Top Pizza Restaurants in Shirley, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Shirley: a local guide

Shirley is a hamlet in Suffolk County on Long Island. New York is known as the Italian American capital because it is home to the largest Italian American population in the United States. In the early 20th century, more than two million Italians entered the country, most of them arriving in New York. By 1930, Italian Americans made up more than a million of New York’s population.

There are strong Italian communities in different parts of the city. Italian immigrants helped build the town and had a significant influence on the city’s art, music, and of course, food. Hence, it is no surprise why Italian food is very prominent in Shirley.

The median age in Shirley is very young, with the majority of the population being young adults and young families. Most people in Shirley prefer upscale restaurants to street food, but busy people always need a quick delivery or takeout pizza. Luckily, that’s available, too.

Shirley is Known for New York-style Pizza

New York is a very diverse city, which is one of the things that makes it rich in culture. This diversity is a part of literally everything, including food, so it’s not a surprise that New York has its own pizza style. If you have never had a New York-style pizza, Shirley is the perfect place to try it out.

New York-style pizza is a beauty in the pizza world. It is characteristically large and round. Often cut into triangular pieces and foldable, it is usually topped with shredded mozzarella cheese instead of fresh mozzarella cheese. This is because it gives a more even melt. The crust is generally thicker at the edge to hold in the toppings and thin on the bottom. Because the crust is thin, it remains pliable, and you can fold it in half to eat it quickly and without spillage. Ultimately, it was inspired by Neapolitan pizza, but it is now the most popular pizza style in the country.

Best Delivery Pizza in Shirley

Shirley has some tough competition among its top pizzerias, but Buona Fortuna Pizza of Shirley has a loyal fan base for a reason (or two). One of them is that they have an excellent approach to their Italian-inspired dishes, so expect to explore new things here. Their cuisine is inspired by Italian recipes and traditional methods that they merge with modern techniques and ingredients. This restaurant serves up classic Italian dishes alongside a menu of craft beverages. With their very own authentic Italian-style Neapolitan pies, it is obvious that the pizza here is the real deal. Buona Fortuna Pizza of Shirley focuses on high-quality dough and classic toppings such as eggplant, fresh garlic, and tomatoes. This makes their wood-fired pies taste fresh and delicious every single time. Just a slice, and you’ll be back at Buona Fortuna again and again.

Best Takeout Pizza in Shirley

Pizzeria Los Amigos is a neighborhood pizzeria that’s open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Pop in for anything from pizza to wrap to burgers. The pizza is the star of the show at Los Amigos with perfect sauce, ample cheese, and a chewy crust. They do excellent Neapolitan, thin-crust Grandma, and Sicilian square pizza. Another menu highlight is the Vegetarian Pizza that has sauteed spinach, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, and broccoli. Feeling adventurous? Try the Tossed Salad Pizza. It has Italian dressing and bleu cheese on a thin and crispy crust. You can both see an taste their innovation in every pie they make. Pizzeria Los Amigos has a genuinely cozy atmosphere and is the ideal place to come for a night out with friends and family. It’s also ideal as takeout for a relaxing night in. You can expect value and friendly service no matter how or where you place your order.

Best Pizza Near Shirley


Brookhaven is the most populous of the ten towns of Suffolk County. It is located approximately two miles from Shirley. Brookhaven has its fair share of upscale pizzerias, including Brook House Pizza & Grill. This charming restaurant has a full menu of Italian dishes like pasta, but don’t place an order without trying the pizza. Brook House does amazing thin-crust Grandma pizza that you can customize with toppings like meatballs, pepperoni, and spinach, as well as Kalamata olives.


Medford is a suburb of New York City well known for its restaurants, coffee shops, and parks. Pizza Corner is a go-to pizza spot in Medford that serves nothing but the best pies. Their wood-fired pizzas have the perfect base, chewy crust, and wonderful toppings that melt in your mouth. Be sure to try the Sicilian Pie. It’s a classic square, thick crust pizza topped with mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

Mastic Beach

Mastic Beach is known for its museums and other popular tourist spots. Mastic Beach is also home to pizza giants Pizza Time. It is fair to say that you are in safe hands when you step into the restaurant. There are plenty of choices on their well-stacked menu, but the Neapolitan Cheese Pizza topped with mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce will be an instant favorite. The salads, calzones, and heores here are also impressive.

show more iconSee More


Q: What restaurant has the best New York-style pizza in Shirley?

caret icon

Q: What restaurant has the best Grandma pizza in Shirley?

caret icon

Q: What restaurant has the best deep-dish pizza in Shirley?

caret icon

Q: What restaurant has the best Neapolitan pizza in Shirley?

caret icon
Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Shirley, NY