Skip to main content
Insatiable Eats Pastaria & Restaurant

Insatiable Eats Pastaria & Restaurant

300 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901
631-868-5493

Order AheadWe open at 11:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
Skip to first category
pizza-alla-pala
Pizza Alla Pala

Classica Pizza

San marzano pomodoro sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$8.00

Classica Pizza

Capricciosa Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, artichokes, mushrooms, black olives, ham, basil.

$12.00

Margherita Verace Pizza

Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil.

$8.00

Tartufina Bianca Pizza

Buffalo ricotta, fresh mozzarella, mascarpone, shaved truffles.

$14.00

Calabrese Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, spicy salami, fresh basil.

$10.00

antipasto
Antipasto
Small bites & small plates.

Antipasto Misto di Verdure

Broccoli rabe, mushrooms trifolati, Sicilian eggplant caponata, marinated olives and parmesan, five bean salad, string bean saad.

$21.00

Mozzarella in Carozza with Salad

Crispy crusted bread with melted mozzarella, pomodoro sauce.

$12.00

Affettati Misti

Imported Italian cured meats and cheese Served with handmade bread sticks.

$31.00

Local Mussels

Red, white or fra diavolo style.

$18.00

Prosciutto Di Parma Con Mozzarella

Aged prosciutto, fresh handmade mozzarella, arugula salad and crostini.

$24.00

Salumi Board

Prosciuttoo di parma, mortadella, capicola, eggplant caponata, stuffed peppers. For la famiglia.

$31.00

Fritto Misto

Fried calamari, shrimp, zucchini, basil aioli.

$20.00

Polpette Signature Meatballs

$22.00

Gnocco Fritto

Fried hallow dough, buffalo ricotta, prosciutto di Parma.

$22.00

insalate
Insalate
Served over seasonal greens with signature dressing.

Beets Salad

Roasted beets, red onions, goat cheese puff, raspberry vinaigrette.

$18.00

Caprese Salad

Heirloom tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil.

$16.00

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, house croutons, shaved parmesan cheese, fresh anchovy dressing.

$12.00

Giardiniera Salad

Mixed greens, seasonal vegetables, aged balsamic dressing.

$16.00

rosticceria
Rosticceria
Italian small bites & specialties.

Arancini Messinesi

Crispy risotto balls filled with meat ragu.

$5.00

Calzone Al Forno O Fritto

Imported tuma cheese, anchovies, escarole, fresh tomatoes.

$6.00

Arancini Bianco

Crispy risotto balls filled with bechamel, prosciutto cotto.

$6.00

Calzone Tradizionale

Choice of: Broccoli and spinach; chicken and mozzarella; eggplant and ricotta; sausage and pepper.

$8.00

Mozzarella In Carozza Bianca

Crispy bread filled with fresh mozzarella cheese.

$5.00

Pitoni Messinese Calzone

Fried calzone with choice of: curly escarole, fresh anchovies, diced tomatoes, mozzarella cheese or Italian ham and cheese.

$7.00

Mini Pizzette

Individual mini pizza; choose from: margherita verace, calabrese, capricciosa, tartufina bianca, patate e salsiccia.

$4.00

pizza-ripiena-sandwiches
Pizza Ripiena Sandwiches
Filled focaccia sandwiches.

IL Americano Sandwich

Roast beef, onion porcini cream, tomato, arugula.

$13.00

IL Laziate Sandwich

Porchetta, roasted pepper cream, grilled vegetables, arugula.

$13.00

IL Bergamo Sandwich

Pistachio cream, stracciatella, sun dried tomato, spicy zucchini, arugula.

$11.00

IL Napoletano Sandwich

Mozzarella, tomato, basil.

$10.00

IL Calabrese Sandwich

Capocollo, stracchino, truffle cream, arugula.

$13.00

IL Sardinian Sandwich

Gorgonzola, spicy zucchini, spicy eggplant, sun-dried tomato, arugula.

$12.00

IL Lombardino Sandwich

Prosciutto cotto, mozzarella, truffle cream, spicy eggplant.

$12.00

IL Siciliano Sandwich

Mortadella, stracciatella, pistachio cream, pistachio.

$13.00

IL Parmigiano Sandwich

Parma prosciutto, pamigian toscano, truffle cream, arugula.

$13.00

IL Toscano Sandwich

Prosciutto toscano, mozzarella, tomato, basil.

$12.00

IL Romano Sandwich

Salame, pecorino cream, artichoke cream, spicy eggplant.

$11.00

IL Venetian Sandwich

Porchetta, gorgonzola, pistachio cream.

