Top Pizza Restaurants in Hilton Head Island, SC Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Hilton Head Island: a local guide

Hilton Head Island is a town located in South Carolina and is a part of the Lowcountry region of the state. Hilton Head Island is known for the beautiful Atlantic Ocean beaches and golf courses that it is home to. Some of the landmarks in Hilton Head Island are the Harbour Town Lighthouse and Museum located at the Southwest end of the island.

Another landmark business in Hilton Head Island is the Coastal Discovery Museum which combines heritage buildings, themed gardens, and trees into an exciting package. Other landmarks to see are the Coligny Beach Park, Harbour Town Golf Links, historic Mitchellville Freedom Park, and the beautiful wildlife habitat Sea Pines Forest Preserve.

There are also a variety of restaurants, eateries, and local dives that are sure to please lovers of all foods. There are also pizzerias, and of course, since we love pizza, we are going to be focusing on the pizzerias. Read on to find out what our picks are for the best pizza delivery, the best pizza takeout, and the best specialty pizzas in and around Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.

Hilton Head Island is Known for New York City-style Pizza

Although Hilton Head Island is nowhere near New York City, the local favorite pizza style is New York City-style pizza. The pizza makers do great justice to New York City-style pizzas, with thin delicious crusts, flavorful sauces, and lots of mozzarella cheese. Of course, they are not stingy with the toppings either.

New York City-style pizzas are made by rolling out a circle of dough. Next, the circle dough is stretched hand until it is in the proper shape and thinness. Once the pizza is the right size, the sauce is added and the pizza is placed in the oven. When the pizza is almost finished cooking, it is removed from the oven, and toppings and cheese are added. The cheese is typically shredded mozzarella.

Next, the pizza is added back into the oven to finish cooking. The pizza is done cooking when the cheese on top is golden brown and fully melted. New York City's pizzas are some of the most famous pizzas in the United States, and it is no surprise that the people of Hilton Head Island love it too.

Best Delivery Pizza in Hilton Head Island

The best pizza delivery in Hilton Head Island is Bella Italia Pizza, located on Mathews Drive. Bella Italia Pizza is a delicious pizzeria that has over 1500 reviews. Bella Italia Pizza has a $3.95 delivery fee and typically delivers within 90 to 105 minutes. Delivery time depends on your location and your order.

Bella Italia Pizza has a variety of delicious pizzas including traditional pizzas and specialty pizzas. Some of the most popular pizzas are the Godfather's Pizza, which is topped with sausage, spiced chicken cutlets, green bell peppers, and black olives, and the Uncle Peter's cheese pizza, which is topped with two toppings of your choice, loaded with cheese, and then loaded with more melted cheese when it comes out of the oven.

They also serve a variety of appetizers, side dishes, wings, and other delicious menu items that are sure to please. You can order from Bella Italia Pizza online, in-store, or over the phone for your convenience.

Best Pizza Takeout in Hilton Head Island

The best pizza takeout in Hilton Head Island is from Club Seats Grille, located on Main Street. Club Seats Grille has no minimum spending requirement for takeout orders and has a pickup time of approximately 15 to 30 minutes from the time of order.

They have a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas, so there is something for everyone here. Some of their pizza styles include cauliflower crust pizza for gluten-free customers, thick crust Sicilian pizza, thin-crust Sicilian pizza, build your own pizzas, and more.

Some of their specialty pizzas include the Philly pizza, which is topped with a cheese sauce, ribeye, bell peppers, mushrooms, jalapeno, and onions, while another favorite is the chicken avocado pizza which has a white sauce base, grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, basil, house cheese, and avocado.

Best Pizza Near Hilton Head Island


The best pizza in Savannah is at Stoners Pizza Joint in Downtown Savannah on West Boundary Street. Stoner’s Pizza Joint is open late and has quick pick-up times so you can grab your late-night munchies quickly and easily. They often offer a variety of specials at their different stores and also nationwide specials.

They offer a variety of pizzas and other menu items, so be sure to check them out next time you get a late-night craving.


Local Pie Bluffton is the perfect place to go for delicious and authentic pizza. Local Pie Bluffton specializes in amazing thin-crust pizzas that are cooked authentically and have the perfect crunch when you bite them. Their pizzas are artisanal and packed with flavor. Their specialties are to die for and their traditional pizzas are just as amazing.


Hearth Wood Fired Pizza in Beaufort is the perfect place to go for delicious and authentic wood-fired pizza. The pizzas get an amazing flavor from the wood oven and the ingredients are always fresh and prepared daily to order. Hearth Wood Fired Pizza is a community stable and reliable place to go for delicious and amazing food, craft cocktails, beer, and wine.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconSouth Carolinachevron right icon Pizza Places in Hilton Head Island, SC