Chicago’s pizza scene is like its weather; it deals in extremes. Like the famously cold winters and humid summers, pizzerias make their crusts either enormously thick or paper-thin. After that, they are topped with classic pizza ingredients and baked to perfection.

Tavern-cut thin-crust is the perfect pizza style for families and parties. This is a round pizza, and it’s cut into squares, making it easy to share. It’s also commonly ordered as an appetizer for the table, as one or two pieces won’t fill one person up too much. Tavern-cut pizza makes up for its small size with big flavor and texture. Because it’s so thin, this crust is crisped, sometimes burnt to be crunchy and delightful.

Every bite on the outer pieces of tavern cut thin-crust snaps and cracks. The middle pieces, generally reserved for crust-averse kids, are loaded with cheese and toppings. Cary, being a family town, is typical of most Chicago suburbs in that tavern-cut is celebrated above all other styles, and there are many places in town to find this wonderful pizza style.

Best Delivery Pizza in Cary

Just down the street from downtown Cary, La Pizza Via is a family restaurant known for its variety of pizza styles. They have New York and Chicago-style thin-crust pizzas. They also have Detroit-style thick crust pan pizza on the menu, which is not easy to come by in Chicago. But the true star of the show is their Chicago-style thin crust pizza.

La Pizza Via’s take on the classic tavern-cut pizza is their Chicago Cracker Thin Pizza. This crust has Ceresota flour and cornmeal, giving it a grainy texture and perfect crunch. This style is topped with La Pizza Via’s own mozzarella cheese blend and cooked on top of the toppings. As is the custom, this pizza is cut into squares and expected to be shared among friends and family.

If you’re not craving pizza, the stuffed breads come in various amazing flavors, the highlight of which is the Meatball Parm. There’s also a full menu of sandwiches, calzones, and stromboli.

To have the best pizza in the Cary area delivered right to your door, order from La Pizza Via with Slice.

Best Takeout Pizza in Cary

Despite the stiff competition, Rosati’s Pizza tends to have the best Chicago-style deep dish pizza in many towns. Rosati’s is a Chicago-area chain restaurant that is a fixture in every community they serve. Cary is no different. Rosati’s is a focal point in this community, where locals celebrate birthdays, and baseball teams meet after games. It’s also the perfect place to grab dinner from on the way home.

Rosati’s is the perfect Chicago-style pizzeria because they have both deep-dish and tavern-cut pizza. The thin vs. thick crust pizza argument isn’t just reserved for New Yorkers and Chicagoans; even families are divided! This explains Rosati’s popularity with families and groups. These two pizza styles compliment each other when shared. A hungry family can order a deep-dish and a tavern-cut pie that will leave everyone satisfied. Adding a salad and wings makes this the quintessential Chicago meal at home.

Order Rosati’s with Slice to pick up the best pizza in Cary.

Best Pizza Near Cary

Lake In The Hills

Alfredo’s Pasta & Pizza is another Chicago-centric pizzeria in that they offer both of the area’s distinct styles. Their Chi-Town Deep Dish fills their buttery crust with heavy mozzarella and tops it with a sweet plum tomato sauce. Their ultra thin-crust pizza offers a lighter but no less flavorful option. Alfredo’s has a balanced pizza menu. Sicilian pizza represents a more traditional option, while Mexican and Gyro Pizzas flex their chefs’ creative muscles.

Crystal Lake

The chefs at Crystal Lake’s El Molino Pizzeria & Bakery set out to bake the perfect family meal from start to finish. Their tavern-cut pizzas are baked and even burnt, but in a good way, to crispy perfection and then cut into squares. They also operate a full bakery where they make custom cakes for birthdays, parties, and other occasions. Pair their thin-crust pizza with breadsticks or wings, and then finish with a cake.

Fox River Grove

You are not heading in the wrong direction if you find yourself at Dead End Bar & Grill in Fox River Grove. Despite the intimidating name, which is a nod to the countless bikers that ride down Northwest Highway, this is a family restaurant and pizzeria. Their thin-crust pizza is so heavily loaded with melted mozzarella that it hardly passes for thin. The crust is crisped enough to hold the dense cheesy layer that rests on top. Add your favorite toppings, and you are good to go.