$11.00

italian-paninis
Italian Paninis
Warm sandwiches on Italian bread.

Caprese Panini

Heirloom tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil.

$12.00

Pollo Panini

Crispy chicken cutlet, arugula, shaved parmesan, balsamic drizzle.

$13.00

Melanzane Panini

Roasted eggplant, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes.

$12.00

Bistecca Panini

Prime steak filet, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes.

$13.00

Di Tonno Panini

Italian tuna, black olive tapenade, red onions, cucumbers.

$14.00

Vitello Panini

Crispy veal cutlet, arugula, shaved parmesan, balsamic drizzle.

$14.00

Petto Di Pollo Panini

Grilled chicken breast, mushrooms, fontina cheese.

$13.00

Verdure Panini

Roasted seasonal vegetables, sun-dried tomato pesto.

$12.00

insatiable-burgers
Insatiable Burgers
Served on house roll with signature fries.

Barrila Burger

Angus beef, caramelized onions, lettuce, tomato, cheese.

$13.00

Baby Bella Melt Burger

Roasted portobello mushrooms with sauteed bell peppers, mozzarella cheese.

$12.00

Flounder Fritto Burger

Crispy local white fish filet with lettuce, tomato, house tartar sauce.

$15.00

la-pastaria
La Pastaria
Fresh artisan pasta & signature sauces.

Bucatini Amatriciana

Guanciale, tomatoes, red pepper flakes.

$18.00

Frutti Di Mare Alla Fra Diavolo

Gulf shrimp, local squid, p.e.i mussels, tomatoes, pepperoncino.

$29.00

Lo Spaghetto Al Pomodoro

San Marzano tomatoes, fresh basil, sea salt.

$16.00

Linguine Vongole

Local clams, garlic white wine sauce.

$26.00

Agnolotti Spinach Ravioli

Choice of mushroom or Pomodoro sauce.

$16.00

Pappardelle Costola Breve Ragu

Braised short ribs in tomato-based ragu.

$22.00

Fettuccine Bolognese

Traditional meat ragu.

$18.00

Lobster Ravioli

Fresh poached lobster filling, cacacha sauce.

$28.00

Paccheri Broccoli & Salsiccia

Broccoli, Italian sausage, garlic and oil.

$18.00

Risotto Funghi

Creamy vialone rice, mushrooms, parmesan cheese.

$18.00

Pansotti Alla Norma

Eggplant, fresh tomatoes, basil.

$18.00

Gnocchi Gorgonzola

Handmade potato dumplings with gorgonzola sauce, toasted pine nuts.

$18.00

Penne Pesto

Basil, parmesan cheese, pine nuts.

$18.00

Open Faced Lasagna

Short ribs meat ragu, mozzarella, ricotta.

$22.00

Fettuccini Mare Monte

Sauteed mushrooms and tiger shrimp.

$28.00

Vegan Dish

Mediterranean couscous with roasted seasonal vegetables.

$22.00

Casarecci Ghiotta

Swordfish, tomatoes, capers, onions, green olives, raisins.

$26.00

Regional Pasta Tasting

Selection of any three pastas.

$38.00

il-macellaio
IL Macellaio
Our most traditional meat and poultry from the butcher.

Pollo Gustoso Dinner

Chicken dish with choice of preparation: Francaise, marsala, Milanese, parmigiana. Served with side dish of the day.

$32.00

Ossobuco Milanese Dinner

Braised veal shank over saffron risotto, parmesan cheese.

$45.00

Costola Di Vitello Dinner

Grilled or Milanese style. Veal chop valdostana bone-in veal chop with prosciutto di parma, mozzarella, spinach, gorgonzola sauce. Served with garlic-roasted mashed potatoes.

$48.00

Tagliata Di Manzo Dinner

Prime steak with Barolo wine reduction. Served with rosemary roasted potatoes and vegetable of the day.

$42.00

il-pescivendolo
IL Pescivendolo
Our fresh caught seafood selections from the ocean.

Braciole Di Pesce Spada

Grilled swordfish filled with fresh herbs, crispy bread crumbs. Served with side vegetable of the day.

$38.00

Shrimp Mare Chiaro

Sautéed shrimp over spinach, white wine tomato sauce.

$36.00

Roasted Salmon

Atlanticc filet, champagne mustard sauce. Served with vegetable of the day.

$34.00

Cacciucco

Fisherman's soup with local fish and shellfish.

$38.00

dolce
Dolce
La dolce vita.

Deconstructed Cannoli

Crispy pastry shells with fresh ricotta cream.

$12.00

Tiramisu

Layers of espresso-drenched ladyfingers separated by mascarpone cream and dusted with cocoa powder.

