Top Pizza Restaurants in Cromwell, CT in 2024 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

Cromwell is a town in the heart of Connecticut with about 14,000 people as of 2010. The town has a total area of about 12.9 square miles. In Cromwell, the median age is 40 years old. The majority of the residents are aged 25 to 44 with 31.8%, followed by people aged 45 to 64 with 25.3%. This means that the people of Cromwell are more likely to prefer sit-down restaurants to street food. Italian-Americans are a vital part of America’s cultural identity. Connecticut has the second overall percentage of Italian-Americans in relation to the total population in the United States. About one fifth of Connecticut’s population claims Italian ancestry. They are very concentrated in Connecticut because that is where their families settled when they entered the U.S. many years ago. There were a lot of jobs around in towns and cities in Connecticut at that time, including Cromwell. Cromwell Wine & Food Festival takes place in January every year and is a great place to enjoy local food and wine in a family-friendly and relaxed atmosphere. Because pizza is trendy in Cromwell, it is a significant part of this festival. It features live music, contests, food events, wine tasting, and so much more.

The best pizza in Cromwell: a local guide

New Haven style pizza originated from New Haven, Connecticut. Frank Pepe started baking pizzas and sold them to local factory workers in the early 1920s. He bought a building with a brick oven and sold pizzas directly from there. This led to the opening of two more pizzerias called Tony’s Apizza and Sally’s Apizza in 1934 and 1938, respectively. It is a crispier descendant of the Neapolitan style pizza and is usually sold whole, not by the slice. New Haven-style pizza is cooked at extremely hot temperatures in an oil-fired or coal-fired brick oven and served in an oblong or irregular shape. It is also a relative of the New York style pizza but has some unique differences like being thinner and drier. Both New York Style pizza and New Haven style pizza are descendants of Neapolitan style pizza.

Best Delivery Pizza in Cromwell

Cromwell is a beautiful town, made even more beautiful thanks to its excellent pizza spots. Cromwell Pizza & Pasta is a restaurant that specializes in delivering the best of Italian cuisine to its customers. Their dishes are focused on amazing recipes that continually raise the standard of food freshness and quality. Cromwell’s Pizza menu features a wide range of delicious dishes like pizza, calzones, grinders, pasta, and chicken. There are a lot of ways to make a pizza at Cromwell’s Pizza, which means there are lots of reasons to place an order from them. Customers can pick the pizza, toppings, cheese amount, crust type, size, and so on. Their staff are fun and friendly and do their best to ensure the comfort of customers. Cromwell’s Pizza also has a unique cozy atmosphere suitable for family-friendly occasions. Whether you want to take out, dine-in, or place an order from the comfort of your home, Cromwell’s Pizza has you covered.

Best Takeout Pizza in Cromwell

Pizza Pie is the king of takeout pizza in Cromwell. From the best ingredients in your pizza to the last bite of your dessert, you are assured of having a good time. Their customer service is also outstanding as they pay utmost attention to timing and every need of their customers. You can expect a memorable experience every time you visit. Their menu is varied and offers something for the whole family. Even though pizza is their specialty, they also have salads, charcoal grilled burgers, and sandwiches. Pizza Pie offers a wide variety of service options as customers can choose to dine-in or take-out, and order food without stress. They are open for both lunch and dinner every day.

Best Pizza Near Cromwell


Clinton, Connecticut, is a popular travel destination for tourists during the summer due to its amazing sand beaches and waters. Pizza is a major theme in Clinton, and the summer is always very profitable for pizza restaurants in the city due to the increased tourism. Fox’s Pizza Den, less than 30 miles from Cromwell, is a pizza chain in Clinton that serves amazing pizza in different shapes, flavors, and sizes.


Jim’s Place Pizza is a family-owned restaurant in Vernon that has been serving delicious pizza, ice cream, calzones, ribs, pasta, and salads for more than 20 years. They offer amazing vegetarian options and late-night food. If you like to enjoy your meal outside, Jim’s Place offers you that option. You can also dine right at the counter and create your perfect pizza.


Bolton is a small town in Tolland County, Connecticut, with a population of about 5000 people. It is one of the best places to live and travel to in Connecticut. Bolton is also the home to some of the best pizzerias in Connecticut. Georgina’s Italian restaurant has been providing Italian-inspired cuisine since 1992. They offer delicious pizza, gyros, pasta, burgers, grinders, and Italian entrees.

show more iconSee More




Slicechevron right iconConnecticutchevron right icon Pizza Places in Cromwell, CT