An interesting pattern in many Lynchburg pizzerias and restaurants is that their most popular pizza is thin-crust New York-style pizza. This is understandable, and you can’t blame the locals, as the combination between the golden crispy crust, the old-fashioned tomato sauce, and tangy cheese is just perfect and is common comfort food for many people. Although New York-style pizza does not usually include many toppings, restaurants in Lynchburg always come up with the most outstanding pizzas.

Many Lynchburg locals also seem to be big Neapolitan pizza enthusiasts, always ready to enjoy a great authentic Italian pizza in an elegantly decorated Italian sit-down restaurant. This type of pizza is usually preferred by those who want the fresh taste of basil, mozzarella cheese, and San Marzano tomatoes on top of a crispy, airy, and thin pizza crust.

Best Delivery Pizza in Lynchburg

The fact that one of the best pizza spots in Lynchburg serves authentic New York-style pizza should not come as a surprise to anyone. Mario’s Pizza & Ristorante is a clear top choice for any Lynchburg local, as they offer a large selection of specialty pizza, chicken wings, subs, calzones, and spaghetti. You have to try their food for yourself to get what all the fuss is about!

Their classic Cheese Pizza is pure delight, as it is a great mixture of savory marinara sauce, buttery pizza crust, and some of the best cheeses on the market. Their Calzones are always loaded with delicious, fresh ingredients and are some of the most ordered items on their menu. If you would like something slightly different, their Vegetarian Pizza is for you. It uses tasty, locally-sourced vegetables covered in a blanket of bubbly cheese.

Best Takeout Pizza in Lynchburg

Since its opening in 1985, Cici's Pizza has opened more than 300 restaurants in more than 30 US states, including Virginia. Up to this day, many families remember dining at this restaurant and enjoying its excellent dishes at great prices. Cici’s has a large variety of pizza types, all served by the slice in a buffet-style restaurant. That way, you can enjoy a little bit of each mouth-watering combination.

According to their customers, the Flatbreads they offer are always soft and fresh, topped with your favorite ingredients, and ready to eat. Their Mac and Cheese Pizza combines the crispy pizza crust and the cheesiness of the mac and cheese to create a unique experience that’s hard to find elsewhere. If you happen to be a true pepperoni lover, then try their Giant Supreme Pizza, as it is a perfect blend of cheese, pepperoni, beef, green peppers, mushrooms, and red onions.

Best Pizza Near Lynchburg

Madison Heights

Famous thanks to its surprising mix of old and new, with many museums and historical sites alongside modern restaurants and malls, Madison Heights is a small town in Amherst County, Virginia.

Although it is a tiny and quiet place, Madison Heights has enough great restaurants and pizzerias for a night out with family or friends. When in town, head to the Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant as it is a top choice among residents. Their Pepperoni Pizza, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Chicken Hoagies are some of their best sellers and tasty addition to any meal.

Timberlake

Timberlake is a little city in Campbell County, Virginia, home to more Scottish people than any other neighborhood in the United States. Even though Deep-Fried Pizza is a popular Scottish specialty, it is unlikely that you will find it in any pizzeria in Timberlake.

If you are looking for the best pizza in Timberlake, try Brothers Pizza & Grill. The restaurant has been named the best pizzeria in the whole state of Virginia. It serves Italian, American, and Greek dishes, all in one restaurant, so everyone dining here will surely find something suitable to their taste.

Salem

Known for its population of students attending nearby Hollins University, one of the oldest higher education institutions for women in the United States, Salem is a suburb in Virginia. Papa’s Pizza is the best pizzeria in the area that has a beautiful and cozy restaurant that you can dine in.

The Prosciutto Pizza is a popular dish, using original Italian prosciutto, fresh arugula, tomatoes, and cheese. The Supreme Pizza is great if you enjoy an all-ingredients type of pizza, and the Baked Ziti is a good pick if you prefer creamy, rich pasta.