$12.00

Frutti Di Bosco

Cream-filled pastry with sponge cake and seasonal berries.

$12.00

Nutella Calzoncini

Calzone with chocolate hazelnut filling.

$12.00

Profiteroles

Cream puff pastry balls filled with vanilla cream and coated in chocolate.

$12.00

appetizers-catering
Appetizers Catering

Antipasti Misto Catering

Bocconcini mozzarella, cured meats, olives, tomatoes.

$104.00

Grigliata Mista Catering

Grilled calamari and shrimp, dipping sauce.

$110.00

Arancini Messinese Catering

Crispy risotto balls, meat ragu.

$36.00

Grilled Octopus Catering

Fresh herb mediterranean marinade.

$110.00

Arancini Formaggio Catering

Crispy risotto balls, bechamel, mozzarella

$30.00

Gnocco Fritto Catering

Fluffy fried dough bites, bufala mozzarella, prosciutto.

$42.00

Baked Clams Oreganata Catering

$73.00

Mozzarella In Carozza Catering

Fried mozzarella cheese sandwich, side of pomodoro sauce.

$36.00

Trio of Bruschetta Catering

Chicken mousse pate, wild mushrooms, tomato.

$69.00

Steamed Mussels Catering

Red, white or fra diavolo style.

$69.00

Burrata Catering

Fresh mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes.

$110.00

Potato Croquettes Catering

Crispy mashed potatoes bites, gorgonzola cheese.

$36.00

Calamari Fritti Catering

Fried calamari, pomodoro sauce.

$99.00

Polpette Di Marco Catering

Chicken, sausage and short ribs meatballs.

$87.00

Calamari Fritti Arrabiata Catering

Fried calamari, spicy pomodoro sauce.

$99.00

Stuffed Mushrooms Catering

Roasted and stuffed with herb bread crumbs, mushrooms.

$77.00

Eggplant Rollatini Catering

Roasted eggplant, pomodoro sauce.

$70.00

Salumi Board Catering

Italian cured meats, imported cheese, accompaniments.

$87.00

Fritto Misto Catering

Fried calamari, shrimp, basil aioli.

$105.00

salads-catering
Salads Catering

Arugula & Mushroom Salad Catering

Baby arugula, farm mushrooms, shaved parmesan cheese, creamy balsamic dressing.

$58.00

Roasted Beets & Goat Cheese Salad Catering

Seasonal greens, creamy balsamic dressing.

$61.00

Classic Caesar Salad Catering

Romaine, parmesan, house croutons, fresh anchovy dressing.

$58.00

Mixed Seafood Salad Catering

Calamari, octopus, scallops, shrimp, citrus vinaigrette.

$119.00

Giardiniera Salad Catering

Organic greens, seasonal vegetables, creamy balsamic dressing.

$58.00

Tri Color Salad Catering

Arugula, endive, radicchio, tomatoes, aged balsamic dressing.

$89.00

Insalata Caprese Catering

Fresh mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, basil pesto drizzle.

$61.00

pasta-catering
Pasta Catering
Pick your signature sauce & fresh pasta.

Pasta Alla Norma Catering

Roasted eggplant, basil tomato sauce.

$99.00

Pasta Nero Di Seppia Catering

Black squid & cuttlefish, tomato sauce.

$99.00

Pasta Alla Vodka Catering

Creamy pomodoro sauce.

$99.00

Pasta with Pesto Catering

Basil, garlic cloves, pine nuts, parmesan cheese.

$99.00

Pasta Amatriciana Catering

Guanciale roasted, tomato, red pepper flakes.

$99.00

Pasta Trapanese Catering

Almond, basil, plum tomatoes, pecorino cheese.

$99.00

Pasta Bolognese Catering

Signature meat ragu.

$99.00

Pasta Pomodoro Catering

Basil, tomato sauce.

$65.00

Pasta with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil Catering

$65.00

Pasta Polpettini & Pomodoro Catering

Meatballs, tomato sauce.

$99.00

Pasta Corn Sarde Catering

Anchovies, onions, golden raisins, pine nuts, sardines, wild fennel.

$125.00

Pasta Primavera Catering

Roasted seasonal vegetables, tomato.

$95.00

Pasta Costola Breve Catering

Braised short rib ragu.

$110.00

Salciccia E Broccoli Catering

Broccoli, sausage, garlic and oil.

$99.00

Pasta Ghiotta Catering

Capers, green olives, onions, raisins, tomatoes, swordfish.

$125.00

Pasta Frutti Di Mare Catering

Calamari, clams, mussels, shrimp (red, white or fra diavolo).

