Find Local Pizza in Middletown, NJ

Many people consider Middletown, NJ one of the best places to live in the state. There’s plenty to do and lots of great food to eat. Many of the people here have a taste for pizza, creating a need for many wonderful pizzerias. If you live here, there are plenty of hidden gems for you to try out.

Pizza originated in New York, but quickly spread to New Jersey. Over time, the people there developed their own flavors and recipes for pizza. One of the most unique options in the state is the tomato pie. You can find it in plenty of areas within Middletown, NJ, although it’s not quite as popular as the Neapolitan pizza is.

Overall, there are many wonderful pies to try in the area! We recommend that you stick around and find something unique for dinner tonight. If you’re planning a pizza night, your family is sure to love anything that you order from Slice!

Top 2022 Pizza Restaurants in Middletown Near You

caret icon

Tre Colore Pizzeria logo
4.8filled star icon(2628)
$1.75 - $4.00 Delivery
Order Online

Pasquale's Pizzeria III logo
5% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(738)
$3.00 Delivery
Order Online

Sisters Pizza & Grill logo
10% Off Online
4.3filled star icon(40)
$3.00 Delivery
Order Online

Toscanella Village Cafe logo
4.2filled star icon(13)
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

shop icon

Lubrano's 36 logo
View Menu

Middletown is Known For Neapolitan Type Pizza

Neapolitan pizza originated in Naples, Italy. Soldiers and immigrants coming to the States after WWII brought the recipe with them. It didn’t take long for American versions of the recipes to develop. As an example, the New York slice took on a life of its own.

However, the Neapolitan pizza strives to remain as authentic to the Naples recipe as possible. If you’re eating an authentic Neapolitan, you’re sure to get a taste of Italy- without ever straying too far from home.

This type of pizza uses simple ingredients. It uses fresh dough, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese, basil, and olive oil. The pie traditionally does not use many toppings. So, any recipe that calls for them is not considered authentic by many people. Still, every Neapolitan is very delicious! You’re sure to love them.

Overall, this pizza type has a lot of rich history and the dish dates back hundreds of years. If you want a classic pizza, then this would be the best item to order through Slice Life.

Best Delivery Pizza in Middletown

Are you looking for the best pizza delivery in Middletown? If so, we recommend that you order from Basille’s Restaurant. It only takes them between 35 and 50 minutes to prepare your food and get it to you. You won’t have to wait very long for your order to arrive.

You can also find tomato pies here, which are very popular in New Jersey. Customers also recommend that you try the vodka pie and the Sicilian pies. All of these pizza options are very tasty and don’t take long to arrive at your doorstep.

As an added benefit, the location is open from 11 in the morning to nine at night each day. That way, you can order on any day of the week! That makes them very convenient for when your dinner plans fall through and you need something fast at home.

Overall, they’re a wonderful option and have some of the best pies in the town. You’re sure to love the prompt service and delicious crust you get!

Best Takeout Pizza in Middletown

Pasquale’s Pizzeria III offers amazing takeout. Plus, when you order with us, you get an online discount. They also have plenty of different pies to try: Sicilian, specialty pizzas, vegan pies, pies by the slice, vodka pies, Neapolitans, lasagna pies, and more! You’re sure to find something to love on their menu.

When you order takeout from this location, you won’t have to wait in line. Many people order while at work, so they can pick up their dinner right on the way home. If you have a larger family, you’re sure to get enough here to feed everyone!

They also have many unique options for you. There are the options we mentioned above, plus a variety of other toppings, cheeses, and sauces. You can build a flavor that you love.

Overall, locals appreciate how fast their customer service is. Your meal is likely to be ready well ahead of time for you. If you can’t pick it up right away, you can trust the store to keep your food hot for you in the meantime.

Best Pizza Near Middletown

New York City

Prince Street Pizza in the SoHo area offers some truly tasty pies! You’ll want to stop by if you happen to be in the city. They have many unique menu items and offer the SoHo Square, which is a small, thick slice coated in pepperoni pieces. You’re sure to love the sweet and spicy flavor it offers.

Jersey City

If you’re looking for a classic Neapolitan pie, then you’ll need to eat from Razza’s in the city. They use fresh ingredients and have some of the best crust around. The cheese and sauce have some of the best flavors, according to the regulars who eat there.


Frank’s Pizzeria has the best recipe in this city. They have Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which locals love. They also have plenty of other spicy options for you to try. The restaurant also offers many wonderful desserts, including funnel cakes.


Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Middletown?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Margarita pizza in Middletown?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best New York pizza in Middletown?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best deep dish pizza in Middletown?

caret icon

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Pizza Types in Middletown

Even More Types of Food in Middletown

Areas of Middletown

Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in Middletown, NJ