Skip to main content
Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza

Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza

5601 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Includes house-made dough, choice of sauce (house red sauce or extra virgin olive oil), house-made mozzarella, fresh basil.

Create Your Own Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.


Coal Fired Pizza
All pizzas are 12 inches (8 slices).

Margherita Pizza

Mozzarella, fresh basil, parmesan-romano, extra virgin olive oil. Vegetarian.


Marinara Pizza

Sicilian oregano, roasted garlic, pomodoraccio tomatoes, house vegan ricotta. Vegetarian & vegan.


Casanova Pizza

Italian sausage, bacon, pepperoni,mozzarella, fresh herbs.


Trevi Fountain Pizza

Pepperoni, fresh ricotta, roasted garlic, sauteed spinach, mozzarella.


Bianco Pizza

Ricotta, parmesan romano, extra virgin olive oil, roasted garlic, mozzarella, fresh basil. Vegetarian.


Verdura Trebbiano Pizza

Asparagus, bell peppers, red onions, fresh spinach, mozzarella, fresh herbs, balsamic reduction. Vegetarian.


Venetian Jail Pizza

Italian sausage, mixed mushrooms, ricotta, goat cheese, fresh herbs, arugula, balsamic reduction.


Greenwich Village Pizza

Italian sausage, roasted peppers, caramelized onions, mozzarella, fresh garlic, fresh herbs.


Funky Funghi Pizza

Mixed mushrooms, gorgonzola, roasted garlic, mozzarella, fresh herbs, truffle oil. Vegetarian.


Aurora Borealis Pizza

Bacon, asparagus, Welsh cheddar, mozzarella, hot pepper flakes.


War & Peaches Pizza

Peach habanero bbq sauce, mojo pulled pork, mozzarella, roasted peppers, red onions, pickled jalapenos, goat cheese.


Bridge of Sighs

Grilled chicken, bacon, pomodoraccio tomatoes, gorgonzola, mozzarella, fresh herb.


Joy of The Mountains

Baked basil, oregano, roasted garlic, dry herbs, mozzarella, feta. Vegetarian.


Weekly Pie

Always changing - ask our staff.




Crispy risotto balls, goat cheese, marinara, parmesan- romano, fresh herbs. Vegetarian.


Coal Fired Wings

Roasted poblano buffalo sauce, brussel sprout slaw, blue cheese dip. Gluten-free.


Baked Macaroni

Cavatappi, four cheese mornay, herbed panko. Vegetarian.



Ohio beef and pork, marinara, parmesan-Ramano, fresh herbs, sourdough bread.


Smoked Trout Dip

Lemon, herbs, lucky cat ciabatta, rosemary. Gluten-free upon request.



Chicken, andouille, jasmine rice, green onion, ground file.


Roman Hummus

Greek olive oil, garlic, roman herbs & spices, sherry & pomegranate gastrique, coal-fired sourdough bread. Vegetarian & gluten-free upon request.


Fried Green Tomato Caprese

Plantain-crusted green tomatoes and mozzarella,fresh corn, mozzarella & heirloom tomato salad, basil, cilantro vinaigrette, balsamic reduction. Vegetarian & gluten-free.



Pear Salad

Baby greens, maple pecans, pear, goat cheese, roasted red peppers, rosemary balsamic vinaigrette. Vegetarian & gluten-free.


House Salad

Baby greens, cucumber, golden raisins, grape tomatoes, carrots, scallions, ricotta salata, salt roasted sunflower seed, champagne citrus vinaigrette. Gluten-free & vegetarian.


Seasonal Salad

Baby greens, snap peas, radish, green onion, dried blueberries, focaccia croutons, pecorino, fennel pollen & pear vinaigrette dressing. Gluten-free & gluten-free upon request.



Lemon Cheese Cake

No-bake, vanilla, raspberry coulis.


Chocolate Charlotte

Mousse, Bailey's, chocolate stick.


Seasonal Pie

Local produce, seasonal house whipped cream.


SliceOHWorthington43085 Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza
Price: $$