Skip to main content
Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gellato Cafe

Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gellato Cafe

119 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
309-787-5898

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gellato Cafe a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Antonella's II Sicilian Pizzeria
421 W River Dr, Davenport, IA
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Clint's Draft House Pizza & Grill
1601 W 3rd St, Davenport, IA
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Porter's Village
621 State Ave, Hampton, IL
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
2604 2nd Ave, Muscatine, IA
Open Now$4.90 Delivery
logo
Mamma Mia Restaurante
101 W Mississippi Dr, Muscatine, IA
New
Open Now$4.95 Delivery
logo
Alfano's Pizzeria
508 E Main St, Galesburg, IL
Open Now$3 Delivery
logo
Gumby's Pizza
702 S Gilbert St, Iowa City, IA
Open Now$4 Delivery
logo
Falbo Bros Pizza
457 S Gilbert St, Iowa City, IA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Sam's Pizza
441 S Gilbert St, Iowa City, IA
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Sanctuary Pub
405 S Gilbert St, Iowa City, IA
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
The KETO Kitchen
116 E Washington St, Iowa City, IA
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Zio Johno's - Iowa City
342 Hwy 1 W, Iowa City, IA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Johnny's Bar & Grill
707 Freeport Rd, Sterling, IL
Open NowFree Delivery
logo
Mazzio's Italian Eatery
616 S Roosevelt Ave, Burlington, IA
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Brick & Iron
104 E 7th St, Coralville, IA
Open Now$3.45 Delivery
logo
Pizza Ranch
395 Beaver Kreek Center, North Liberty, IA
Open Now$3.50 Delivery
logo
Main St. Pizza - Mount Pleasant, Iowa
110 S Main St, Mt Pleasant, IA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Pizza Ranch
6095 Carlson Way, Marion, IA
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Scores on 33rd
3287 6th St SW, Cedar Rapids, IA
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Aroma Artisan Pizza
1100 3rd St SE, Cedar Rapids, IA
New
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Zio Johno's - Marion
755 7th Ave, Marion, IA
Open Now$5 Delivery
logo
460 Pizza
8879 Knoxville Ave, Peoria, IL
Open Now$4 Delivery
logo
Oliver's Pizza & Pub North
3300 W Willow Knolls Dr, Peoria, IL
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Zio Johno's - Cedar Rapids
3120 Edgewood Rd SW, Cedar Rapids, IA
Open Now$5 Delivery
logo
Pizza Ranch
2450 Westdale Dr SW, Cedar Rapids, IA
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Nick-N-Willy's Pizza
4700 N University St, Peoria, IL
Open Now$5.10 Delivery
logo
Pizza World
4201 42nd St NE Ste, Cedar Rapids, IA
New
Open Now$5 Delivery
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
woodfired-pizzas
Wood-Fired Pizzas

Double Cheese Pizza

The classic with mozzarella & our original sauce sprinkled with parsley.

$9.49


Pepperoni Pizza

Loaded with big slices of our premium liguria pepperoni, mozzarella & tomato sauce.

$9.49


Sausage Pizza

Italian sausage, three blends of cheeses, our signature tomato sauce & parsley.

$9.49


Sicilian Pizza

Hand pinched chunky Italian sausage with our signature tomato sauce, mozzarella and parsley.

$9.49


Three Cheese Pizza

Parmesan, romano & mozzarella sprinkled with parsley, served with sauce on the side.

$9.49


Hawaiian Pizza

Sweet juicy Hawaiian pineapple, Canadian bacon, mozzarella & parsley sprinkled on top. Go all out for that true Hawaiian flavor and add shredded coconut to your pizza. Additional topping charge applies.

$9.49


Margherita Pizza

Our version of the traditional Margherita pizza with, our signature pizza sauce with fresh, creamy mozzarella cheese, Roma tomatoes, freshly chopped basil, and garlic.

$9.49

specialty-pizzas
Specialty Pizzas

Grilled Chicken Pizza

Grilled chicken shredded with mozzarella, mushroom, red onion, black pepper & romano.

$10.49


B.L.T. Pizza

B.L.T. with our signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, bacon then topped w/lettuce & Roma tomatoes.

$10.49


Spinach Pizza

Fresh spinach leaves with Roma tomatoes, mozzarella, tomato sauce, garlic & fresh basil.

$10.49


Garlic Chicken Pizza

Mozzarella, mushrooms, chicken, roma tomatoes, cheddar, garlic, romano & tarragon.

$10.49


Anchovy Pizza

Anchovies, romano, mozzarella, our signature tomato sauce, red onion & green pepper.

$10.49


Tomato & Basil Pizza

Olive oil, mozzarella, red onion, Roma tomatoes, bacon, garlic, romano cheese, fresh basil and other spices, a very light pizza. Try this with fresh mozzarella!

$10.49


Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Creamy alfredo sauce, mozzarella, chicken, bacon, red onion, cheddar & black pepper.

$10.49


Spinach Alfredo Pizza

Creamy alfredo sauce, fresh spinach leaves, Roma tomatoes, mushroom, mozzarella, white onion & black pepper.

$10.49


Hawaiian Chicken Pizza

Mozzarella, red onion, pineapple & chicken sprinkled with Romano & tarragon.

$10.49


Chicken Ranch Pizza

Ranch dressing, mozzarella, white onion, Roma tomatoes, chicken, oregano, fresh basil, fresh garlic & shredded parmesan.

$10.49


Sauerkraut Pizza

Canadian bacon, mozzarella, sauerkraut with caraway seeds & our signature tomato sauce.

$10.49


Spinach Pesto Pizza

Pesto sauce, fresh spinach leaves, Roma tomatoes, mushroom, mozzarella, garlic, salt & black pepper.

