Skip to main content
Sam's New York Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Sam's New York Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant

2 E State St, Quarryville, PA 17566
717-786-3737

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Sam's New York Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Bravo Pizza
601 Commons Dr. Walmart Shopping Center in PA, Oxford, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
A Slice of Brooklyn
241 N Queen St, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Pasquale's Pizza & Carry Out
3104 Limestone Rd, Cochranville, PA
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Andre's Pizza
2209 Baltimore Pike, Oxford, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Espino's Pizza
323 W Lemon St, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Antonio's Pizza House
678 W Chestnut St, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Pizzaiola
344 W Main St, Leola, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Leola Pizza Place
23 W Main St, Leola, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Rosario's Pronto Pizza & Italian Restaurant
289 W Main St, Leola, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Signature Pizza Restaurant
360 Commons Dr, Parkesburg, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Finazzo's Italian Restaurant & Pizza
2121 New Holland Pike, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Nova's Pasta & Pizza
428 W 1st Ave, Parkesburg, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Rosa Rosa Pizzeria
1040 Harrisburg Pike, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Columbo's Pizza
1226 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Two Cousins Pizza Columbia Avenue Lancaster
1762 Columbia Ave, Lancaster, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
A Slice Of Brooklyn
808 E Main St, New Holland, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Caruso's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
2719 Lititz Pike, Neffsville, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Roma's Delight
2512 Delta Rd, Brogue, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Carini's Italian Restaurant
4204 Division Hwy, Blue Ball, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Milano Pizza & Pasta
149 Oakridge Dr, Mountville, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Milton's Pizza & Pasta
108 Airport Rd, Coatesville, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Venice Pizza & Pasta
1131 W Lincoln Hwy, Coatesville, PA
Open NowPickup Only
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
pizza
Pizza

Classic Cheese Pizza

Classic Cheese or create your own pizza.

$8.00


Meat Lover’s Pizza

Oh, heavenly meats! Sausage, hamburger, ham, bacon and of course, pepperoni.

$11.00


Veggie Licious Pizza

A garden of plenty on our veggie pizza with spinach, tomato, broccoli, black olives, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.

$11.00


White Pizza

Always a classic — garlic, ricotta cheese and mozzarella cheese, no sauce.

$9.00


Hawaiian Pizza

Don the hula skirts, boys and girls! This pizza is going hawaiian, packed with just the right amount of ham and pineapple. Aloha!

$11.00


Sam’s Special Pizza

Let us trick out your pizza sam’s ny style with lots of pepperoni, hamburger, sausage, bacon, onion, green peppers, black olives and mushrooms.

$11.00


Three Cheese Pizza

A cheese lover’s perfect pie. Smothered with mozzarella, provolone and parmesan cheese.

$11.00


Upside Down Pizza

Layers of provolone cheese topped with our homemade tomato sauce.

$10.00

gourmet-pizza
Gourmet Pizza

Spaghetti Pizza

Spaghetti tossed in our homemade tomato sauce and topped with grated parmesan and mozzarella

$10.00


Chicken Florentine Pizza

Grilled chicken, sliced tomato, red onions and baby spinach topped with alfredo sauce.

$11.00


Margherita Pizza

Our traditional tomato sauce topped with fresh mozzarella cheese and fresh basil.

$9.00


Taco Pizza

Ground beef flavored with our homemade taco seasoning topped with mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection.

$11.00


BBQ Chicken Pizza

Barbecued chicken breast and mozzarella cheese drizzled with bbq sauce.

$11.00


Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza

It’s like a burger on a pizza! Hamburger and bacon topped with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

$11.00


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

It’s getting hot in here! Crispy chicken drizzled with our hot sauce

$10.00


Bruschetta Pizza

Fresh tomato, garlic, basil, mozzarella cheese and balsamic vinegar

$9.00


Seafood Pizza

That’s right seafood lovers, a pizza just for you! Piled with shrimp and crabmeat. A real catch.

$14.00


Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Grilled chicken topped with crispy bacon and finished off with some creamy ranch dressing.

$11.00


Sandwich Pizza

A pizza sub! Our pizza crust brushed with garlic butter and stuffed with ham, provolone cheese, salami and capicola topped with lettuce and tomatoes.

$11.00


Messy Fry Pizza

Crispy french fries with bacon, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese and topped with ranch dressing.

$11.00


Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

Sliced steak topped with mozzarella cheese, american and cheddar.

$11.00

appetizers
Appetizers

Soup Of The Day

Call the restaurant for today's selection.

$4.95


Garlic Knots

Our homemade dough tied into a knot and baked, then tossed in olive oil, garlic and Parmesan cheese. Served with a side of sauce

$3.75


Breaded Mushrooms

Lightly breaded and deep fried to a golden brown.

