Skip to main content
The Pizza Mafia Grill

The Pizza Mafia Grill

1276 Fairport Rd, Fairport, NY 14450
585-673-2020

Open until 8:00 PM

Full Hours
    pizza
    Pizza

    Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $9.00

    specialty-pizzas
    Specialty Pizzas

    Mangia! Pizza

    Picture bruschetta, but on a pizza. Garlic sauce, crispy prosciutto, mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, and balsamic reduction drizzle.

    $12.50


    Goodfellas Pizza

    Red sauce & garlic sauce mixed with whipped ricotta, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheese.

    $12.00


    How You Doin Pizza

    Garlic sauce, whipped ricotta, tomato, and spinach.

    $11.75


    Bada Bing Pizza

    Red sauce, house-made meatballs, sausage, whipped ricotta, banana peppers, caramelized onions, and mozzarella.

    $13.75


    Bills Mafia Pizza

    House-made sweet buffalo sauce, chicken, crispy prosciutto, red onion, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, and ranch drizzle.

    $11.75

    pizza-by-the-slice
    Pizza By The Slice

    Cheese Pizza Slice

    $3.50

    fried-goods
    Fried Goods

    Mozzarella Sticks

    Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce.

    $6.50


    French Fries

    Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior & a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

    $4.00


    Chicken Fingers

    Breaded & fried chicken strips.

    $10.00

    soups
    Soups

    Daily Soup

    $4.99

    salads
    Salads

    House Salad

    Tomatoes, red onions, artichokes, light Parmesan, and light balsamic vinaigrette.

    $8.99


    Caesar Salad

    Red onions, croutons, cannellini beans, and Caesar dressing.

    $9.99


    Buffa Love Salad

    Healthy game-day option. Shredded chicken with buffalo sauce, tomatoes, red onion, and bleu cheese.

    $12.00


    Off The Boat Salad

    A light pour of our house-made sauce over a giant meatball with fresh greens and ricotta on the side.

    $13.00

    bread
    Bread

    Fresh Bread

    $2.00


    Pizza Dough

    $4.50

    side-sauces
    Side Sauces

    Side of Sauce

    $0.75


    Side of Bleu Cheese Sauce

    $0.75


    Side of Ranch Sauce

    $0.75


    Side of BBQ Sauce

    $0.75


    Side of Meatballs

    $4.00

    wings
    Wings

    Jumbo Wings

    Deep-fried chicken wings with your choice of sauce.

    $14.49


    Boneless Wings

    Boneless chicken breast coated in breading.

    $10.00

    dinners
    Dinners

    Italian Chili

    Mafia original.

    $7.95


    Parmesan Dinner

    Uncle Nicks Parm Dinner. Your choice of chicken or eggplant over pasta and topped with house-made sauce.

    $11.99


    Sunday Dinner

    Grampa Jim's homemade sauce, meatballs & sausage. Served with garlic toast.

    $11.99


    Stuffed Shells Dinner

    Served with garlic toast.

    $11.99


    Fish Fry

    Beer battered and flash-fried haddock served with fries and coleslaw.

    $14.99

    something-sweet
    Something Sweet

    Cannolis

    Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.

    $5.99


    Cookies

    $2.50


    Fried Dough

    $5.00


    Italian Spumoni

    $6.50


    Italian Ice

    $4.99


    Dippin Dots

    $3.50

    drinks
    Drinks

    Fountain Drink

    $3.00


    Drink

    $3.00


    Fizz

    $2.00


    Water

    $2.00


    Gatorade

    $3.00

    SliceNYFairport14450 The Pizza Mafia Grill
    Price: $$