5% Off Online!
Cottage Inn Pizza
4674 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026
614-721-4966View Full Hours$10 MinimumMenu
Pizza
Round Cheese Pizza$699+
Classic Cheese Or Create Your Own Pizza.
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza$899+
Classic Cheese Or Create Your Own Pizza.
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza$899+
Classic Cheese Or Create Your Own Pizza.
The Nino Deep Dish Cheese Pizza$499
Classic Cheese Or Create Your Own Pizza.
Gourmet Pizza
Deluxe Pizza$1099+
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
All Meat Pizza$1099+
Pepperoni, Ham, Italian Sausage, Beef, Bacon and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
BBQ Chicken Pizza$1099+
BBQ Sauce,Grilled Chicken,Onions and Bacon and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Hawaiian Pizza$1099+
Ham, Pineapple, Bacon and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Pricebuster Pizza$1099+
Pepperoni, Ham, Italian Sausage, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Ground Beef, Green Olives, Black Olives and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Traditional Vegetarian Pizza$1099+
Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Fresh Tomatoes and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Flavorful Vegetarian Pizza$1099+
Choice Of Up To Five Of Your Favorite Vegetable Toppings Mixed with Feta and Parmesan Cheeses, Topped with Herbal Infused Olive Oil and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Spicy Mediterranean Pizza$1099+
Hot Pepper Rings, Feta Cheese, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Topped with Herbs and Olive Oil.
The Favorite Pizza$1099+
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Topped with Parmesan Cheese and Italian Seasoning.
The Cuban Pizza$1099+
Carolina Gold BBQ Sauce, Pulled Pork and Ham, Topped with Bread and Butter Pickles.
Pesto Primavera Pizza$1099+
Pesto Sauce, Broccoli, Fresh Tomatoes, Feta Cheese, Mushrooms, Black Olives and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Sprinkled with Seasoning.
Teriyaki Chicken Pizza$1099+
Light Teriyaki, Sesame Seeds, Onions, Mushrooms and Chicken.
Greek Pizza$1099+
Feta Cheese, Black Olives, Hot Pepper Rings, Onions, Fresh Tomatoes and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Aloha Chicken Pizza$1099+
Grilled Chicken, Ham, Pineapple and A Light Chipotle Drizzle.
Spinach Supreme Pizza$1099+
Spinach, Feta Cheese, Black Olives, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses and Topped with Olive Oil & Seasoning.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Pizza$1099+
Ranch Sauce, Breaded Chicken, Ham, Bacon and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Chicken Parmesan Pizza$1099+
Grilled Chicken, Onions, Fresh Tomatoes, Parmesan Cheese and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
BLT Pizza$1099+
Ranch, Bacon, Tomatoes, Lettuce and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Chicken Artichoke Pizza$1099+
Grilled Chicken, Artichoke, Spinach, Garlic, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Olive Oil and Herbs.
Garlic Chicken Pizza$1099+
Breaded Chicken, Fresh Tomatoes, Red Onions, Garlic, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses & Parmesan Cheese.
Kick'in Chicken Pizza$1099+
Grilled Chicken, Red Onions, Fresh Tomatoes, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses and Our Flavorful Tomato Sauce Blended with Our Hot and Spicy Buffalo Wing Sauce.
Chicken Mediterranean Pizza$1099+
Grilled Chicken, Feta Cheese, Hot Pepper Rings, Topped with An Herbed Olive Oil and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Ranch Taco Pizza$1099+
Taco Seasoning, Beef, Onions, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Olive Oil, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Cheddar Cheese and Ranch Sauce.
Spicy Italian Pizza$1099+
Pepperoni, Ham, Italian Sausage, Salami, Garlic, Italian Dressing and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Motor City Meatball Pizza$1099+
Meatballs, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Topped with Parmesan Cheese and Italian Seasoning.
Pulled Pork Pizza$1099+
Slow Cooked Pulled Pork In Your Choice Of Sweet Baby Ray's Or Carolina Tangy Gold Sauce with Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Coastal Vegetarian Pizza$1099+
Carolina Gold BBQ Sauce, Spinach, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Black Olives and Feta Cheese.