$6.50


Chicken Fingers

Lightly breaded all white meat chicken breast tenders fried to a golden brown and served with choice of sauce

$6.75


Fried Shrimp & French Fries

Lightly breaded and deep fried to a golden brown, served with french fries and cocktail sauce

$7.25


Mozzarella Sticks

Lightly breaded and deep fried to a golden brown, served with french fries and cocktail sauce

$6.50


Calamari Fritti

Tender calamari lightly breaded and fried to a golden brown tossed with hot peppers

$8.25


Jalapeno Poppers

Delicious cheddar-stuffed jalapeños coated with a crispy breading and fried crisp. Cool it down with a side of ranch dressing

$6.50


Mac & Cheese Bites

Nuggets of deep-fried macaroni and cheese – a true indulgence! Served with a side of sauce

$6.75


Classic Onion Rings

Large sweet onion rings lightly breaded and fried to a golden brown

$5.50


Bruschetta

$6.95


Broccoli Cheddar Bites

These bites are delicious! Crispy breaded outer layer and cheddar cheese broccoli stuffed inside

$7.25

fries
Fries

French Fries

$2.95


Old Bay Fries

Covered in Old Bay seasoning with melted American on top.

$6.50


Seasoned Wedges

Thick-cut seasoned potato wedges

$3.95


Messy Fries

French fries smothered in bacon, mozzarella cheese and cheddar cheese served with a side of ranch

$7.95


Southwest Messy Fries

French fries topped with bbq sauce, bacon, jalapeños and mozzarella cheese

$7.95


Pizza Fries

French fries topped with tomato sauce, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese

$6.95

salad
Salad

Taco Salad

Freshly made tortilla bowl with your choice of seasoned beef or chicken, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese and ranch dressing

$9.50


House Salad

Fresh tomatoes, onions, carrots, mozzarella cheese, black olives and pepperoni on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce

$7.25


Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce topped with fresh parmesan cheese, crushed black pepper and garlic bread

$7.25


Chef Salad

Crisp iceberg lettuce garnished with tomatoes, onions, carrots, mozzarella cheese, black olives and pepperoni, finished with sliced ham and turkey

$8.25


Antipasto Salad

Ceberg lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, carrots, black olives, pepperoni, sliced ham, salami, capicola and provolone cheese, dressed with sweet peppers and banana peppers

$9.25


Chicken Salad

A bed of iceberg lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, carrots, mozzarella cheese, black olives and pepperoni.

$8.25


Greek Salad

Romaine lettuce topped with feta cheese, red onions, tomatoes and kalamata olives

$7.95


Grilled Shrimp Salad

A bed of iceberg lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, carrots, mozzarella cheese, black olives, pepperoni and 4 grilled jumbo shrimp.

$8.95


Spinach Salad

Spinach, roasted peppers, cucumbers, red onions and sliced oranges

$7.95


Country Crisp Salad

Romaine lettuce, granny smith apples, sliced oranges and sweet corn tossed in a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

$8.25

wings
Wings

Buffalo Wings

Our pizza is not the only thing ny inspired. Try our traditional drums and flats fried until crisp and bathed in your choice of sauce

$9.00


No Bones About It

Same great wings, no bones

$9.00

stromboli
Stromboli

Traditional Stromboli

Ham, cheese, salami, sausage, mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$10.00


Cheesesteak Stromboli

Sliced grilled steak with fried onions, mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$12.00


Calzone

With ricotta and ham.

$11.00


Special Stromboli

Ham, cheese, salami, sausage, pepperoni, hamburger, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$12.00


Vegetable Stromboli

Onion, mushroom, broccoli, spinach, green peppers, mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$10.00


Bbq Chicken Stromboli

Grilled chicken smothered in bbq sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$12.00


Buffalo Chicken Stromboli

Crispy chicken smothered in buffalo sauce and bleu cheese.

$12.00

cold-subs
Cold Subs

Ham Cheese & Capicola Sub

$6.75


Ham & Cheese Sub

$6.25


Tuna Fish With Cheese

$7.00


Turkey & Cheese Sub

Oven-roasted turkey and provolone cheese

$7.00


Italian Sub

Sam’s Italian sub made with freshly sliced ham, Genoa salami, Italian capicola and provolone cheese

$7.00


American Sub

Ham, American cheese, salami

$6.75


Sandwich Pizza

Open face style sandwich using our pizza crust, garlic butter spread, Italian meats, provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato

$7.50

hot-subs
Hot Subs

Meatball Sub

Italian meatballs smothered in tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese then baked in the oven

$8.00


Sausage, Peppers & Onions Sub

Sweet italian sausage sautéed with fried onions and green peppers, topped with sauce and mozzarella cheese and baked

$8.00


Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

Sliced eggplant lightly breaded, smothered with sauce and mozzarella cheese and baked

$7.00


Chicken Parmigiana Sub

Chicken breast cutlet lightly breaded, smothered with sauce and mozzarella cheese and baked.

