Hungry customers can find a variety of pizza styles in Butler. Sicilian Pizza is on several menus. L Pizza proves you can find deep-dish pizza outside of Northern Illinois. But thin-crust pizza is king in Butler.

Thin crust may have started in New York, but this dish’s popularity quickly spread around the country. As thin-crust pizza became America’s go-to dinner for any occasion, regional varieties formed, and local flavors were infused into recipes. Regional specialties like Hawaiian and BBQ became famous nationally, and even ingredients from European cuisine all became pizza toppings. Butler is no different. Its most famous dish is a pierogi-themed thin crust pizza. Purists need not worry, as there are plenty of outstanding classic thin-crust pizzas in Butler as well. Butler residents are lucky enough to enjoy such variety in their pizza options. And luckily, they can count on the quality and consistency of the thin-crust creations of Butler’s pizzerias.

Best Delivery Pizza in Butler

L Pizza Plus in Butler is known for its exceptional variety in pizza styles. In the mood for thin and cheesy? They have a New York-Style pizza option. Need something substantial to get you through a cold spell? They have a deep-dish option that will make the trip to Chicago unnecessary. They also have a Sicilian pizza for any purist.

The most exciting item, and perhaps the “most Butler'' item, on the menu has to be their Pierogie Pizza. Borrowing from the culture of the town’s Polish-American residents, L Pizza has deconstructed the iconic pierogi dumpling and made a delicious pizza. You will be delighted to find potatoes, grilled onions, provolone, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese. Add ham, bacon, or sauerkraut (or all three) to make this pizza even heartier. This pizza is a taste sensation, and these flavors reflect the history and culture of Butler.

Order L Pizza Plus with Slice to get a variety of pizza options delivered right to your door.

Best Takeout Pizza in Butler

Tani’s Pizza is the perfect takeout spot on the way home from work or downtown Butler. They are, perhaps, best known for their famous Sicilian-style pizza. But, this thick-crust creation isn’t their only option on the menu. You can’t get any more authentic than their Florence Pizza. Topped with spinach, chopped Roma tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, and parmesan cheese, this is Italian decadence at its best.

Anyone craving something other than pizza has plenty of excellent options at Tani’s. The variety of calzones and strombolis will certainly satisfy just about anyone. Most notable are the Special - some might call this a meat-lovers - Stromboli or the Veggie Stromboli.

They have a full menu of traditional Italian dishes. Chicken Parm, Shrimp Alfredo, and even Linguine Pescatore prove this is more than just a pizzeria. They have sausage, metaballs, and eggplant sides to create a truly complete meal. This is a restaurant first, pizzeria second. But still, try the pizza.

Order Tani’s Pizza House with Slice to get the best takeout pizza in Butler.

Best Pizza Near Butler

Prospect

Prospect Pizza is “Your Hometown Pizza Shop.” This is an unfussy pizza place that is perfect for groups. They load specialty pies like The Prospect with generous toppings like steak, chicken, cheddar, ranch, and even french fries. Their homemade ricotta calzones make this a go-to lunch option for people on the go.

Saxonburg

Novotny’s Pizza is concerned with one thing: discovery. While the less adventurous can find familiar favorites, customers can go crazy with some of their pizza options: the Reuben Pizza, Maui Waui, and Cordon Bleu Pizza showcase Novotny’s creativity. Even the mighty pierogi makes an appearance on this menu. The Pierogie Pie is a favorite and uses garlic butter mashed potatoes.

Cranberry Township

Gordon’s Mini Mart has a balanced variety of options, but you will notice one thing when looking at the menu. Gordon’s “The Burgh” Pizza is topped with cheeseburger-inspired options. Another one of the local favorites is their Sicilian pizza. This squared creation is baked to perfection, and they urge you to try it with just cheese, to show the simple, elegant quality, or create your own.