Skip to main content
Sugar River Pizza Company

Sugar River Pizza Company

700 Railroad St, New Glarus, WI 53574
608-527-5000

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Sugar River Pizza Company a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Villa Pizza Inn
1011 1st Center Ave, Brodhead, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza
1618 W Beltline Hwy, Madison, WI
New
Open Now$2.50 Delivery
logo
Jesse's Stone Oven Pizza & Pasta
2207 1st Center Ave, Brodhead, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Villa Dolce
1828 Parmenter St, Middleton, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Pizza Pit Extreme
1614 Monroe St, Madison, WI
Open Now$2.50 Delivery
logo
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
2360A Jackson St, Stoughton, WI
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Falbo Bros Pizzeria
406 S Park St, Madison, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Toppers Pizza
1368 Regent St, Madison, WI
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza
1301 Regent St, Madison, WI
New
Open Now$2.50 Delivery
logo
Naples 15
15 N Butler St, Madison, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Falbo Bros Pizzeria
101 River Place, Monona, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
115 E Broadway, Monona, WI
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Falbo Bros Pizzeria
1207 North Sherman Ave, Madison, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza
4556 Monona Dr, Madison, WI
New
Open Now$2.50 Delivery
logo
Cafe La Bellitalia
1026 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Papa Murphy's Take 'n' Bake Pizza
6030 Gemini Dr, Madison, WI
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Lazy Oaf Lounge
1617 N Stoughton Rd, Madison, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Rosati's Pizza
4933 Commercial Ave, Madison, WI
Open Now$4 Delivery
logo
Toppers Pizza
4128 E Washington Ave, Madison, WI
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza
2828 Prairie Lakes Dr, Sun Prairie, WI
New
Open Now$4.99 Delivery
logo
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
2041 McCoy Rd, Sun Prairie, WI
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Jim's Pizzeria
1103 Center Ave, Janesville, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Falbo Bros Pizzeria
1219 W Main St, Sun Prairie, WI
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Mac's Pizza Shack
2307 Milton Ave, Janesville, WI
Open Now$3.50 Delivery
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
build-your-own-pizza
Build Your Own Pizza

Thin & Crispy Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own.

$11.75


Hand-Tossed Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own.

$11.75


Thick & Whole Wheat Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own.

$11.75


Thick Crust Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own.

$12.25


Gluten Free Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own.

$16.75

specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza

Steak Pizza

Succulent layers of Rib-eye (all local beef!), with our steak sauce, green peppers, mushrooms, caramelized onions, and cheese.

$15.95


Baked Potato Pizza

Our home-made ranch with seasoned waffle fries, onions, bacon, and Wisconsin cheddar.

$13.95


Justin's Spinach Artichoke Pizza

Pair our homemade pesto with spinach-artichoke dip, with chicken, red peppers, tomatoes, and Wisconsin cheddar.

$13.95


Kicking Horse 4-Alarm Pizza

Spicy combination of pepperoni, house-spiced sausage, jalapenos, onions, and habañero. Make it a 5-alarm with extra habañero cheese!

$13.45


Mac-N-Cheese Pizza

Homemade mac-n-cheese (our mac-n-cheese is rated in the top 5 of Madison Area favorite comfort foods!) on our hand-tossed crust! OMG!

$13.95


Kickapoo Taco Pizza

Taco sauce covered with your choice of spicy local beef or chicken, black beans, tomatoes, and cheddar. Served with salsa, sour cream, lettuce, and homemade chips.

$13.95


Concord Chicken Bacon Pizza

Our homemade ranch sauce, grilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, cheddar, and onions. Finished with ranch swirl 'cause you can't have too much of our ranch sauce.

$13.95

flatbreads
Flatbreads

Grilled Chicken & Red Pepper Flatbread

Naan flatbread with our alfredo sauce, chicken, roasted red peppers and Parmesan cheese.

$7.95


Matt's Seasonal Flatbread

Naan flatbread spread with our fig and sun-dried tomato jam, topped with our pulled pork, pickled onions and cheese. Finished with sriracha mayo.

$9.45


Flatbread Salad

Spring greens with a grilled Naan flatbread spread with our homemade Parmesan garlic sauce, grilled chicken and cheese.

$8.45


Caprese Flatbread

Naan flatbread with pesto, fresh basil, tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. Finished with balsamic reduction drizzle

$6.45

plates-to-share
Plates to Share

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

A perfect blend of spinach and artichokes. Served hot with house chips.

