Top Pizza Restaurants in Hillsborough, NC Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Hillsborough: a local guide

Hillsborough is among the oldest towns in North Carolina, and it lies along the Eno River. The town is home to several of the country’s writers and artists. The locals like shortening the name to Hillsboro, and it was named in honor of Will Hills, the earl of Hillsborough. Before settling on that name, the town had other names such as Corbin Town, Orange, and Childburg. Hillsborough is a unique town with several amazing restaurants that prepare tasty meals such as BBQ sandwiches and pizza. Pizza may sound like a rare dish in Hillsborough, but it has been around since the mid-to-late 20th century when Italian immigrants and New Yorkers decided to serve it in their restaurants. You can tour several historical buildings in the town, starting with the Old Orange County Courthouse built in 1844 and still working in judicial matters. Make sure you attend Hog Day or the Apple Festival, and you will have a grand time sampling local delicacies and listening to live music performances.

Hillsborough is Known for New York-style Pizza

When visiting Hillsborough, treat yourself to a New York-style pizza that reigns supreme in many restaurants across town. You can’t go wrong with New York pizza, and one slice will make you want more and more. Restaurants here serve tasty New York-style pizzas, which you can request as a whole pie or slices. Gennaro Lombardi baked the first New York-style pizza in New York City in 1905 by borrowing some features from Neapolitan pizza from Naples, Italy. New York-style pizza has a thin and crispy crust with large slices, and many people love folding them into two while eating. The pizza has delicious toppings, including shredded mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce. You can customize your pizza by adding more toppings without altering the crust. Restaurants season the sauce with grated parmesan cheese, dried oregano, basil, and dried red chili pepper flakes. Some pizzerias go the extra mile to import water from New York City since they believe it contains certain minerals that add flavor to the pizza.

Best Delivery Pizza in Hillsborough, North Carolina

J & F Kitchen is a fancy family-owned and operated pizzeria that serves delicious veggie, vegan, and meat pizzas in Hillsborough. The restaurant incorporates fresh ingredients and follows traditional homemade recipes. Place your order on Slice in advance for your dish to be prepared hot and fresh. For diners who want a hearty meal, make sure you add the Greek Pizza to your delivery order. It has savory feta, mozzarella, olives, and tomatoes. Add the Hummus and Pita or Flaming Saganaki as the perfect appetizer to stay with the Greek theme. The Pizza Bianca is another excellent option with olive oil as the sauce, parmesan, ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic. In addition, J & F Kitchen serves flavorsome Caesar Salads tossed with homemade croutons, lettuce, parmesan cheese, and a tangy Caesar dressing. You can wind up your delivery order with a side of Deep-fried French Fries, and you will enjoy a feast fit for a king or queen.

Best Takeout Pizza in Hillsborough, North Carolina

Anna Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a stylish family-owned and managed restaurant that has served delicious Italian dishes in Hillsborough for over 20 years. Start your meal off on the right foot with their appetizer Sample Platter. It has a little bit of everything, including jalapeno poppers, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and fried ravioli. Once you’ve browsed the appetizers, beef up your order with an Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza loaded with marinara sauce, two types of cheese, and eggplant. Food tastes better when shared, so add an Italian Chicken Pizza to please a crowd. The restaurant has a fantastic selection of pasta dishes, and you can request the Spicy Chicken Ravioli served with spicy marinara sauce, fresh garlic, black olives, and chicken ravioli. It’s a homemade flavorsome dish prepared to perfection. Anna Maria’s seafood pasta options are worth noting as well. The Shrimp Alfredo prepared with fettuccine in a creamy sauce and jumbo shrimp is quite decadent.

Best Pizza Near Hillsborough


Durham, 15 miles southeast of Hillsborough, has many pizzerias, but the best of the bunch is the Loop Restaurant. The family-owned and run restaurant offers delicious gluten-free, veggie, and cauliflower pizzas that you can order on Slice for takeout or delivery at a reasonable price. Take one bite of their Meat Market Pizza, and you will be happy as a clam. It has tasty toppings, including applewood smoked bacon, artisanal pepperoni, and tomato sauce.


Roma’s Pizza is famous for serving exquisite healthy and veggie pizzas in Mebane, ten miles from Hillsborough. Give them a try by ordering a delivery of BBQ Chicken Pizza, and you won’t regret it. The pizza has flavorful toppings comprising chicken, mozzarella cheese, and BBQ sauce. If that’s not sufficient, you can add a Veggie Pizza topped with freshly sliced tomatoes, homemade sauce, a special cheese blend, and green peppers. The restaurant also offers delicious wraps, salads, and calzones.

Chapel Hill

Alfredo’s Pizza Villa is an iconic restaurant that serves the best pizzas in Chapel Hill. When visiting the town, be sure to savor delightful dishes served at the restaurant. Rev up your appetite with Garlic Knots baked with olive oil and garlic, or another of their many appetizers. The restaurant also has a wide selection of pizzas. A delicious option is the Bella Napoli Pizza piled with green peppers, mozzarella cheese, onions, and olive oil brushed on the crust.

show more iconSee More


caret icon
caret icon
caret icon
caret icon
Slicechevron right iconNorth Carolinachevron right icon Pizza Places in Hillsborough, NC