Find Local Pizza in Pleasantville, New York

Pleasantville is a suburb of New York City. The city is considered one of the best places to live in Westchester County. With most residents owning their homes, the city offers a sparse suburban feel. The small city is made up of a tight-knit community. Residents are always out casually walking their dogs or grabbing a bite to eat; you always run into someone you know. Pleasantville was rated the second-best smelling city a few years ago - likely due to its abundance of trees. Aside from smelling good, it is a cultural and artistic hub in the center of the county. The city is home to the secondary campus of Pace University and the Jacob Burns Film Center. Additionally, Pleasantville has one of the region’s largest farmers’ markets, with more than 50 vendors. The market boasts weekly live music and a Market Sprouts program for kids, culinary demos, and health and sustainability programs. For a town that is about two miles long, it has everything you need. From an irresistible collection of small boutiques, restaurants, and pizzerias. When looking for convenience, pizza is the first food residents reach out for.

Top Pizza Restaurants in Pleasantville Near You

caret icon

Craft Pizza & Beer logo
4.9filled star icon(1977)
Open Now
Free Delivery
Order Online

Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza & Catering logo
5% Off Online
5.0filled star icon(605)
$3.60 Delivery
Order Online

Lucio's Pizzeria logo
View Menu

Pleasantville Pizzeria logo
View Menu

Sal's Pizza & Pasta logo
View Menu

Pleasantville is Known for Neapolitan Pizza

Neapolitan pizza originated from Naples, Italy. The thin pizza has traveled far and wide and gained favor with the residents of Pleasantville. Primary ingredients in the preparation of Neapolitan pizza include San Marzano tomatoes, sliced fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil. Sometimes, parmesan cheese is sprinkled at the very top to add flavor. To make Neapolitan pizza, the crust has a sizable thin base, with dough that puffs up from the sides, providing a light, airy crust. With its characteristic light crust, it is easy to overcook and completely burn the crust. Thus, a lot of precision is required when preparing this pizza. Additionally, because of the thin bottom, it is impossible to pick up the pizza by hand. As a result, most restaurants in Pleasantville offer a fork and knife when serving their Neapolitan creations.
It’s easy to satisfy your craving for proper Neapolitan pizza in Pleasantville. While some restaurants may vary in preparation and topping style, peruse all the different menus till you find your perfect Neapolitan match!

Best Delivery Pizza in Pleasantville

Craft Pizza & Beer is a family-friendly eatery serving gourmet Neapolitan pizza, specialty wine, excellent sangria, and micro-brewed beer. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere with a simple ambiance. The staff is always friendly, attentive, and prompt to ensure you have a smooth and swift delivery process. The pizzeria makes consistently tasty wood-fired pizza with an excellent thin crispy crust. Their pizzas range from traditional crust pizzas to gluten-free crust pizzas and cauliflower crust pizzas. All their pizzas are prepared with precision and available in a large selection. If you are looking to try new items from their menu, it is essential to note that Craft Pizza & Beer serves some of the best Rigatoni Bolognese. The restaurant understands the importance of al dente pasta, that’s for sure. Check out more flavorsome menu items, like the appetizers, salads, and sandwiches, and place an order through Slice:

Best Takeout Pizza in Pleasantville

Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza & Catering, located on Marble Ave, is an unparalleled restaurant for takeout pizza. The pizzeria serves specialty wood-fired pizzas, frozen take and bake cheese pizza, and a selection of authentic Italian entrees. The pizzeria prepares 10 – 12 "personal pies without the option of serving pizza by a slice. The pizza cooks in an 800-degree Fahrenheit wood-fired oven. If you ask the staff, they will tell you that the oven infuses the pizza with wood flavor, giving it a nice char at the base and crust edges. The pizza comes out perfectly crisp yet tender.
Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza uses dough straight from Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, layers the crust with an in-house sauce made from San Marzano tomatoes, and adds unique cheese made to withstand the wood-fired oven's high temperature. Luckily, for people short on time, the pizza is always ready in under 10 minutes due to the high temperatures of the brick oven. If you are time conscious but still demand flavorful pizzas, Arthur Avenue is the perfect restaurant.

Best Pizza Near Pleasantville

Briarcliff Manor

Briarcliff Manor is a relatively kind and welcoming community that offers a lot of diverse foods and a fair number of fast-food restaurants. It is worth a stop at Giovanni's Pizza for their tremendous thin and crispy slices of pizza in Briarcliff Manor. The easy-going pizzeria serves custom and gourmet New York-style pizzas. All their pizzas are perfectly presented and consistently tasty. Be sure to order their Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza. Layered with pink vodka sauce and melted mozzarella cheese topped with chicken cutlet, It is simply divine!

New City

New City is your typical New York City area suburb. With calm and captivating scenery, the city tends to be quite charming. When driving along South Mountain Road or taking a walk by Zukor Park, you will see why it’s a popular spot. Agnello's Pizza is an excellent restaurant serving brick oven pizzas, regular pasta, and traditional Italian comfort foods. The restaurant prides itself on incorporating premium ingredients, and the best part about their brick oven pizzas is their mozzarella cheese. Here, you will have a taste of the freshest mozzarella available locally. The tomato toppings they use on their pizza have a natural sweetness, which combines perfectly with their homemade sauce and crispy crust.


Ossining is a very diverse town in Westchester County. The city's natural scenery, especially the Hudson River, provides a great place to enjoy outdoor activities, like kayaking and hiking with family and friends. If you are looking for solid pizza in Ossining, D'Italia Pizzeria is a great start. The pizzeria serves unique flavors of gourmet pizza and a wide range of Italian cuisine. Their menu offers a selection of terrific pizzas. Make sure to try their Focaccia Pizza. It’s made with a crunchy, airy crust layered with evenly cooked cheese, delicious sauce, and consistently fresh toppings. You will also find top-notch entrees and tasty desserts at D'Italia Pizzeria.


Q: 🍕Which restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Pleasantville?

caret icon

Q: 🍕Which restaurant has the best stuffed pizza in Pleasantville?

caret icon

Q: 🍕Which restaurant has the best thin-crust pizza in Pleasantville?

caret icon

Q: 🍕Which restaurant has the best Sicilian pizza in Pleasantville?

caret icon

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Areas of Pleasantville

Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Pleasantville, NY