Top Pizza Restaurants in Gettysburg, PA Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Gettysburg: a local guide

Saying that Gettysburg is known for traditional-style pizza is quite a vague thing to say, but bear with us. Gettysburg has a heavy tourist population, with groups and families coming and going from all ends of the nation all the time. Everyone wants something different, so local pizzerias have modified themselves to be multi-purpose. That way, they can offer the basic styles and have customers find what they want.

Styles of pizza like New York City-style, Neapolitan, Sicilian, thin-crust, and others are hugely popular among the pizza eaters in Gettysburg. These traditional styles are then altered and made unique by the pizzerias to stand apart from the other pizza places in Gettysburg. Everyone still offers a cheese pizza though. You can’t go wrong there.

Let’s get into some of our favorite spots in Gettysburg.

Best Delivery Pizza in Gettysburg

The best delivery pizza in Gettysburg is Antica Napoli Pizza. Antica Napoli Pizza is a great spot to order from because of its wide variety of pizzas and other menu items. They have an average delivery time of 20 to 35 minutes depending, of course, on the items in your order and how far you are from the restaurant. They have a delivery fee of $2.

On their menu, you will find pizzas like the pizza Bianca, (garlic olive oil, mozzarella, oregano) BBQ pizza, Hawaiian, meat lovers, and supreme. If you want to round out your meal, then you should check out their salads. All the salads come with onions, pickles, tomatoes, black olives, and sweet peppers.

Additionally, on their menu, Antica sells hot subs, cold subs, strombolis, calzones, and offers party trays for larger gatherings. You can order from Antica online, in-store, or over the phone for your convenience.

Best Takeout pizza in Gettysburg

Despite their name containing the word “tacos,” Tacos Monarca is a fantastic pizza place that is loved by locals and visitors to Gettysburg all the same. They often feature deals and coupons like 2 large pizzas for 19.99 among others. If you are going for pickup, then you will be pleased to know that the wait time is typically about 15 to 30 minutes, so your food should be out fairly quickly, depending on the order.

Tacos Monarca sells a specialty pizza that is very unique to this area; a Mexican pizza. You pick the meat you want on it, and it is topped off with beans, tomatoes, onions, mozzarella, cilantro, and fresh avocado. It is truly a fan favorite here. They are well known for fusing Mexican flavors and pizza.

You can order from Taco Monarca online, over the phone, or inside the store for your convenience.

Best pizza near Gettysburg

Littlestown

A little ways due East of Gettysburg you will find the town of Littletown. Here is the restaurant La Bella Italia that serves hot and flavorful pizzas and pasta to the residents of the town. They offer lunch specials, seafood, traditional style NYC pizza, dine-in, takeout, subs, and gourmet pizza like the shrimp pizza or the chicken fajita pizza.

Fairfield

In Fairfield, just a short drive south from the heart of Gettysburg is the restaurant Taverna 5450. Taverna 5450 has taken pizza and elevated it to a flatbread-like experience, full of rustic and seasonal flavors and ingredients. With items like BBQ chicken, Mediterranean, and Hawaiian, you know that you are eating pizza, but it looks like farm-to-table chic right here in Pennsylvania. Stop by for dine-in or takeout next time you want something fantastic.

Biglerville

If you drive North of Gettysburg and a bit west, you will reach Biglerville, home of Mamma’s Pizzeria. Mamma’s Pizzeria is a fan and local favorite, offering classic pizza in a classic pizzeria. Italian desserts are also sold here and they are a perfect way to finish up a delicious meal here. At Mamma’s Pizzeria, you can order online, over the phone, or in-store. They typically offer takeout and delivery, as well as dine-in.

show more iconSee More

FAQ

Q: Where is the best Greek-style pizza in Gettysburg?

caret icon

Q: Where is the best Sicilian pizza in Gettysburg?

caret icon

Q: Where is the best grandma pizza in Gettysburg?

caret icon

Q: Where is the best veggie pizza in Gettysburg?

caret icon

PIZZA TYPES IN GETTYSBURG

Slicechevron right iconPennsylvaniachevron right icon Pizza Places in Gettysburg, PA