$125.00

Pasta Gorgonzola Catering

Imported gorgonzola, cream, parsley.

$99.00

Sicilian Lasagna Catering

Mini meatballs, tomato sauce, bechamel, mozzarella.

$95.00

meats-catering
Meats Catering
Served with insatiable sides & dinner rolls.

Chicken Francese Catering

Lemon beurre blanc sauce.

$99.00

Chicken Roulade Catering

$154.00

Veal Francese Catering

Lemon beurre blanc sauce.

$139.00

Chicken Saltimbocca Catering

Spinach and prosciutto.

$154.00

Chicken Marsala Catering

Mushrooms, marsala wine reduction.

$99.00

Seared Duck Catering

Cherry port wine reduction.

$209.00

Veal Marsala Catering

Mushrooms, marsala wine reduction.

$139.00

Brisket of Beef Catering

Horseradish creme fraiche, crispy onions.

$198.00

Chicken Palliard Catering

Fresh herb marinade.

$99.00

Roasted Pork Loin Catering

Mushroom sauce.

$140.00

Veal Palliard Catering

Fresh herb marinade.

$139.00

Filet Mignon Catering

Borolo wine reduction.

$252.00

Chicken Parmigiana Catering

Mozzarella, pomodoro sauce.

$99.00

Prime Rib Eye Catering

Au jus or bearnaise sauce.

$222.00

Veal Parmigiana Catering

Mozzarella, pomodoro sauce.

$139.00

Skirt Steak Catering

Argentinian chimichurri sauce.

$222.00

Chicken Piccata Catering

Lemon, white wine, capers.

$99.00

Italian Sausage & Peppers Catering

$94.00

Veal Piccata Catering

Lemon, white wine, capers.

$139.00

Roasted Rack of Lamb Catering

Au jus.

$194.00

Chicken Scarpariello Catering

Sausage, onions, peppers, tomatoes.

$99.00

Braised Short Ribs Catering

Red wine and tomato ragu.

$194.00

Veal Scarpariello Catering

Sausage, onions, peppers, tomatoes.

$139.00

Grilled Veal Chop Catering

$194.00

Chicken Sorrentino Catering

Eggplant, prosciutto, mozzarella, marsala.

$99.00

Milanese Veal Chop Catering

$194.00

Veal Sorrentino Catering

Eggplant, prosciutto, mozzarella, marsala.

$139.00

seafood-catering
Seafood Catering
Served with insatiable sides & dinner rolls.

Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes Catering

Chipotle mayo or creole remoulade.

$144.00

Stuffed Sole Catering

Crab stuffing, lemon beurre blanc sauce.

$192.00

Red Snapper Catering

Capers, olives, tomatoes, white wine.

$192.00

Swordfish Involtini Catering

Citrus beurre blanc sauce.

$216.00

Poached Chilian Sea Bass Catering

Wild fennel crust.

$274.00

Yellowfin Tuna Catering

Black & blue or crusted.

$216.00

Grilled Salmon Catering

Champagne mustard sauce.

$134.00

Lobster Pot Pie Catering

lobster, artichokes, asparagus, saffron velouté, savory pie crust.

$186.00

Poached Salmon Catering

Creamy dill sauce.

$134.00

Filet of Sole Oreganata Catering

Lemon fresh herbs, parmesan, beurre blanc sauce.

$134.00

Red Snapper Mare Chiaro Catering

Tomato, white wine sauce.

$134.00

shrimp-catering
Shrimp Catering
Served with insatiable sides & dinner rolls.

Shrimp Fra Diavolo Catering

Spicy pomodoro sauce.

$144.00

Shrimp Mare Chiaro Catering

Tomato, white wine sauce.

$144.00

Shrimp Francese Catering

Lemon butter white wine sauce.

$144.00

Shrimp Marinara Catering

Basil pomodoro sauce.

$144.00

Shrimp Scampi Catering

Herb bread crumbs, white wine sauce.

$144.00

Shrimp Parmigiana Catering

Mozzarella, pomodoro sauce.

$144.00

Shrimp Oreganata Catering

Herb bread crumbs, white wine sauce.

$144.00

carving-trays-catering
Carving Trays Catering
Served with palm rolls.

Bone-In Fresh Ham Catering

Pineapple chutney.

$149.00

Corned Beef Catering

Grain mustard, sauerkraut.

$149.00

Pork Loin Catering

Apple compote, roasted fennel.

$149.00

Top Round Roast Beef Catering

Horseradish sauce.

$149.00

Free-Range Turkey Catering

Cranberry relish, goblet gravy.

