Top Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg, VA in 2024 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

People in Williamsburg enjoy healthy pizzas. There are tons of restaurants that are dedicated to making veggie, vegan, gluten-free, and low-calorie pizzas. You can find a mix of trendy, new pizzerias among many traditional, old-fashioned places. Both can offer you a tasty slice!

Plenty of Italian restaurants here opened when Italian-Americans moved from New York to the area. They brought their traditional pizza recipes with them and some opened pizzerias. From there, the pizza pie developed into what we know it as today.

People in Virginia love pizza. Many of the older pizza places opened as early as 1970- some of which are still running today. If you enjoy pizza too, you will want to visit the area for a slice. You may find your new favorite, go-to restaurant while you are there!

Below, we have everything that you will need to know about pizza in Williamsburg, VA.

show more iconSee More

The best pizza in Williamsburg: a local guide

If you want to enjoy delicious wood-fired pizzas, then Williamsburg is going to be the place to go! The city has plenty of stores that use wood fire ovens to create their food. These ovens give the crust a delicious and unique taste. It helps to keep it crunchy, while the inside of the crust is warm and fluffy.

Many people living in the area love this style of pizza for many reasons. If you want to try some of the best wood-fired slices, then you should order from Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza-Pasta, Blaze Pizza, or FTH Pizza. All of these stores use wood ovens to cook their meals.

Wood-fired pizza is also quick to make. Since the pizza is right next to an open flame, it should usually take just a few minutes for the cheese to melt and the crust to cook the entire way through. Plus, most of these pizzerias take a lot of pride in perfecting their wood-fired recipes and techniques.

Best Delivery Pizza in Williamsburg

If you want the fastest delivery, then you should reach out to Francesco’s Ristorante Italiano for healthy pizza options. This Italian restaurant focuses on traditional Italian, Sicilian, and Southern-Italian meals. Their pasta is one of the most popular options from their menu.

Their delivery services are always prompt and your food should still be hot when they arrive with your order. The staff are friendly and will make sure that your order is made correctly. Do not hesitate to contact them if something is not to your liking.

Additionally, the restaurant is open late at night, carries vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free dishes, and has great portion sizes. You will be receiving a lot of food with your orders. Overall, there are plenty of factors that make this one of the best pizza delivery places in the city.

Best Takeout Pizza in Williamsburg

Mama Mia’s Pizza & Deli on Ironbound Road offers the best healthy takeout pizza slices. They also have several items on their menu, so you can find something that satisfies your cravings. For example, they make philly cheesesteak subs, cheesecake, onion rings, toasted ravioli, pizza burgers, and plenty more dishes!

Their service is pretty fast as well. That means you will not have to wait too long for your order. Many people will stop here on their lunch breaks to pick up a quick bite to eat before going back to work. Next time you are in the area, you can do the same.

Many customers also appreciate that the staff gets their orders right. You should not have to deal with wrong orders here. Finally, customers also appreciated that they were open at night. Their hours make it much easier to get your cravings out of the way before bed.

Best Pizza Near Williamsburg

Newport News

Newport is a 26-minute drive out towards Hampton. There are plenty of pizza restaurants for you to experience here. If you want the best slices from this city, you need to stop by Vinny’s Pizza and Pasta. They are not open late, so you will want to get there for lunch. The story focuses on creating thin New York City-style slices. They are very large, so you should only need one- they take up an entire plate!


Poquoson is a bit more of a drive at 35 minutes. However, there are plenty of places to stop and explore along the way. It can be a fun road trip for many. The best pizzeria here is for sure Anna’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant. The place has vegetarian-friendly menu items as well.


If you are going to be around Hampton any time soon, check out the Venture Kitchen and Bar. This restaurant has a lovely mixture of American and Italian dishes. Plus, they have a comfortable atmosphere that should make you feel right at home while eating.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconVirginiachevron right icon Pizza Places in Williamsburg, VA