Philly Steak Supreme Pizza$1099+
Steak, Onions, Green Peppers, Red Peppers and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Hot & Tangy Pizza$1099+
Fresh Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers, Hot Pepper Rings, Crushed Red Peppers and A Light Portion Of Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Spicy Polynesian Pizza$1099+
Pineapple, Green Peppers, BBQ Sauce, Onions, Crushed Red Peppers and a Light Portion Of Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Bacon Cheddar Burger Pizza$1099+
Mild Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Ground Beef, Onions and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Zesty Italian Pizza$1099+
Pesto Sauce, Ham, Italian Sausage, Green Olives and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza$1099+
Alfredo Sauce Based Pizza with Grilled Chicken, Mushrooms, Fresh Tomatoes and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Spinach Alfredo Pizza$1099+
Alfredo Sauce Based Pizza, Spinach, Mushrooms, Fresh Tomatoes and Our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Philly Steak Alfredo Pizza$1099+
Alfredo Sauce Based Pizza With Steak, Onions, Sweet Red Peppers, Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses, Topped with Our Mild Cheddar Cheese.
Garden Vegetable Pizza$1099+
Onions, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Tomatoes, Herbed Olive Oil and A Light Portion Of Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Buffalo Chicken Bleu Pizza$1099+
Light Buffalo Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken.
Calzones
Fresh Calzone$699+
Baked Italian Turnover Of Pizza Dough Filled with Our Special Tomato Sauce, Our Blend Of 3 Cheeses and 3 Toppings Of Your Choice, Brushed with Garlic Butter, Sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese and Served with A Side Of Sauce.
Appetizers
Inn Stix$399
Brushed with Garlic Butter and Topped with Parmesan Cheese Blend. Comes with 1 Pizza Sauce.
Inn Stix$599
Brushed with Garlic Butter and Topped with Parmesan Cheese Blend. Comes with 2 Pizza Sauces.
Everything Inn Stix$399
Brushed with Garlic Butter and Topped with Parmesan Cheese Blend. Comes with 1 Pizza Sauce.
Everything Inn Stix$599
Brushed with Garlic Butter and Topped with Parmesan Cheese Blend. Comes with 2 Pizza Sauces.
Garlic Cheese Bread$699
A Cottage Inn Classic. Our Signature Dough Brushed with Herbed Garlic Butter Spread, Topped with Our Gourmet Cheese Blend and Sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
Garlic Cheese Bread$799+
A Cottage Inn Classic. Our Signature Dough Brushed with Herbed Garlic Butter Spread, Topped with Our Gourmet Cheese Blend and Sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
Bacon Cheddar Bread$699+
An All American Favorite. Garlic Cheese Bread Topped with our Cheddar Cheese, Bacon and Italian Herbs.
Feta Bread$699+
A Mediterranean Twist On Our Cheese Bread. Garlic Cheese Bread Topped with Our Feta Cheese, Italian Herbs and Finished Off with a Drizzle Of Extra Virgin Olive Oil.
Pepperoni Bread$699+
A Great Choice For Any Pepperoni Lover's. Garlic Cheese Bread Topped with Pepperoni and Sprinkled with Italian Herbs and Parmesan Cheese.
Side Orders
Pizza Dipping Sauce$075
Ranch Dipping Sauce$075
Garlic Butter Dipping Sauce$075
Garlic Cream Cheese Dipping Sauce$150
Chips$099
Gourmet Salads
Antipasto Salad$499+
Romaine Lettuce, Red Onions, Hot Peppers, Salami, Tomatoes Our Special Blend Of Three Cheeses and Italian Dressing.
Caesar Salad$399+
Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Shredded Parmesan Cheese and Caesar Dressing.
Chicken Caesar Salad$499+
Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Shredded Parmesan Cheese, Grilled Chicken and Caesar Dressing.
Greek Salad$499+
Romaine Lettuce, Red Onions, Pepperoncini Peppers, Italian Seasoning, Feta Cheese, Beets, Kalamata Olives, Tomatoes and Greek Dressing.
Tossed Salad$399+
Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Croutons and Italian Dressing.
Grilled Chicken Salad$499+
Romaine Lettuce, Grilled Chicken, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Our Special Blend Of Three Cheeses and Italian Dressing.
Cranberry Walnut Salad$499+
Romaine Lettuce, Dried Cranberries, Walnuts, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Bleu Cheese & Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing.
