Bethpage is a census-designated area within the town of Oyster Bay, in Nassau County in the Borough of Long Island, in New York State. Bethpage has a population of approximately 17,000 residents as recorded by the United States census in 2019. Bethpage is home to a variety of places that attract visitors.

Most of these attractions are green spaces and natural escapes that can be hard to find around New York City. Some of these spaces are the Bethpage State Park, the Bethpage Community Pool, and the Bethpage Bikeway, all of which allow visitors to enjoy the fresh air and new views.

Bethpage is also home to a variety of different restaurants, eateries, coffee shops, and local dives. Here, however, we want to focus on pizza! Read on to find out what our picks for best pizza delivery, best pizza takeout, and best specialty pizzas are in and around Bethpage.

Bethpage is Known for New York City Pizza

Bethpage is close to the mid-northeastern epicenter of pizza: New York City. New York City has long been considered one of the several pizza style favorites around the nation, and Bethpage is another fan.

New York City pizzas are made by rolling out the dough until it is a thin circle. Next, the pizza maker stretches the pizza dough by hand to create a perfect circle with a very thin crust. Tomato sauce goes on top of the dough and the pizza is placed into the oven.

After a while, the pizza is taken out of the oven and shredded mozzarella cheese is added on top. At this point, if there are any toppings to add, they will be added too. Finally, the pizza returns to the oven to finish cooking. Once the cheese is melty and the crust is lightly golden brown, the pizza is removed from the oven, sliced into triangles, and served.

Best Delivery Pizza in Bethpage

Delivery pizza is always a perfect way to end the day or to celebrate the little things, like getting an A+ on a paper, finishing a big project, or an at-home date night. If you are in Bethpage, then the perfect place to order from is Gino’s of Tuscany.

Gino’s of Tuscany has a $2.50 delivery fee and has an average delivery time of approximately 40 to 55 minutes. This time depends on your order, your location, and how busy Gino’s of Tuscany is. They have no minimum spending requirement for delivery orders and you can order online, in-store, or over the phone for your convenience.

They serve delicious fresh traditional and specialty pizzas that are sure to satisfy your pizza craving. One of their yummy specialty pizzas is the Spinach and Artichoke pizza, which is topped with mozzarella cheese, onions, artichokes, and spinach. Another favorite is the Mac and Cheese pizza, which is loaded up with creamy mac and cheese, mozzarella, and romano cheese.

Best Pizza Takeout in Bethpage

Takeout pizza is a perfect way to take care of dinner, grab lunch, or settle a craving while out on the town. Villa Maria Pizzeria is a great place to hit in Bethpage for delicious pizza at affordable prices. Villa Maria Pizzeria offers both free delivery and has no minimum spending requirement for takeout orders. Pick-up time is typically 15 to 30 minutes, depending on the order.

The most popular pizzas at Villa Maria Pizzeria are the traditional Cheese Pizzas, the Sicilian pizzas, and the Grandma pizzas. They also offer a variety of delicious gourmet pizzas, like the Chicken, Bacon, Ranch pizza, the White Spinach pizza, the Salad pizza, and more.

Villa Maria Pizzeria also offers a variety of other menu items besides pizzas, like homemade soups, salads, side dishes, and wings to complete your takeout order. Order online, in-store, or over the phone today.

Best Pizza Near Bethpage

Westbury

Toskana Pizzeria Restuarant in Westbury is located just a short drive outside of Bethpage and has fantastic, authentic Italian cuisine including pizza. They offer many lunch specials, as well traditional and gourmet pizzas. Some of their specialties include thin-crust pizzas, White Pizzas, Margherita pizzas.

Syosset

Slightly north of Bethpage is Syosset, home to Lia’s Pizzeria. Here they serve authentic, delicious Italian cuisine including thin-crust Italian-style pizza. Additionally, they serve fantastic Italian dishes like pasta, salads, and more. Lia’s Pizzeria is also a catering service, so if you love their food, have them cater your next event. They offer takeout and dine-in options in their casual yet pleasant dining room with their friendly staff.

Old Bethpage

Villa Monte in Old Bethpage is the perfect place to go for tasty and quality Italian dishes, sub sandwiches, pasta, and authentic pizzas packed full of flavor. They offer dozens of house specialty pizzas like the shrimp scampi pizza and the spicy grandma pie.