Top Pizza Restaurants in Cheektowaga, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Cheektowaga: a local guide

Cheektowaga is a city located in Erie County, New York. Cheektowaga is in the north-central part of the county and is a suburb of Buffalo. Cheektowaga is the second-largest suburb of Buffalo after the town of Amherst. The population of Cheektowaga was approximately 89,000 as recorded by the United States census in 2020.

There are plenty of things to do in Cheektowaga, such as visiting the Reinstein Woods Nature Preserve, Amherst State Park, the University of Buffalo Art Gallery, and the Museum of disABILITY History. There are also a wide variety of restaurants, coffee shops, and other local eateries to enjoy.

Here, we only care about the pizza! Read on to find out what our picks are for the best pizza delivery, take-out pizza, and other specialty pizzas in and around the Cheektowaga area.

Cheektowaga is known for New York City pizza

Although Cheektowaga is located far north in the state of New York and is nowhere near New York City, New York City-style pizza is still one of the most popular types of pizza. New York City Style Pizza is a national favorite and is known for having delicious and flavorful Italian seasonings, lots of melty cheese, and a thin crispy crust.

New York City-style pizzas are made by rolling out a lump of dough until it is thin and then stretching the dough by hand until it is a perfect circle and thin enough to cook. The crust is then cooked with sauce on top in the oven for a little while.

Once the crust is almost done cooking, shredded mozzarella cheese and toppings are added to the pizza. Then, it is put back into the oven to finish cooking. The pizza is complete when the cheese is golden brown on the top and super melty.

Best Delivery Pizza in Cheektowaga

The best delivery pizza in Cheektowaga is at Poplar Pizza WNY, on William Street. Poplar Pizza WNY is a great place to order a fresh and delicious pizza from. They have 4.7 stars out of 5, and over 200 positive reviews. Poplar Pizza has a $3 delivery fee and has a delivery time of approximately 40 to 55 minutes, depending on your order, your location, and how busy Poplar Pizza is.

Poplar Pizza offers specialties by the day as well as house specialties that are sure to please any type of pizza lover. Some of the favorites at Poplar Pizza are the Chicken Finger Pizza, the Fajita Pizza, (topped with chicken, onions, peppers, and three types of cheese,) the Pork-a-Saurus Pizza, (pepperoni, ham, sausage, and bacon,) and the Seasonal Specialty pizza.

You can order from Poplar Pizza WNY online, in-store, or over the phone for your convenience. Be sure to check out what their daily special is as they change day by day.

Best Takeout Pizza in Cheektowaga

The best take-out pizza in Cheektowaga is located on Dingens Street and is called Buffalo Grill N Ale House. Buffalo Grill N Ale House is the perfect place to pick up some delicious pizza or other menu items such as wings, chicken fingers, hot and cold subs, or burgers.

Some of their house Gourmet pizzas are the Bubba Pizza, (loaded with pepperoni and finished with crispy bacon) the Buffamonti Pizza, (no sauce with Romano cheese and mozzarella cheese, onions, tomatoes, olive oil, garlic, pepper, and oregano), and the Full Count Pizza (loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, sausage, black olives, and bacon.)

Buffalo Grill & Ale House also has the Friday special and plenty of other delicious menu items to try out. Check out their menu and order online, in-store, or over the phone today.

Best Pizza Near Cheektowaga

Amherst

The best pizzeria in Amherst is Blaze Pizza. Blaze Pizza has a variety of small, medium, and large pizzas as well as different menu items such as salads, side dishes, and drinks. They have plenty of unique and delicious options for you to try, such as The Art Lover which has artichokes, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, chopped garlic, and red tomato sauce dollops.

Williamsville

Rocco's Wood Fired Pizza in Williamsville is the best place to go for fresh and delicious pizza in Williamsville. They have plenty of authentic and unique pizzas prepared in-house with fresh ingredients. Some of their specialty pizzas include the Arugula Pizza which has sliced tomatoes, pesto, arugula salad, parmesan cheese, and mozzarella. They have plenty of other side dishes as well such as salads, sandwiches, and chicken wings.

Depew

Grasso's Pizza in Depew is the perfect place to go for traditional pizzeria fare. Grasso’s has daily specials as well as everyday specials, so be sure to check out their deals and combos. Their monthly specials are also delicious. One of their current monthly specials is a spinach pizza, which has a garlic crust, ricotta cheese, Romano cheese, oregano, spinach, and tomatoes and is finished with a three-cheese blend.

show more iconSee More

FAQ

PIZZA TYPES IN CHEEKTOWAGA

EVEN MORE TYPES OF FOOD IN CHEEKTOWAGA

Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Cheektowaga, NY