The Gristmill

144 Main St, East Rockaway, NY 11518

Currently ClosedFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give The Gristmill a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

12'' personal pizzas. All of our brick oven pizzas can be made into calzones.
Margherita Pizza$12.00
Fresh mozzarella, basil, evo, tomato sauce.
The Sophia Siciliana Pizza$16.00
Ricotta cheese, garlic, grated romano, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, arugula, an balsamic glaze.
The Sicilian Pizza$16.00
Prosciutto, shaved parmesan, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, arugula.
Clam Tastic Pizza$17.00
Chopped clams, white seafood sauce, seasoned bread crumbs.
Messina Pizza$17.00
Fresh burrata mozzarella, roasted peppers, red onion, baby arugula, and fig glaze.
Napolitano Pizza$16.00
Broccoli rabe, garlic, crumbled sausage, hot cherry peppers, and mozzarella.
The GMC Pizza$17.00
Southern fried chicken, country gravy, smoked gouda, mozzarella, hot sauce, and pickled reds.
The Meat Lover's Pizza$17.00
Crumbled speck, sausage, prosciutto & ham cappy, savory sauce and mozzarella.
Steamed Littleneck Clams$16.00
Pancetta, celery, Calabrian chilis, garlic herb broth, and toasted crumbs.
Brick Oven Wings$14.00
Cherry peppers, garlic-herb butter, pecorino, charred lemon.
Chicken Meatballs$15.00
Spinach, white wine shallot sauce, and prosciutto dust.
Stuffed Baby Eggplant$14.00
Mozzarella, provolone, romano, herb, toasted crumbs and savory sauce.
Grilled Octopus$17.00
Chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, pickled reds, dill, crispy potatoes, charred lemon, evo, capers.
Warm Savory Goat Cheese Cake$15.00
Heirloom tomato salad, pistachio crust, balsamic glaze and toast points.
Crab Salad Napoleon$18.00
Roasted peppers, scallions, plum tomatoes, crispy wonton skins, basil oil, and sriracha aioli.
Burrata Salad$16.00
Arugula, grilled peaches, grilled asparagus, capers, peppadews, pickled reds, evo, lemon, balsamic glaze.
Grilled Romaine Salad$14.00
Cukes, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, red onion, pepperoncini, roasted peppers, toasted almonds, feta - dill vinaigrette.
Baby Spinach Salad$15.00
Strawberries, crispy chickpeas, smoked gouda, peppadews, red onion, and buttermilk ranch.
Grilled Asparagus$7.00
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe$7.00
Handcut French Fries$7.00
Picatta Risotto$10.00
Mac & Cheese$12.00
sandwiches served with hand-cut french fries.
The Gristmill Burger$17.00
House blend (chuck, short rib, brisket), pancetta, roasted tomato, burrata, and garlic aioli.
Shrimp Po Boy$16.00
Southern-fried shrimp, lettuce, tomato, house dills and zesty tartar sauce.
Smoked Mozzarella & Basil Gnudi$22.00
Roasted corn, heirloom grape tomatoes, corn broth, and herbs.
Cavatelli Bolognese$22.00
Milk braised ground beef, pork & veal, San Marzano, tomatoes and romano cheese.
Lemon Pepper Tagliatelle$28.00
Clams, shrimp, speck, roasted tomatoes, garlic herb broth.
Ground lamb, goat cheese ricotta, smoked gouda, rosemary, fresh tomato sauce, and olive tapenade.
Spaghetti Squash$18.00
Blistered cherry tomatoes, zucchini, white beans, garlic, roasted peppers, herbs, evo.
The Gristmill Chicken$22.00
Buttermilk brined & fried, roasted tomatoes, burrata, country gravy, ditalini & zucchini risotto.
Salmon Fillet$26.00
Broccoli rabe pesto, piccata risotto, roasted baby carrots.
Smokehouse BBQ Platter$28.00
Baby back ribs, chicken leg & thigh, shrimp, mac & cheese, and corn on the cob.
Boneless Pork Chops Milanese Style$26.00
Marinated & grilled, heirloom tomato salad, crispy potatoes, and balsamic glaze.
Shrimp & Grits$27.00
Creole scampi, tomatoes, scallions, jalapeno - cheddar grits, charred lemon.
Pan Roasted Black Angus Sirloin$35.00
Crispy lemon potatoes, creamed kale, brandy - peppercorn demi.
All of our desserts are handmade in house.
Cheesecake Du Jour$11.00
Johnny Cheesecakes choice, be sure to ask.
Panna Cotta$9.00
Topped with fresh fruit compote.
Banana Chocolate Tiramisu$11.00
Layers of fresh banana cream, chocolate ganache, and lady's fingers dipped in espresso and creme de cacao. Dusted with cocoa powder and topped with fresh whip.
Vanilla Bean Pound Cake$12.00
Topped with sweet basil ricotta & fresh strawberries. Served with vi ale strawberry gelato.
Via Gelato$4.00
Vanilla, deep dark chocolate, cherry, pistachio.