$7.50


Cheeseburger Sub

The long bun burger. Same great burger with melted american cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion with mayo (upon request) on a long rol

$8.50

steak-subs
Steak Subs

Bacon, Ranch & Chicken Cheesesteak Sub

Chopped chicken, bacon and American cheese, topped with ranch dressing

$8.50


Cajun Chicken Cheesesteak Sub

Chopped chicken, cajun seasoning and american cheese.

$8.50


Cheesesteak Sub

Traditional grilled sliced steak with sautéed onions, melted American cheese

$8.00


Cali Cheesesteak Sub

Traditional grilled sliced steak with sautéed onions, melted american, lettuce,

$8.50


Pizzaiola Cheesesteak

Traditional grilled sliced steak with sautéed onions, topped with mozzarella cheese then toasted in the oven till crispy

$8.50


Mushroom Cheesesteak Sub

Traditional grilled sliced steak with sautéed onions, mushrooms, melted american cheese and sauce

$8.50


Philadelphia Cheesesteak Sub

Traditional grilled sliced steak with sautéed onions, mushrooms, melted american cheese and sauce

$8.50


Cheesesteak Special Sub

Traditional grilled sliced steak with sautéed onions, mushrooms, melted american cheese and sauce

$9.00


Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak Sub

Chicken, fried onions, american cheese and sam’s buffalo sauce

$8.50

burgers
Burgers
All burgers come with fries.

Mega Burger

One pound of burger! Topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise

$15.95


Bacon Burger

Charbroiled burger topped with lots of crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and cheddar cheese

$10.75


Bbq Burger

Charbroiled burger topped with lots of crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and cheddar cheese

$10.75


Blue Cheese Burger

Charbroiled burger topped with chunky bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion

$9.50


Mushroom Burger

Charbroiled burger topped with mushrooms and provolone cheese

$9.50


Avocado Burger

Charbroiled burger topped with lettuce, tomato, onion cheddar cheese and fresh slices of avocado

$11.25


Backyard Burger

8oz charbroiled burger topped with american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions and mayo

$9.50


Firehouse Burger

8oz charbroiled burger topped with provolone cheese, jalapeños, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato & onions

$9.50

wraps
Wraps
Wraps are served with french fries

Turkey Avocado

Sliced turkey, bacon, avocado, lettuce and tomato on white wrap

$9.50


Philly Steak Wrap

Sliced grilled steak, fried onions and melted provolone cheese. Served with a side of sauce

$9.50


Chipotle Chicken Wrap

Crispy chicken mixed in chipotle sauce with iceberg lettuce and ranch dressing

$9.00


Taco Wrap

Chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese and ranch

$9.50


Turkey Bacon Ranch Wrap

Sliced turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, iceberg lettuce and ranch dressing

$9.50


Chicken Caesar Wrap

Cajun seasoned grilled chicken, melted provolone and our homemade bruschetta mix.

$9.00


Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Iceberg lettuce and crispy chicken tossed in Sam’s homemade Buffalo sauce

$9.00


Tuna Wrap

Tuna salad topped with american and provolone cheese, iceberg lettuce and tomato

$9.50


BLT Wrap

Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo

$8.50


Chicken Bruschetta Wrap

Cajun seasoned grilled chicken, melted provolone and our homemade bruschetta mix.

$9.00


Club Wrap

Turkey, ham, bacon, mayo, lettuce and tomatoes.

$8.50

panini
Panini

Cuban Panini

Pulled pork, sliced ham, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard

$9.50


Italian Panini

Ham, Genoa salami and melted provolone cheese

$9.50


Eggplant Panini

Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella cheese, basil with a side of sauce

$9.50


Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini

Grilled chicken, ham and melted provolone cheese served with a side of sweet honey mustard.

$9.50


Philly Steak Panini

Fresh sliced steak, fried onions and melted provolone cheese served with a side of sauce

$9.50


Patty Melt Panini

Angus beef burger, topped with grilled onions and melted american cheese.

$9.50


Veggie Panini

Fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, roasted peppers and pesto

$9.50


Chicken Pesto Panini

Tender grilled chicken breast,fresh melted mozzarella and pesto sauce

$9.50


Sausage Feta Panini

Italian sausage, roasted red peppers and feta cheese crumbles

$9.50

pasta
Pasta

California Pasta

A veggie lover’s dish! Broccoli, baby spinach, fresh peas, diced tomato and onions tossed with penne pasta in pink cream sauce

$11.95


Nonna’s Gnocchi

Gnocchi pasta tossed with fresh peas and sliced ham mixed in a cream sauce.

