Top Pizza Restaurants in Southington, CT Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

shop icon

Nicos Pizza

697 N Main St, Southington, CT 06489

The best pizza in Southington: a local guide

Southington is known for the regional specialty pizza named after its neighboring town: New Haven, Connecticut. New Haven pizza originates from Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, who first served this pie in 1925. New Haven-style pizzas feature a light coating of sauce and minimal cheese toppings. It is generally thinner than New York and Neapolitan pizza but draws inspiration from these two classic pizza styles. Its characteristically oblong shape is another easy way to tell it apart. Also, on the dry side, the crust remains chewy and should be expertly charred from baking in a coal or wood-fired oven.

Local restaurants add toppings like littleneck clams for a tasty regional variation on New Haven pizza. You’ll often find this seafood paired with generous amounts of fragrant garlic.

You will find New Haven pizza on most menus in Southington. JD’s Pizzeria bakes their Casino Pizza with a light white sauce and adds bacon to set it apart. The presence of clams and customizable menus allow locals to experiment with New Haven-style pizza as the foundation.

Best Delivery Pizza in Southington

Southington Pizza House is located right in town, and this classic pizzeria serves up the best New Haven Pizza in Southington. Locals rave about the garlic and bacon-forward creation. While Southington Pizza House makes a faithful recreation of the New Haven Pizza, they also make a variety of creative white pizzas to give you some options. The Shrimp Scampi Pizza and the Italian Flag Pizza with broccoli, ricotta, mozzarella, and tomatoes make this menu full of exciting possibilities.

But pizza is not the only game in town. Stuffed bread is a prominent feature on this menu, with options like Chicken Parm, Sausage & Spinach, and Pepperoni Bread that offer customers familiar flavors in a unique presentation. Get a little creative by ordering the Philly Steak or Buffalo Chicken Breads.

There is a plentiful selection of grinders and subs for the lunch crowd. The Genoa Salami Grinder keeps customers who want traditional flavors happy, while the Chicken Stir Fry Wrap is an excellent option for the more curious diner.

Order from Southington Pizza House with Slice to get some of the best pizza in Southington delivered right to you!

Best Takeout Pizza in Southington

Renaldo’s Apizza & Catering is the perfect spot to pick up your New Haven pizza. Notice that this is not a typo; Renaldo’s Apizza is even named after the iconic dish they take so much pride in serving. Their Clams Casino Pizza certainly backs up all the talk!

They have a varied menu with a few local favorites. Their New Haven Clams Casino Pizza will satisfy the Connecticut die-hards. Purists love the Margherita Pizza for its traditional Italian flavors. Perhaps the most famous is Renaldo’s Old Fashioned Pizza. It’s a classic Sicilian pizza with a huge dollop of sauce and spices.

Renaldo’s is unique in that their chefs make several styles of pizza very, very well. This will come in handy when you get takeout from Renaldo’s for your next get-together. Renaldo’s offers a full catering menu, making it perfect for large family gatherings and other functions. The Baked Ziti and Eggplant Parm are always a big hit.

Best Pizza Near Southington

Plantsville

Nico’s Pizza is a classic pizzeria located just down the street from Southington. This is a casual restaurant, content on serving traditional flavors. Their Tomato Basil Pizza has the freshest basil, homegrown tomatoes, and olive oil atop their mozzarella cheese. Their Porchetta Pizza will satisfy the pork lover with ham, salami, and bacon. Other than pizza, their chicken wings, gyros, and grinders are all great menu items to try.

New Britain

Pizza Pal is all about customization. These chefs will worry about the quality. Their New York-style thin crust pizza is baked to crispy perfection. Their sauce and cheese are both layered evenly. They make the foundation, now it’s the customer’s turn. Choose from a variety of fresh toppings. Don’t miss out on the grinders at Pizza Pal. The lunch crowd raves about their Italian Combo. Capicola, salami, ham, and provolone will excite anyone looking for that classic deli combination.

Waterbury

Located just west in Waterbury, Vincenzo’s Pizzeria bakes classic pizza styles. Local favorites like the Clams Casino and Florentine headline this menu. Their Giardiniera Pizza loads a pizza crust with broccoli, fresh tomatoes, peppers, onions, and eggplant. Perfect for anyone looking for greens and flavor. Don’t forget to try their authentic Italian dishes too! The Veal Francese is prepared in a lemon, butter, and wine sauce for a decadent dinner.

show more iconSee More

PIZZA TYPES IN SOUTHINGTON

AREAS OF SOUTHINGTON

Slicechevron right iconConnecticutchevron right icon Pizza Places in Southington, CT