Fluffy's Cafe & Pizzeria

370 W 58Th St, New York, NY 10019

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Fluffy's Cafe & Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Pies available starting 11:30 am. every day!
  • Plain Cheese Pizza Pie$19.50
    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
  • Pepperoni Pizza Pie$24.95
  • Bacon Pizza Pie$24.95
  • Mushroom Pizza Pie$24.95
  • White Pizza Pie$27.95
    With Ricotta, mozzarella and Parmesan cheeses. No sauce.
  • Vegetable Pizza Pie$27.95
    With mixed vegetables.
  • Sausage Pizza Pie$27.95
  • Sausage & Peppers Pizza Pie$27.95
  • Pepperoni & Mushrooms Pizza Pie$27.95
  • Pepperoni & Bacon Pizza Pie$27.95
  • Pepperoni, Peppers & Onions Pizza Pie$27.95
  • Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza Pie$29.95
  • Chicken & Broccoli Pizza Pie$29.95
  • BBQ Chicken Pizza Pie$29.95
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza Pie$29.95
  • Margherita Pizza Pie$29.95
    With fresh mozzarella cheese, tomato & basil.
  • Hawaiian Pizza Pie$29.95
    With ham & sweet pineapple chunks.
  • Baked Ziti Pizza Pie$29.95
    With penne pasta & vodka sauce.
  • Mexican Pizza Pie$33.50
    With ground beef, jalapenos, cheddar cheese & onions.
  • Philly Steak Pizza Pie$33.50
    With freshly sliced shredded beef, green peppers & onions.
  • Meat Lovers Pizza Pie$33.50
    With bacon, pepperoni & sausage.
  • Gluten Free Pie$12.00
  • Plain Cheese Pizza Slice$2.75
  • Pepperoni Pizza Slice$3.50
  • Bacon Pizza Slice$3.50
  • Mushroom Pizza Slice$3.50
  • White Pizza Slice$3.95
    Ricotta, mozzarella and Parmesan cheeses. No sauce.
  • Mixed Vegetable Pizza Slice$3.95
  • Sausage & Peppers Pizza Slice$3.95
  • Pepperoni & Mushrooms Pizza Slice$3.95
  • Pepperoni & Bacon Pizza Slice$3.95
  • Pepperoni, Peppers & Onions Pizza Slice$3.95
  • Margherita Pizza Slice$4.50
  • Hawaiian Pizza Slice$4.50
    With ham & sweet pineapple chunks.
  • Baked Ziti Pizza Slice$4.50
  • Chicken & Broccoli Pizza Slice$4.50
  • BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice$4.50
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice$4.50
  • Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza Slice$4.50
  • Meat Lovers Pizza Slice$5.25
    With bacon, pepperoni & sausage.
  • Sicilian Pizza Slice$3.75
  • Sicilian with Pepperoni Pizza Slice$4.50
Available from 11:00 am.
  • Soup of the Day$4.95 +
    Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
Fresh. All Natural. Locally Grown When Possible.
  • Custom Garden Salads$8.95
    Includes choice of Salad Greens & 5 Toss-Ins.
  • Custom Quinoa$8.95
    Includes choice of Base & 4 Toss-Ins.
  • Custom Brown Rice Bowls$8.95
    Includes choice of Base & 4 Toss-Ins.
Fries available from 11:00 am.
  • Steak Cut French Fries$4.50
  • Steak Cut Cheese Fries$5.95
  • Tuna Salad Sandwich$6.95
    With lettuce and tomatoes.
  • Chicken Salad Sandwich$6.95
    With lettuce and tomatoes.
  • Egg Salad Sandwich$6.95
    With lettuce and tomatoes.
  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich$4.95
  • BLT Sandwich$5.95
    With bacon, lettuce and tomato.
  • Club Sandwich$8.95
    With bacon, lettuce and tomato.
  • Ham & Swiss Croissant$5.95
  • Imported Smoked Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich$12.75
    With sliced tomato, red onions, capers and cream cheese on a bagel.
Made with 100% fresh premium chicken cutlets. Served with lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles & Russian dressing on a brioche roll with a small side of potato chips.
  • Crispy Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich$7.95
  • Spicy Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich$7.95
  • Char-Grilled Chicken Cutlet Sandwich$7.95
Hot or Cold.
  • Adobo Chicken Sandwich$8.95
    Cajun chicken with salsa, avocado, vegetables and chipotle dressing served on 7 grain bread.
  • California Tuna Sandwich$8.95
    With alfalfa sprouts, avocado, lettuce and low fat mayonnaise in pita pocket.
  • Grilled Chicken Pita Sandwich$8.95
    With lettuce, tomatoes, peppers and nonfat garlic yogurt dressing served on pita bread.
