Hilliard is known for Ohio Valley-style Pizza

The Ohio Valley pizza style is very unusual as it is served partly cold. First, the pizza is baked with tomato sauce and a little cheese, and then another generous layer of mozzarella is added above before serving. The mozzarella cheese on top is not cooked and just melts slightly into the pizza due to the heat from the hot tomato sauce. This pizza is delicious, and the cold cheese reveals its aroma and taste when it starts to heat up. For the best Ohio Valley-style pizza experience, you should eat the pizza as soon as it is served. This unique style was born in Ohio, as the name suggests. An Italian soldier, Primo Di Carlo, created it in 1945 in Steubenville inspired by a dish he sampled in Italy during WWII. Today, his niece Anna Di Carlo runs an Italian restaurant in Hilliard where she cooks this amazing pizza. It has a rectangular shape and is cut into two; you can top it with cold pepperoni for a heartier, meatier option.

Best Delivery Pizza in Hilliard

Cottage Inn Pizza is a famous pizza restaurant located in the Hilliard Square Shopping Center that makes the best quality pizza and has great delivery. You can choose the pizza which best fits your mood and preferences from their extensive variety of options, or you can create your own. They have thin crust, deep-dish, New York-style, and personal pizzas. For those who are on a gluten-free diet, they have a separate gluten-free menu with plenty of choices. Most of the time, the delivery from Cottage Inn Pizza takes less time than the time they quote. Your order will arrive hot and be accurate. In the rare case of an error, don’t worry. They will correct it quickly and professionally. Besides pizza, the menu at Cottage Inn Pizza is filled with different Italian and American dishes, appetizers, and salads. Finish off your meal with their Apple Pie Dessert Pizza with a cheesecake filling and perfectly sweet cinnamon apples.

Best Takeout Pizza in Hilliard

Zuko’s Pizza is a local pizzeria with 35 years of successful experience. It is conveniently located in Hoffman Farms and is the best takeout place in the city. Zuko’s makes New York-style and Columbus-style pizzas. Professionalism, passion for their job, and fresh and high-quality ingredients make them one of the favorites with the Hilliard community. Their best sellers from the Columbus-style pizza menu are the Triple Double with double pepperoni, double cheese, and double sauce, and the Stacked – the one with pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onion, and mushrooms. From the New York-style pizza list, their recommendation is the Wifey. It’s full of decadent toppings like roasted portobello mushrooms, goat cheese, and a shallot puree. The pizza is then topped with a flavorful balsamic drizzle. All the pizzas are cooked to perfection. They are always generous with portions and toppings, and the prices are reasonable.

Best Pizza Near Hilliard

Columbus

TAT Ristorante di Famiglia was the first pizza restaurant in Columbus. They started to make pizza in 1930 and are still doing their job today. Their pizza is made with homemade tomato sauce and high-quality provolone cheese, available in four sizes. The TAT Special with pepperoni, mushrooms, Italian sausage, white onion, and banana peppers is a must-try. Thanks to this place, in 1990, the city of Columbus was called the capital of pizza in the US. The restaurant features a beautiful banquet room for parties.

Dublin

Harvest Pizzeria was created with a mission to offer their guests tasty food made of fresh ingredients provided by local farmers. All the ingredients are locally produced, utilizing a sustainability philosophy and a natural way of living. Highlights on the menu of Neapolitan pizza include the Vegetable and Margherita options. The Monaco Pizza is quite unique with arrabbiata sauce, a blend of Italian cheeses, four kinds of meat, fennel sauce, and a drizzle of herbed chili oil.

Worthington

Natalie’s Coal Fired Pizza in Worthington was the first restaurant in central Ohio to use a coal oven to make pizza like they do in New York. Also, its popularity increased when the place became a venue with live music like on-stage jazz and acoustic acts. In addition to being a great entertainment restaurant, they cook delicious pizza, making the place one of the most popular. Besides classic pizza options, they have a weekly special, which changes every week. Combine your favorite pizza with a cocktail or a glass of wine and enjoy the sound and the taste.