$149.00

Whole Wild Salmon Catering

Creamy dill sauce.

$149.00

insatiable-sides-catering
Insatiable Sides Catering

Grilled Asparagus Catering

$42.00

Scalloped Potatoes Catering

$54.00

Sauteed Spinach Catering

$42.00

Glazed Butternut Squash Catering

$54.00

Sauteed Broccoli Catering

$42.00

Roasted Seasonal Vegetables Catering

$59.00

Sauteed Broccoli Rabe Catering

$42.00

Carrot Cauliflower Mash Catering

$59.00

Escarole & Beans Catering

$48.00

Leek & Kale Cauliflower Mash Catering

$59.00

Roasted String Beans Catering

$42.00

String Bean Gremolata Catering

$59.00

Roasted Cauliflower Catering

$42.00

Chef's Macaroni & Cheese Catering

$59.00

Roasted Potatoes Catering

$36.00

Lobster Mac & Cheese Catering

$79.00

Mashed Potatoes Catering

$36.00

Ultimate Duck Stuffing Catering

$59.00

Truffled Mashed Potatoes Catering

$49.00

Ultimate Vegetarian Stuffing Catering

$49.00

Truffle Fries Catering

$58.00

Kale, Squash & Pancetta Pie Catering

$59.00

Signature Meatballs Catering

$58.00

Lemon Orzo Couscous Catering

$59.00

Creamed Spinach Catering

$54.00

Mediterranean Couscous Catering

$59.00

Braised Baby Carrots Catering

$54.00

Quinoa & Wild Rice Farro Catering

$59.00

Sauteed Bok Choy Catering

$54.00

Quinoa & Vegetable Catering

$59.00

Indian Corn Pudding Catering

$54.00

Honey Nut Corn Bread Catering

$29.00

Roasted Brussel Sprouts Catering

$54.00

Artisan Dinner Rolls Catering

$11.00

Roasted Portobello Mushrooms Catering

$54.00

imported-cheese-catering
Imported Cheese Catering
Chef's selection of imported cheese with fresh fruit & berries.

Imported Cheese Catering

Bufala, caccio tartufo, gorgonzola, parmesan, pecorino provolone, stracchino, goat cheese, and ricotta salata, fig spread, honey, membrillo, garnished with nuts, dried fruit, assorted berries, cantaloupe, honeydew melon, golden pineapple, seedless red grapes. Served with flatbreads and crackers.

$142.00

vegetarian-catering
Vegetarian Catering
Served with Artisan dinner rolls.

Eggplant Parmigiana Catering

Layered with mozzarella, pomodoro sauce.

$99.00

Pasta Primavera Catering

Fresh pasta, seasonal vegetables.

$99.00

Eggplant Rollatini Catering

Rolled and filled with mozzarella, pomodoro sauce.

$99.00

Roasted Seasonal Vegetables Catering

Mediterranean grains of the day.

$99.00

Eggplant Boats Catering

Roasted and filled with vegetable quinoa.

$99.00

charcuterie-catering
Charcuterie Catering
Chef's selection of Italian cured meats, imported cheese.

Charcuterie Catering

From Chef's cheese selection, bresaola, cacciatorini, finocchietto, mortadella, porketta, prosciutto di parma, soppressata, speck. Served with grissini bread sticks or warm bread basket, extra virgin olive oil, whipped butter.

$154.00

mediterranean-catering
Mediterranean Catering
Chef's selection of specialty vegetable offerings.

Mediterranean Catering

Roasted squash, zucchini, eggplant, fennel, mixed marinated peppers, feta cheese, chickpea hummus, Greek dolmas & tabbouleh. Served with assorted flatbreads and pita bread.

$128.00

tuscan-catering
Tuscan Catering
Chef's selection of bruschetta bar dips, spreads & more.

Tuscan Catering

Marinated artichokes, olives, mushrooms, fresh bocconcini, tomatoes, fresh basil, balsamic cannellini bean salad with leon, herbs tomatoes, eggplant caponata, tomato bruschetta with red onions, olive oil, herbs stuffed peppers in extra virgin olive oil. Served with assorted focaccia breads.

$147.00

desserts-catering
Desserts Catering
Italian inspired desserts.

Dark Chocolate Profiteroles Catering

$59.00

Frutti Di Bosco Cake Catering

$59.00

White Chocolate Profiteroles Catering

$59.00

Traditional Tiramisu Catering

$59.00

Deconstructed Cannoli Catering

$59.00

SliceNYRiverhead11901 Insatiable Eats Pastaria & Restaurant
Price: $$