  • Applewood Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich$8.95
    With Brie cheese, plum tomatoes, green leaf lettuce and honey mustard on a crispy french baguette.
  • Rare Roast Beef Sandwich$8.95
    Roasted bell peppers, cheddar cheese, plum tomatoes, arugula, red onion and horseradish relish on onion ciabatta.
  • Prosciutto & Mozzarella Sandwich$8.95
    Roasted peppers, sliced Prosciutto ham, fresh Mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes and pesto dressing on a baguette.
  • Fresh Avocado & Alfalfa Sprouts Sandwich$8.95
    With basil pesto on walnut pullman bread.
Made with 100% fresh sliced roast beef. Served on hero roll with grilled peppers & onions.
  • Classic Steak$8.95
  • Philly Cheesesteak$9.95
    With choice of cheese.
  • Cheesesteak Melt$9.95
    Swiss cheese, grilled onions & thousand island dressing.
  • Mushroom Philly$10.50
    Sauteed mushrooms & choice of cheese.
  • Pizza Cheesesteak$10.50
    Mozzarella cheese & fresh marinara sauce.
  • Southwestern Philly$10.50
    Pepper Jack cheese, jalapenos, grilled onions & chipotle mayo.
  • Bacon Philly$11.50
    Crispy bacon & choice of cheese.
  • Barbecue Philly$11.50
    Crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, griled onions & barbecue sauce.
  • Philly Club$11.50
    Crispy bacon, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
  • Italian Club Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Turkey, ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese and red onion aioli on whole wheat panini.
  • Chicken Fajita Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Grilled chicken breast, pico de gallo, shredded cheddar, shredded mozzarella and chipotle mayo on sundried-tomato panini.
  • Turkey Bacon Guacamole Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Turkey breast, crispy smoked bacon, pepperjack cheese, guacamole and ranch dressing on spinach panini.
  • Chipotle Chicken Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Grilled chicken, sliced avocado, cherry tomatoes, Muenster cheese and chipotle mayo on white panini.
  • Sierra Turkey Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Fresh roasted turkey with pepperjack cheese and southwestern chipotle on whole wheat panini.
  • Tuscan Melt Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto dressing on spinach panini.
  • Baked Chicken Parmigiana Panini$8.95
    Served hot. Oven baked breaded chicken cutlet with fresh homemade marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil on sundried-tomato panini.
Made with 8 oz. of 100% fresh ground beef. Served with lettuce, tomato & pickle on a brioche bun.
  • Classic Burger$7.95
  • Cheeseburger$8.95
    With choice of cheese.
  • Pizza Burger$8.95
    Mozzarella cheese & marinara sauce.
  • Mushrooms Swiss Burger$9.95
  • Brooklyn Burger$9.95
    Sauteed peppers, onions, mushrooms & A1 steak sauce.
  • Barbecue Burger$9.95
    Cheddar cheese, raw onions & barbecue sauce.
  • California Burger$9.95
    Fresh avocado & raw onions.
  • Southwestern Burger$9.95
    Pepperjack cheese, jalapenos, fried onions & chipotle-mayo.
  • Ultimate Cheeseburger$9.95
    American cheese, fried onions, mayo, mustard & relish. New York's best!
  • Bacon Cheeseburger$10.95
    Crispy bacon & choice of cheese.
  • Hawaiian Burger$10.95
    Provolone cheese, ham, pineapple, raw onions & teriyaki sauce.
  • Super Burger$11.95
    Swiss cheese, mushrooms, crispy bacon & fried onions.
  • Custom Hot Pastas$8.95
    Includes choice of Pasta, Sauce & 3 Toss-Ins.
A Taste of the Orient, Made Your Way.
  • Custom Stir Fry$8.95
    Includes choice of Stir Fry Base & 3 Toss-Ins.
  • Specialty Cakes$5.95
  • Scrumptious Pastries$5.95
  • Sweet Delights$3.95
  • Jumbo Cookies$2.95
  • Jumbo Yogurt Muffins$2.95
  • Sweet Danishes$2.95
Available all Day.
  • Greek Yogurt Parfait$4.50 +
    Vanilla or strawberry.
  • Fresh Fruit Salad Bowl$5.50
  • Strawberry & Banana Smoothie$4.95 +
  • Four Berry Blast Smoothie$4.95 +
  • Poland Spring$1.50 +
  • Snapple$2.00
  • Soda$1.50 +
  • Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice$2.95 +
  • Tropicana Orange Juice$2.95
  • Vitamin Water$2.95
  • Chocolate Milk$2.95
  • Nantucket Nectars$2.95
  • Coconut Water$2.95
  • Gatorade$2.95
  • Bai Antioxidant Infusions$2.95
  • Red Bull$2.95
  • Pellegrino$2.00