$8.49


Marinara & Goat Cheese

An amazing combination of our house marinara with goat cheese served bubbly hot with our breadsticks.

$8.99


Stuffed Cheese Bread with Pepperoni

We start with our amazing cheese bread then stuff it with your choice of ingredients.

$7.49


Stuffed Cheese Bread with Bacon & Jalapeno

We start with our amazing cheese bread then stuff it with your choice of ingredients.

$8.49


Stuffed Cheese Bread with Extra Yummy Cheese

We start with our amazing cheese bread then stuff it with your choice of ingredients.

$7.49


Waffle Fries

Beer-Battered with local beer and just the right seasoning.

$4.49


Waffle Fries with Wisconsin Cheese & Bacon

Beer-Battered with local beer and just the right seasoning.

$8.99


Sugar River Papitas

Fried morsels of homemade dough smothered with Wisconsin Cheddar and bacon. Can't beat that combination!

$6.99


Grissini Bread Sticks

Whole wheat bread sticks, olive oil, herbs, and light cheese.

$4.49


Chicken Tenders

Whole pieces of white chicken lightly battered and fried. With your choice of amazing dipping sauces.

$7.59


Loaded Fries

Seasoned waffle fries, fully-loaded with bacon and Wisconsin cheddar.

$8.99


Mediterranean Small Bread

Spinach, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, feta cheese with our pesto sauce on our homemade bread. Yum!

$8.99


Cheese Curds

Chicken, tomatoes, onions and green peppers folded into a lightly grilled tortilla with cheddar and pepper-jack cheese. Served with salsa and sour cream.

$10.49


Hummus Mediterranean Plate

Our in-house made hummus served with cucumbers, chicken, Kalamata olives and grilled Naan bread.

$10.95


Onion Rings

Huge, lightly beer-battered (local beer) onion rings served with a sauce of your choice.

$8.99


Mac Cheese Bites

Mac cheese wrapped with pepper-jack cheese, lightly breaded and fried.

$6.99


Appetizer Platter

All your favorites on one platter. Cheese curds, Sriracha bites, waffle fries and onions rings! Two sauces of your choice.

$12.99


Bruschetta

Homemade bruschetta made with fresh diced tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, and olive oil served in a bowl alongside grilled baguette bread spread with our fig & sun-dried tomato jam; finished with a balsamic drizzle.

$8.99


Sriracha Bites

Chunks of chicken fried in a light Sriracha base batter. Try with our Ginger-Sesame dipping sauce.

$8.99


Bread Sticks

Classic breadsticks served with choice of sauce.

$3.69


Fried Ravioli with Pesto & Sriracha Mayo

Cheese-stuffed fried ravioli, plated on a base of our home-made pesto sauce, then finished with our sriracha mayo sauce.

$7.99


#1 Bone In Chicken Wings

Made to order with your choice of tossing and dipping sauce.

$10.99


#2 Bone In Chicken Wings

Made to order with your choice of tossing and dipping sauce.

$17.99


Cheese Bread

Our breadsticks topped with butter, herbs and two Wisconsin kinds of cheese.

$4.99


#½ Boneless Chicken Wings

With your choice of tossing and dipping sauces.

$8.99


#1 Boneless Chicken Wings

With your choice of tossing and dipping sauces.

$15.99

soup
Soup

Soup of the Day

Our soups are always homemade. Ask your server for today's custom creation.

$2.99

salads
Salads

Greek Salad

Mixed greens, kalamata olives, green peppers, tomatoes, feta & finished with a touch of basil.

$5.99


Caesar Salad

A delicious mix of romaine, sun-dried tomatoes, and homemade Caesar dressing. Homemade croutons and Parmesan.

$5.99


Taco Salad

Your choice of grilled chicken or seasoned beef with black beans, tomatoes and cheddar. Finished with a chopped cilantro/green onion mix. Chips, sour cream and salsa on the side or our taco salad dressing.

$5.99


Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad

Oven-roasted chicken, tomatoes, bacon, onions and in-house smoked cheddar.

$5.99


Garden Salad

Tomatoes, red onions, green peppers, cucumbers and cheddar.

$5.49


Crunchy Chicken Salad

Greens tossed with crisp chicken chunks, smoked cheddar, onions and peppers.

