Top Pizza Restaurants in Scarsdale, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Scarsdale: a local guide

New York-style pizza is one of the country’s most popular regional pizza types. Although initially inspired by Neapolitan-style pizza, the New York-style of pizza has now grown to become available everywhere in the country. While this style is available in many places in and outside the United States, the best place to score one is still its birthplace, obviously, New York City.

A typical New York-style pizza features large, wide slices that are foldable. These hand-tossed beauties are usually baked in coal or deck ovens. New York-style pizza features a crispy outer crust perfectly sauced and brilliantly topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Any extra toppings you get go on top of the cheese. Usually ordered whole or by the slice, they are often heavy on the cheese and light on the sauce.

Best Delivery Pizza in Scarsdale

Slice of Scarsdale has been a Garth Road staple since 2016. Their soft-crusted, topping-loaded pies are crafted with the best ingredients and extra care. Try one of their unique and tasty combos like the Chicken Parm Pizza, which tempers the richness of breaded chicken with the flavor of tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. They offer pizza in three different sizes and have about 14 different lunch-special combos. Some of their pizza options can be made gluten-free, so everyone can enjoy a slice. Another tantalizing menu item here is the signature Seasoned Tomato Pizza which contains thinly sliced tomatoes marinated in olive oil with basil, garlic, pepper, and mozzarella cheese.

Before you complete your delivery order on Slice, consider adding one or two of their side dishes. Their wings and boneless tenders are prepared with buffalo sauce and come highly recommended. The Classic Minestrone Soup or the Roasted Vegetable Salad will pair well with any of Slice of Scarsdale’s mouth-watering pizzas.

Best Takeout Pizza in Scarsdale

The wood-fire pizza lineup at Scarsdale Pizza Station includes authentic Grandma and New York-style pizza in a vast assortment of combinations. Since they aren’t available everywhere, pad your takeout order with as many of their Sicilian Grandma pizzas as you can eat. This is where Scarsdale Pizza Station really shines. There are over 15 different Grandma pizza types on their menu. The Whole Wheat Special Grandma pizza is a cross between Grandma and California-style pizza. It has caramelized onions, goat cheese, arugula, and bruschetta.

The dough at Scarsdale Pizza Station is so good that it almost doesn’t matter how you top it. The service here is excellent, and they make sure your takeout order is accurate no matter how busy they are. If you need something other than pizza, browse their other dishes like soups, salads, and pasta.

Best Pizza Near Scarsdale


Located less than three miles from Scarsdale, Eastchester is known for its agricultural activities. It is also quite dominant in the pizza game, with some of the best pizzerias and restaurants in the area. The Pizza Shop serves tasty pies with a heavily blistered crust that benefits from fresh ingredients and the best preparation process. Try their Sicilian cheese pizza, topped with spinach, onions, and ham.

White Plains

White Plains is generally known as the home of business in Westchester County due to its upscale malls, shops, bars, and restaurants. Lombardo’s Pizza is an Italian restaurant serving Neapolitan pizza and Sicilian-style pizza, as well as soups, salads, and calzones. The Grandma pie at Lombardo’s is also coal-fired-layered with mozzarella and has herbed San Marzano tomato sauce. From their locally grown ingredients to homemade mozzarella, Lombardo’s Pizza works hard to maintain the authenticity and integrity of its food.


Harrison is a New Jersey town with vibrant downtown neighborhoods with solid culture and history. Harrison’s residents enjoy living in a town that features amazing attractions, shops, and restaurants. Gina’s Pizzeria has pizza with a crispy outer edge and a delicious crust. They offer both New York-style pizza and Sicilian cheese pizza at affordable prices. If you don’t necessarily want pizza or you just want something to complement your pizza, Gina’s Pizzeria also serves soups, salads, and beverages.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Scarsdale, NY