Top Pizza Restaurants in Smithtown, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Smithtown: a local guide

Smithtown is a family-friendly town with amazing people and several things to explore. Smithtown got the name from Richard Smith, who acquired the chunk of land where the town sits after riding a bull for a whole day. Many families live here due to the low cost of living, and many residents own their homes. You can use railroad or Suffolk County transit buses if you don’t have a car. The town is famous for serving tasty Italian food such as chicken riggies and pizzas. If you haven’t heard of chicken riggies, it’s a pasta dish that combines chicken and hot or sweet peppers on a bed of rigatoni. Pizza became a favorite dish in Smithtown in the mid 20th century when Italian immigrants decided to serve their local delicacies to the residents. Nowadays, you can savor the pizzas with just a few clicks on your phone or during the Smithtown Festival Day. Before leaving town, make an effort to visit Blydenburgh County Park, which is a perfect place to enjoy your takeout meals and participate in recreational activities.

Smithtown is Known for New York-style Pizza

Pizzerias in Smithtown offer delicious pizzas, and you shouldn’t resist the temptation to try a New York-style pizza that reigns supreme in many restaurants here. Gennaro Lombardi created the first New York-style pizza in little Italy, Manhattan, in 1905. New York pizza became famous in Smithtown in the mid 20th century, and many pizzerias have polished their skills in making tasty dishes. New York-style pizza is loosely based on Neapolitan pizza from Naples, Italy, first prepared in the late 19th century. New York-style pizza has a thin and crispy crust piled with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and some restaurants will allow you to customize it by adding more toppings. Chefs liven up the pizza sauce with dried oregano, red chili pepper flakes, dried basil, and grated parmesan cheese. The pizza uses high-gluten flour and New York City’s tap water since it’s believed to contain minerals that add more flavor to the dish.

Best Delivery Pizza in Smithtown, New York

Sal's of Smithtown is a family-owned and managed pizzeria that has served mouth-watering Italian and American food since 2001. The pizzeria prepares its food using premium ingredients, and you can order in advance since they make everything on request. The restaurant's prices are pocket-friendly, and you should place a delivery order on Slice for maximum convenience. Food tastes better when shared with your loved ones, and you should treat your family to a Meat Lover's Pizza loaded with pepperoni, cheese, ham, and bacon. The fun doesn't end there since you can also try a house special of the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza; it’s always a crowd-pleaser. It has chicken, mozzarella, bacon, and a creamy ranch dressing. Remember to add a Chicken & Shrimp salad tossed with grilled chicken, cucumbers, shrimp, and feta cheese. The wraps, calzones, and pasta meals are all worthy of your next order as well.

Best Takeout Pizza in Smithtown, New York

Buona Sera in Smithtown serves some of the best pizza around and is ideal for your next takeout meal. There's something for everyone here with Grandma, Sicilian, and Neapolitan pizzas. Their dishes will make you feel on top of the world, and they offer over 25 specialty pizzas. A unique option on the menu is the Sausage & Rabe Pizza loaded with broccoli rabe, fresh tomato sauce, sweet Italian sausage, and fresh mozzarella. Ordering on Slice is easy, and your dish will be ready for carry-out in less than an hour. If you need a healthier choice with no meat toppings, you can opt for the Veggie Pizza topped with flame-roasted peppers, sautéed spinach, mushrooms, and homemade fresh mozzarella cheese. It's a flavorsome dish that will have you wondering if just one pizza is enough. You can also request a side of Steamed Spinach served with virgin olive oil and garlic. What a tasty way to get your greens! Another solid choice is the Buona Sera Salad tossed with red onions, Roma tomatoes, shredded mozzarella cheese, and cucumbers.

Best Pizza Near Smithtown


Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria is a top-notch restaurant in Hauppauge that serves delicious stuffed, Grandma, brick oven, and New York-style pizzas. An excellent start to your meal is the Mozzarella Caprese served with basil, tomatoes, homemade balsamic vinaigrette, and slices of mozzarella cheese. For the main course, consider the Pizza Bianca for a change. It has fresh garlic, two types of cheese, and olive oil brushed on the crust. If you crave a pasta dish, try the Rigatoni alla Siciliana, and you will experience the savory taste of pomodorino sauce, eggplant, fresh mozzarella cheese, and basil.


Nesconset lies three miles from Smithtown, and it's an ideal place to spend a day or two. You won’t go hungry here; lots of restaurants with varied and delectable food await. For pizza, and Italian food in general, head to Gino's of Nesconset. They have everything from Sicilian to gluten-free pizza. The restaurant's staff are friendly and prepare outstanding dishes worth trying. Start your order right with a Veggie Pizza topped with freshly sliced mushrooms, pineapples, green peppers, and homemade pizza sauce. For pasta lovers, the Rigatoni Fiorentina and Spaghetti with Meatballs never disappoint.

Kings Park

If you haven't visited Kings Park in New York, you should plan to tour the town soon. It has several restaurants that offer mouth-watering dishes, and Linda's Riverside Pizzeria & Café should be your first stop when visiting Kings Park. You can indulge in a delicious Supreme Pizza piled with fresh garlic, sausage, meatballs, and peppers. When ordering for big appetites, the thicker Grandma Pizza is very satisfying with San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, garlic, and the crust is brushed with olive oil. Other tasty items here include paninis, salads, wings, and heroes.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Smithtown, NY