$5.99

grilled-sandwiches
Grilled Sandwiches

Steak Sandwich

Local rib-eye steak slices paired with our homemade steak sauce, caramelized onions and cheese.

$12.79


Clearwater Garden Sandwich

We grill fresh mushrooms, green peppers, red onions, tomatoes, cheese and roasted red peppers atop our basil-pesto sauce.

$8.45


Crunchy Chicken Sandwich

Lightly battered chicken paired with bacon, smoked Wisconsin cheddar, and our homemade sriracha mayo sauce.

$10.49


Cuban Sandwich

Grilled baguette loaded with pulled pork, Swiss cheese, Canadian bacon, and pickles with roasted garlic aioli and mustard.

$10.49


The "No Frills Pulled Pork" Sandwich

The showcase in this sandwich is the pulled pork. It's home-smoked pork served up Kansas City style with smoky BBQ, grilled onions and just a touch of cheese ('cause we are in Wisconsin').

$10.49


Classic Italian Sandwich

Layers of salami, prosciutto, pepperoni, cheese and arugula on a toasted baguette with Italian oil and vinegar.

$10.49


Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich

Layers of Canadian bacon, chicken, Swiss cheese and honey-mustard.

$10.49


Spinach-Artichoke Pesto Sandwich

Our spinach-artichoke dip with basil pesto, grilled chicken, spinach, and tomato.

$10.49


Caesar Club Sandwich

Best of both - Caesar salad on a baguette! We take Caesar salad, Parmesan cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, and chicken with homemade Caesar dressing.

$10.49


Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

BBQ base topped with lightly battered fried chicken tossed with our buffalo sauce, onions, jalapeños and habañero cheese. Smoking hot!

$10.49


Parmesan Chicken Sandwich

Battered and fried chicken breasts with just the right amount of marinara sauce and Parmesan cheese.

$10.99


Pastrami Reuben Sandwich

Tasty pastrami from Usinger's, sliced in our kitchen and served with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and our homemade thousand island on rye.

$10.49

pasta
Pasta

Chicken Parmesan Pasta

Lightly battered chicken smothered in our marinara sauce, topped with Parmesan and served over fettuccini noodles.

$10.99


Goat Cheese Alfredo with Fresh Asparagus Pasta

Fettuccini noodles tossed with our homemade goat cheese alfredo sauce, fresh asparagus, sweet roasted red peppers, and grilled chicken.

$10.99


Lasagna

A hearty award-winning Italian serving of our homemade lasagna featuring our meat sauce, ricotta, cheese, and tender lasagna noodles.

$10.99


Chicken Alfredo Pasta

Our homemade Alfredo sauce over fettuccine with chicken and mushrooms.

$10.99


Build Your Own Pasta

$10.99

kids-menu
Kids Menu
For kids under 6 years.

Kids Boneless Wings

$9.99


Kids One Topping Pizza

$9.99


Kids Mac N Cheese Pizza

$9.99


Kids Mac N Cheese

Our homemade Mac is a customer favorite!

$9.99


Kids Cheese Ravioli

$9.99


Kids Noodles

With your choice of pasta sauce, meat sauce or butter.

$9.99


Kids Chicken Tenders

$9.99


Kids Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$9.99


Kids Spaghetti

$9.99


Kids Drinks

Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Fanta Orange, Sprite, Mellow Yello, Barge's Root Beer, Lemon-Aide.

$0.90

sweet-finish
Sweet Finish

Cinnamon Nuggets

Our homemade dough balls fried to perfection, then tossed in cinnamon sugar. We toss the dough balls over vanilla ice cream then top with home-made whip cream, chocolate, and caramel drizzle. Enough for a table of 4 to enjoy!

$5.99


Cheesecake of the Day

Creamy cheesecake with seasonal flavors served with our home-made whip cream. Ask about our cheesecake of the day!

$5.99


Beignets

Our homemade dough balls tossed in powdered sugar!... Takes you to New Orleans on a Sunday morning!

$3.99

beverages
Beverages

Soda

Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Fanta Orange, Sprite, Mellow Yello, Barge's Root Beer, Lemon-Aide. Free Refills.

$1.95


Milk

$1.95


Chocolate Milk

$1.95


Apple Juice

$1.95


Ice Tea

Raspberry, Unsweetened.

$1.95


Coffee

$1.95


Tea

$1.95

SlicePizza Places in New Glarus, WI Sugar River Pizza Company
Price: $$