$11.95


Homemade Ravioli

Choice of cheese or meat stuffed into our homemade pasta delicately cooked and served with tomato sauce

$11.95


Lasagna

Homemade lasagna layered with ricotta, ground beef and shredded mozzarella, baked until melted and bubbly.

$11.95


Manicotti

Ricotta-filled pasta crepes topped with our homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese

$11.95


Stuffed Shells

Seashell pasta stuffed with ricotta cheese and topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella

$11.95


Salsiccia Napoletana

Sautéed Italian sausage and fresh basil tossed in marinara sauce and topped with Parmesan cheese

$13.50


Penne Alla Vodka

Penne pasta lightly sautéed with ham and cherry tomatoes in a vodka cream sauce

$12.95


Baked Mostaccioli

Penne pasta tossed with ricotta cheese and mozzarella, baked till bubbly

$12.95


Eggplant Parmigiana

Lightly breaded slices of eggplant fried to a golden brown, served with tomato sauce and sprinkled with shredded mozzarella cheese

$13.50


Spaghetti

$11.50


Tortellini Primavera

Cheese tortellini and mixed vegetables in a creamy Alfredo sauce

$11.95


Fettuccine Alfredo

Creamy parmesan cheese sauce tossed with fettuccine noodles and lightly dusted with grated parmesan cheese and fresh basil

$11.95


Fettuccine Carbonara

Fettuccine noodles tossed with sautéed bacon in our creamy alfredo sauce, finished with fresh basil and grated parmesan cheese .

$13.50

seafood
Seafood

Capelli D’angelo Adriatica

Shrimp, scallops & crabmeat in our homemade sauce.

$18.95


Cajun Shrimp Pasta

Cajun spiced shrimp, red onions, baby spinach, roasted peppers tossed in a cream sauce and served with penne pasta.

$15.50


Shrimp Scampi

Sautéed shrimp in garlic and olive oil and tossed in a lemon white wine sauce

$16.50


Creamy Shrimp Tortellini

Cheese tortellini and grilled shrimp tossed with baby spinach and cherry tomatoes in a creamy alfredo sauce

$14.95


Crab Alfredo

Colossal chunks of crabmeat tossed in our homemade alfredo sauce.

$16.95


Shrimp Alfredo

Shrimp and fettuccine tossed in a rich parmesan cream sauce

$16.50


Spaghetti With White Clam Sauce

A bed of pasta covered with our delicate white clam sauce made with fresh clams .

$15.95

chicken-more
Chicken & More

Fiesta Chicken

Homemade pita with crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing

$7.50


Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato and onions.

$8.50


Chicken Avocado Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast topped with fresh slices of avocado, bacon, cheddar cheese and chipotle sauce.

$10.00


Cajun Chicken Sandwich

Cajun seasoned grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

$8.50


Crab Cake Sandwich

Freshly made crab cake, lettuce, tomato, onions with a side of tartar sauce.

$10.95


Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla

Chicken and cheese quesadilla served with our homemade salsa and sour cream

$9.50

chicken-veal
Chicken & Veal
All served with your choice of spaghetti, fettuccine, penne or capellini pasta unless otherwise noted

Chicken Chesapeake

Grilled chicken breast topped with jumbo lump crab and drizzled with alfredo sauce.

$18.50


Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

Chicken breast grilled and tossed in our delicious traditional fettuccine alfredo finished with a light sprinkling of grated parmesan cheese and fresh basil

$14.95


Chicken Parmigiana

Chicken breast lightly breaded and baked to a crisp golden brown, smothered with our homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese

$16.50


Chicken Marsala

Thin-sliced breast of chicken pan sautéed with fresh mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.

$16.50


Chicken Brunello

Chicken breast and mushrooms sautéed in a roasted cream sauce.

$15.50


Veal Marsala

Veal scallopini and mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce

$16.99


Veal Parmigiana

Veal breaded with our homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$16.50

kids-menu
Kid's Menu

Kid’s Pasta

Half a portion of pasta or mac & cheese

$5.95


Kid’s Sticks

4 mozzarella sticks served with a side of sauce

$5.25


Chicken Tenders & French Fries

4 mozzarella sticks served with a side of sauce

$5.50


Mac & Cheese Bites

4 battered mac & cheese bites deep fried and served with a side of sauce and french fries

$5.25

SlicePizza Places in Quarryville, PA Sam's New York Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Price: $$