger

House blend (chuck, short rib, brisket), pancetta, roasted tomato, burrata, and garlic aioli.


Shrimp Po Boy

Southern-fried shrimp, lettuce, tomato, house dills and zesty tartar sauce.


Doughs To Remember

Smoked Mozzarella & Basil Gnudi

Roasted corn, heirloom grape tomatoes, corn broth, and herbs.


Cavatelli Bolognese

Milk braised ground beef, pork & veal, San Marzano, tomatoes and romano cheese.


Lemon Pepper Tagliatelle

Clams, shrimp, speck, roasted tomatoes, garlic herb broth.



Ground lamb, goat cheese ricotta, smoked gouda, rosemary, fresh tomato sauce, and olive tapenade.


Spaghetti Squash

Blistered cherry tomatoes, zucchini, white beans, garlic, roasted peppers, herbs, evo.



The Gristmill Chicken

Buttermilk brined & fried, roasted tomatoes, burrata, country gravy, ditalini & zucchini risotto.


Salmon Fillet

Broccoli rabe pesto, piccata risotto, roasted baby carrots.


Smokehouse BBQ Platter

Baby back ribs, chicken leg & thigh, shrimp, mac & cheese, and corn on the cob.


Boneless Pork Chops Milanese Style

Marinated & grilled, heirloom tomato salad, crispy potatoes, and balsamic glaze.


Shrimp & Grits

Creole scampi, tomatoes, scallions, jalapeno - cheddar grits, charred lemon.


Pan Roasted Black Angus Sirloin

Crispy lemon potatoes, creamed kale, brandy - peppercorn demi.


All of our desserts are handmade in house.

Cheesecake Du Jour

Johnny Cheesecakes choice, be sure to ask.


Panna Cotta

Topped with fresh fruit compote.


Banana Chocolate Tiramisu

Layers of fresh banana cream, chocolate ganache, and lady's fingers dipped in espresso and creme de cacao. Dusted with cocoa powder and topped with fresh whip.


Vanilla Bean Pound Cake

Topped with sweet basil ricotta & fresh strawberries. Served with vi ale strawberry gelato.


Via Gelato

Vanilla, deep dark chocolate, cherry, pistachio.


SlicePizza Places in East Rockaway, NY The Gristmill
Price: $$