Top Pizza Restaurants in Carle Place, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Carle Place: a local guide

Carle Place is a beautiful and peaceful town in New York, previously known as Mineola Park and Frog Hollow. The town is a perfect place to raise your kids, and it has excellent public schools; thus, you don’t have to worry about your children’s education. The residents care for each other, and some volunteer in community activities. That’s why many young professionals and families prefer settling in the town. When planning a picnic, you can visit Charles J. Fuschillo Park or 8th Street Field, and you’ll have a fabulous time. The parks offer excellent spots to enjoy your takeout meals while in Carle Place. If you love partying, get your dancing shoes ready since the town has terrific nightlife. Carle Place also offers opportunities to savor local delicacies such as bagels and pizza. Italian immigrants brought the first pizza to New York in the early 20th century, and the dish became famous in Carle Place in the mid 20th century. Make sure you attend the Famous Food Festival: Taste the World. The event allows people to sample cuisine from all over the world, and it’s a nice place to network and learn more about Carle Place.

Carle Place is Known for New York-style Pizza

It will be an oversight if you leave Carle Place without enjoying a New York-style pizza, which dominates many restaurants in the town. New York-style pizza came to Carle Place in the mid 20th century after being invented in New York City in 1905. New York-style pizza acquired some features from Neapolitan pizza from Naples, Italy. Lombardi’s Pizza was the brain behind the dish, and you can now order it from almost all Italian restaurants in Carle Place. The pizza has a thin crust topped with shredded mozzarella, tomato sauce, and you can also add your favorite toppings. New York pizza is identifiable due to its thick and fluffy crust around the edges, and most people prefer folding the slices into two while eating. You will need to preheat your oven to achieve a crispy bottom crust. You can season the sauce with grated parmesan cheese, red chili pepper flakes, dried oregano, and basil.

Best Delivery Pizza in Carle Place, New York

Angelo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante is a family-owned and managed pizzeria that has served in Carle Place for over 25 years. The restaurant offers the best Sicilian, Neapolitan, and grandma pizzas that you can order on Slice for delivery at a real bargain. Nuno and Dana Desousa own the restaurant, and both possess many years of experience in the food industry. They are behind the tasty dishes served at Angelo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante. The pizzeria offers over 20 specialty pizzas, and it will be nice to try their Primavera Neapolitan Pizza loaded with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, mushrooms, and zucchini. Top up the delivery order with a signature Capricciosa Pizza, and your tastebuds will thank you. The pizza has tasty toppings, including mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, broccoli, and sauce. If you only need a few slices to satisfy your pizza cravings, you can try slices of Pepperoni Pizza, and you will be tickled pink. Be sure to leave space for a Chicken Noodle Soup served with noodles and pieces of chicken meat.

Best Takeout Pizza in Carle Place, New York

Louie’s Pizzeria is a world-class restaurant in Carle Place serving delicious brick oven, deep-dish, grandma, and dessert pizzas. The restaurant also offers over 25 varieties of pasta dishes, and it should be your favorite place to grab a flavorful takeout meal after a long day at work or school. Their Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza is a safe bet. It has delicious toppings such as parmesan cheese, grilled chicken, and romaine lettuce. The restaurant prepares the pizzas right after you place your order, and you are guaranteed a fresh and mouth-watering meal. When ordering for a large group, consider adding Louie’s Salad Pie topped with gorgonzola cheese, tomato, mixed greens, and onions. You can also try pizza by the slice, and you will be pleased when you savor slices of a thick-crust Sicilian pizza with tomato sauce, basil, and mozzarella. Additionally, Louie’s Pizzeria serves heavenly seafood meals, and you can opt for a Shrimp Parmigiana. You will experience the delectable taste of fresh tomato sauce and two kinds of cheese.

Best Pizza Near Carle Place


Westbury lies less than two miles from Carle Place, and it will take you about four minutes to drive there. When visiting the town, you can sample a wide variety of pizzas served at Vito’s Pizzeria. The family-owned and managed restaurant serves heavenly Sicilian, veggie, and thin-crust pizzas. Treat yourself to a Chicken Francese Pizza served with lemon, butter, white wine sauce, and egg batter. Don’t forget to review their soups, and you can try a Tortellini en Brodo Soup prepared with pepper, tortellini, basil, and spinach.


Taglio Pizza is a megastar restaurant serving the best Italian food in Mineola, located two miles from Carle Place. The pizzeria offers its pizzas for takeout and delivery, and you can use Slice for a better experience. If you need a quick and tasty meal to get you through the day, get yourself a Vodka Roni Pizza topped with vodka sauce, pepperoni cups, basil, and mozzarella. You can throw in an Arugula Salad tossed with artichokes, arugula, Parmigiano, and a balsamic dressing.

Garden City

Garden City is a perfect place to live or visit, and you will enjoy every minute spent there. It will only take you about eight minutes to drive three miles southwest of Carle Place to Garden City. You will have fun exploring delicacies served at Enzo’s Pizzeria Restaurant. It’s a world-class restaurant with mouth-watering cauliflower, Neapolitan, and stuffed pizza in Garden City. The restaurant also serves pizza by the slice, and you can go for slices of BBQ Chicken Pizza piled with chopped red onions, BBQ sauce, a blend of two kinds of cheeses, and fried chicken covered with bread crumbs. Before placing your order, add a Vanilla Butter Milkshake, and you will enjoy the feast of a lifetime.

show more iconSee More




Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Carle Place, NY