Italian Favorites
Lasagna$899
Our Own Recipe Made with Pasta, Ground Beef, Our Special Tomato Sauce and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Lasagna Dinner$1299
Lasagna, Small Stix and Small Tossed or Caesar Salad. 8 Pieces Innstix Comes with 1 Pizza Sauce and 1 Garlic Butter.
Oven Toasted Subs
BBQ Pulled Pork Sub$499+
Slow Cooked Pulled Pork In Your Choice Of Sweet Baby Ray's Or Carolina Tangy Gold Sauce and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Cuban Sub$499+
Carolina Gold BBQ Sauce, Pulled Pork and Ham, Fresh Gourmet Cheese Blend Topped with Bread and Butter Pickles.
Chicken Parmesan Sub$499+
Pizza Sauce, Breaded Chicken, Parmesan Cheese and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Motor City Meatball Sub$499+
Meatballs, Parmesan Cheese, Pizza Sauce and Our Special Blend Of 3 Cheeses.
Italian Sub$499+
Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Hot Pepper Rings, Onions, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes and Mustard Sauce.
Ham & Cheese Sub$499+
Ham, Provolone Cheese, Hot Pepper Rings, Onions, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes and Mustard Sauce.
Veggie Sub$499+
Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Lettuce, Hot Pepper Rings, Fresh Tomatoes, Provolone Cheese and Mustard.
Cottage Inn Club Sub$499+
Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes, Provolone Cheese and a Side of Mayonnaise.
Chicken Pita Sandwich$799
Grilled Chicken, Feta Cheese, Onions, Lettuce and Fresh Tomatoes on Baked Pita with a Side of Italian Dressing.
Turkey & Cheese Sub$499+
Turkey, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes, Onions, Hot Peppers and a Side of Mayonnaise.
Philly Steak Supreme Sub$499+
Steak, Onions, Hot Peppers, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Fresh Tomatoes, our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses and a side of Ranch Dressing.
Chicken Club Sub$499+
Bacon, Chicken, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes and Provolone Cheese, Served with a Side of Ranch Dressing.
BLT Sub$499+
Bacon, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes and Provolone Cheese, Served with a Side of Ranch Dressing.
BBQ Chicken Sub$499+
BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Onions, Bacon and our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses.
Pizza Sub$499+
Pizza Sauce, our Special Blend of 3 Cheeses and 2 of Your Favorite Toppings.
Wings
Oven Roasted Wings$799+
Try Our New Oven Roasted Wings.
Boneless Wings$799+
Cottage Inn's Wings, Boneless Style.
Breaded Wings$799+
Savory Cottage Inn Original Wings.
Gluten Free Menu
Gluten Free Cheese Pizza$999
Classic Cheese Or Create Your Own Pizza.
Gluten Free Veggie Sandwich$999
Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Lettuce, Hot Pepper Rings, Fresh Tomatoes, Provolone Cheese and Mustard.
Gluten Free Garlic Cheese Bread$999
Gluten Free Crust Spread with Garlic Butter and Topped with Three Cheese Blend and Sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese Served with A Side Of Garlic Butter and A Side Of Pizza Sauce.
Gluten Free Italian Sandwich$999
Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Hot Pepper Rings, Onions, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes and Mustard Sauce.
Gluten Free Ham & Cheese Sandwich$999
Ham, Provolone Cheese, Hot Pepper Rings, Onions, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes and Mustard Sauce.
Gluten Free Turkey & Cheese Sandwich$999
Turkey, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes, Onions, Hot Peppers and a Side of Mayonnaise.
Desserts
Cinnamon Sticks$399+
Oven Baked Bread Brushed with a Cinnamon and Sugar Mix, Smothered with Vanilla Icing.
Chocolate Delight Sticks$399+
Oven Baked Bread Smothered with Chocolate and Vanilla Icing.
Beverages
20 oz. Soda$185+
2 Liter Soda$285+
Water$175
Your Cart
ASAP Delivery
Update
delivery
pickup
We can’t tell if the restaurant delivers to your location unless you provide us with an address.
Edit Address
Your cart is empty. Select from the menu to start an order!
Let Us Help You
Pizzeria Owners
Grow your business with easy online ordering, personalized marketing, and larger orders more often. We list your menu on Slice for free!
Browse Pizza Delivery or Pickup by City
