Top Pizza Restaurants in East Windsor, NJ Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in East Windsor: a local guide

East Windsor is an excellent family getaway destination in New Jersey and has several shopping malls, restaurants, and the nightlife is on another level. If you are searching for a place to relax with your family, stop by Anker Park and bring with you a takeout meal of hoagies and pizza. Pizza became common in East Windsor when Italians and New Yorkers relocated to the town in the mid 20th century. Many young professionals and families have settled here due to the low cost of living and many business opportunities. In East Windsor, you can attend the Pit Boss Rumble, a Country Western BBQ Competition where attendees get a chance to participate in fun activities, enjoy live country music, and sample the local cuisine. There is also a Latino Festival where you can savor dishes from the Latin culture. Don’t leave town without visiting Lee Turkey Farm to get yourself fresh fruit, vegetables, and even a turkey.

East Windsor is Known for Sicilian Pizza

Your visit to East Windsor will be incomplete until you savor a Sicilian Pizza served from any of the pizzerias here. Many pizzerias in East Windsor have polished their pizza-making techniques, and you can trust them with your order. Sicilian pizza, also called sfincione, came from Sicily, Italy, in the mid 19th century and got famous in East Windsor in the mid 20th century. The pizza has a thick and spongy rectangular crust piled with tomatoes, anchovies, herbs, and strong cheese like caciocavallo. A traditional Sicilian pizza uses more sauce than other pizza styles. The sauce goes above the cheese, followed by other toppings to avoid sogginess. However, some restaurants bake Sicilian Pizza without cheese. When seasoning the meatless sauce, you can use red chili pepper flakes, dried oregano, and olive oil. Authentic Sicilian pizzas are baked using wood-fired ovens, and you place the dough in rectangular or square pans. Make an effort to try Sicilian pizza in East Windsor; you won’t regret it.

Best Delivery Pizza in East Windsor, New Jersey

Sabrina’s Pizza & Pasta is a nice restaurant in East Windsor that serves delicious thin-crust, Sicilian, and gluten-free pizzas. The pizzeria offers over ten specialty pizzas, and you can treat yourself to a Sabrina’s Special Pizza topped with sliced tomatoes, fresh basil, mozzarella, and imported prosciutto. Another good choice is the Bacon Ranch Pizza loaded with chicken, chopped tomatoes, bacon, and a ranch dressing. Other than pizza, you can grab tasteful Veggie Stromboli with mushrooms, onions, mozzarella, and broccoli. The Bruschetta served with flavorful garlic, balsamic vinaigrette, fresh tomatoes, and capers as an appetizer kicks any delivery meal off right. If sandwiches are more your thing, a Turkey Club or Cheesesteak Hoagie served with vinegar, tomatoes, lettuce, and onions are just the ticket. Deliveries from Sabrina’s are quick and convenient, especially when you order on Slice. Expect excellent customer service if you have questions, and you get all this for a price that won’t break the bank.

Best Takeout Pizza in East Windsor, New Jersey

Planet Pizza & Wings is a notable restaurant in East Windsor serving delectable Italian and American dishes that you can easily order on Slice for takeout. They specialize in New York-style pizza, stuffed pizza, and the state’s famous New Jersey tomato pie. The prices are reasonable, so you’ll fill your order up in no time. Grab a tasty Philly Cheesesteak Pizza piled with sirloin steak and a blend of three kinds of cheese. If you are ordering for people with big appetites, consider adding a Steak Taco Pizza loaded with red onions, two types of cheese, a ranch dressing, and sirloin steak. Make your order more delightful by including a Garden Salad tossed with mixed greens, roasted peppers, green olives, and cherry tomatoes. The restaurant has a great selection of heavenly calzones, like the Chicken Cordon Blue Calzone, Popeye Calzone, and Primavera Calzone. You can review more options on their large menu, like paninis, subs, burgers, and seafood dishes.

Best Pizza Near East Windsor

Hamilton Square

Mannino’s 3 is a casual restaurant serving mouth-watering food in Hamilton Square, located nine miles southwest of East Windsor. The restaurant incorporates high-quality ingredients to make their pizzas, and you should give them a try by ordering a takeout or delivery meal. A top-selling item on the menu is the Chicken & Ranch Pizza with breaded chicken, mozzarella, tomatoes, and a ranch dressing. If you prefer a pizza with more veggie toppings, you can try a Veggie Lover’s Pizza piled with garlic mozzarella, pizza sauce, mushrooms, and tomatoes.


Nonno Sal’s Pizza is a world-class restaurant in Trenton that has served heavenly New York-style and Sicilian pizza for many years. Opt for the ideal combination of meat and sauce with the Chicken Marsala Pizza. You’ll get the tastiness of mozzarella cheese, marsala sauce, chicken, and mushrooms. Need a quick lunch? Nonno Sal’s offers over 15 specialty pizza options by the slice. The weekday specials are light on your wallet so that you can order even more food. Consider adding an appetizer, salad, or buffalo wings to your order.


The town of Robbinsville lies six miles southwest of East Windsor, and when in town, pay a visit to Massimo’s for the best pizza. The family-owned and managed Italian restaurant has been in business for over 45 years. Treat your taste buds to a Sicilian Cheese Pizza with homemade ragu sauce and two types of cheese. If you want a pizza with no tomato sauce, try a Verdura Pizza served with chopped tomatoes, mixed green veggies, garlic, and smoked mozzarella cheese.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in East Windsor, NJ