Top Pizza Restaurants in Farmingdale, NY in 2024 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

New York is the birthplace of pizza in the United States. After Italy, you can conclude that New York follows in making the best pizza in the world. Pizza was brought to New York in the early 20th century by Italian immigrants who came with the idea of establishing pizzerias in the state and exploring their Italian cuisine as a business in their new environment. New York is one of the busiest states in America, and it's a financial hub that has attracted people from all over the world. When people visit this state, they make sure they taste some of the local cuisines, and that's why pizzerias in New York are successful. Pizza in New York is made using the Italian traditions, and most pizzerias still use wood-fired ovens while others have gone digital. Young people's love for pizza has resulted in a rise in pizza deliveries across New York and other states.

The best pizza in Farmingdale: a local guide

Farmingdale lies almost 39 miles east of New York City. The town is home to renowned pizzerias, which make some of the best pizzas in New York. In Farmingdale, people enjoy their best style of pizza which is the New York-style pizza. A traditional New York-style pizza has a thin base, and around the outside, it's much thicker. The thin crust folds easily, which is how New York-style pizza is typically consumed. If you can't fold it, then it’s definitely not New York-style pizza. Finding an authentic pizzeria offering the best New York-style can sometimes be challenging. However, Slice is helping you identify all the best pizzerias, whatever your preference. Some pizzerias are still using the traditional pizza-making techniques of the brick wood oven, while others are using gas ovens.

Best Delivery Pizza in Farmingdale, New York

Eating a large pizza alone can be boring so why not enjoy your pizza by sharing with your family and friends? It’s even better when you can dine in the comfort of your own home. That's why it’s good to have the option to have your pizza delivered to your door. For your next delivery in Farmingdale, check out Bocconcini Deli and Pizza. It’s a treasured gem in Farmingdale, having served the locals for decades with some of the best Italian and American cuisines. The pizzeria makes the best New York-style pizzas, and customers never say a bad thing regarding the pizza or service. Bocconcini also offers salads, specialty pizzas, sandwiches, burgers, and paninis. They offer free pizza delivery around Farmingdale, and their food prices are affordable to all. With just a few clicks on your phone, you can get any pizza at your door quickly anywhere in Farmingdale through Slice.

Best Takeout Pizza in Farmingdale, New York

Takeout has become even more popular due to the recent outbreak of Coronavirus. Instead of dining in, people are now ordering ahead and getting takeout. Many pizzerias in Farmingdale offer this easy option to pick up your food for dinner on your way home from work. Vincent's Pizzeria in Farmingdale has opted for takeout to serve its customers well. The pizzeria is owned and operated by the Marino family, who has a history of Italian cuisines. They offer the best New York-style and Italian-style takeout pizza in town. They also offer other pizza and meals such as salads, seafood, chicken, veal, and much more. If you miss enjoying pasta or a panini, then Vincent's Pizzeria is your home for mouth-watering dishes ready for takeout. The pizzeria has set its food prices in a family-friendly way.

Best Pizza Near Farmingdale


The town of Wantagh lies six miles northeast of Farmingdale, and you will need around ten minutes to drive there. Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza is a household name for making the best New York-style pizzas in Farmingdale. The chain boasts over 60 restaurants nation-wide. The pizzeria offers Italian and American coal-fired pizzas, eggplant Marino, homemade meatballs, roasted chicken wings, and classic Italian salad. The pizzeria prepares its pizza and other dishes using fresh ingredients and vegetables. It’s easy to order from Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza through Slice if you’re in the market for something tasty in Wantagh.


Plainview, located about four miles north of Farmingdale, is home to various restaurants and coffee shops. The town residents are pizza lovers, and it's evident due to the many pizzerias in the small town. Umberto's Pizzeria has been serving Plainview residents with the best pizzas and Italian cuisine in the area. The pizzeria also offers their customers calzones, salads, burgers, and wings. They have wallet-friendly prices compared to other pizzerias in town. Umberto's offers their food for both takeout and delivery.


Bethpage is a small town northwest of Farmingdale and is considered a safe place to live in New York. The town is known for its diverse food cultures, and pizza is a favorite among the locals who embrace the New York-style pizza. Villa Maria Pizzeria is one of the best pizzerias in Bethpage, offering Italian and American food. The pizzeria is owned and run by Chef Goldsborough, who has experience in different cuisines. They use fresh ingredients sourced from the local market and take a traditional pizza-making approach by using wood-fired ovens. They offer delivery, dine-in, and takeout, and their prices are affordable.

show more iconSee More




Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Farmingdale, NY