$10.49


Poma Sechi Pizza

Sun dried tomatoes, red onions, mozzarella, garlic & diced Roma tomatoes, sprinkled with chives.

$10.49


Cheddar & Bacon Pizza

Cheddar & mozzarella cheese, red onion & bacon sprinkled with black pepper.

$10.49


Barbecue Chicken Pizza

Shredded barbecue chicken, mozzarella & red onion topped with fresh cilantro.

$10.49


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo hot sauce with chicken, mozzarella & blue cheese crumbles

$10.49


Veggie Pizza

Mushroom, green pepper, black olives, Roma tomatoes, our signature tomato sauce, white onion & mozzarella.

$10.49


Asparagus Pizza

Mozzarella, cut asparagus, pimentos, parmesan & a variety of spices.

$10.49


Parker's Pizza Pie

Pepperoni, hand pinched Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, our signature tomato sauce, mozzarella and parsley.

$10.49


Angelina Mamma Mia Pizza

Meatballs, mushrooms, mozzarella, white onion, tomato sauce and sprinkled with parsley.

$10.49

gourmet-pizzas
Gourmet Pizzas

Italian Stallion Pizza

Our signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onion, garlic, parmesan, romano & parsley.

$11.59


Tex-Mex Pizza

Italian sausage, jalapeno, white onion, green pepper, Roma tomatoes, our signature tomato sauce, cilantro, chives & three blends of cheese.

$11.59


Chicken Fajita Pizza

Mozzarella, green pepper, onions, tomatoes, chicken, cheddar, chives and fresh cilantro.

$11.59


Mediterranean Alfredo Pizza

Creamy alfredo sauce, fresh spinach leaves, Roma tomatoes, mushroom, black olives, artichoke hearts, oregano & mozzarella.

$11.59


Grecian Artichoke Pizza

Artichoke hearts on an olive oil base with mozzarella, Roma tomatoes, black olives, Feta cheese, Romano cheese, fresh basil, oregano, and salt. Try this with fresh mozzarella!

$11.59


Tuscan Alfredo Pizza

Alfredo sauce, spinach, Roma tomatoes, chicken, mushroom, mozzarella, fresh basil, oregano, black pepper, and garlic.

$11.59


Garden Deluxe Pizza

Mozzarella, green peppers, Italian sausage, mushrooms, black olives, Roma tomatoes, our signature tomato sauce & red onion.

$11.59


Sun-Dried Pesto Pizza

Pesto sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, salami, fresh garlic, salt & black pepper.

$11.59


Taco Pizza

Seasoned taco beef, black olives, cheddar, Roma tomatoes, our signature tomato sauce, white onions, topped with taco chips & fresh lettuce.

$11.59


Western Poppy Pizza

This is just like our South Western pizza only with our wildly popular poppyseed dressing with mozzarella, bacon, red onion, chicken, cheddar, black pepper & oregano.

$11.59


South Western Pizza

Tangy barbeque sauce base with mozzarella, cheddar, red onion, bacon, grilled chicken, black pepper & oregano.

$11.59


Thai Chicken Pizza

Spicy peanut sauce with mozzarella, chicken, bean sprouts, green onion, carrots, and cilantro.

$11.59


Cashew Chicken Pizza

A thin layer of general Tso's sauce with mozzarella, chicken, white onion, cashews, shredded carrots, and cilantro.

$11.59

appetizers
Appetizers

Pagalo's Famous Breadsticks

Try an order of our most talked about appetizer from our wood-fired oven! Basket of 6 breadsticks, includes dipping sauce. Brushed with butter, with your choice of garlic salt, poppy seed or sesame seed.

$3.99


Baked Jalapeno Poppers

Cream cheese filled jalapeno poppers baked, not fried in our wood-fired oven, served with a side of ranch dressing,

$6.99


Toasted Ravioli

Toasted Ravioli filled with Italian sausage and cheese, baked in our wood-fired oven, sprinkled with parmesan cheese and served with our own marinara sauce.

$7.99


Spicy Popcorn Chicken

Tender chunks of boneless chicken breast seasoned and breaded baked in our wood-fired oven, served with your choice of sauce for dipping, our BBQ sauce, ranch dressing, or hot sauce.

$6.99


Our Famous "Cricket Nachos"

Almost as popular as our breadsticks this appetizer is loaded with tortilla chips, taco flavored beef, melted jalapeno cheese, black olives, tomatoes &jalapeño. Sour cream is available upon request.

$9.49


Baked Mozzarella Sticks

Yes, baked in our wood-fired oven, not in grease. Six mozzarella sticks per order includes marinara sauce for dipping, please allow ten minutes to bake.

$6.49


Spinach Artichoke Dip

This is a great spinach dip with melted parmesan cheese mixed in, served with tortilla chips for dipping.

$8.99


Hush Puppies

Golden hush puppies baked in our wood-fired oven and served with a side of our sweet honey mustard.

$4.49

soup
Soup

Soup of the Day

Please call the restaurant for today's selection.

$3.59


Wisconsin Cheese Soup

A creamy blend of cheeses laced with bits of bacon & celery makes this a smooth, creamy soup and one of our most popular.

$3.59


Hearty Chicken Noodle Soup

One of everyone's favorites with thick noodles, carrots & chunks of chicken blended into a hearty seasoned broth.

$3.59


Bread Bowl Soup

This is an edible sourdough bread bowl brushed with butter & garlic and baked in our oven, overflowing with your choice of any of our > soups sprinkled with a dash of chives.

$3.59

salads
Salads

Pagalo’s Signature Salad

This salad is our signature with bacon, eggs, Roma tomatoes, artichoke hearts, shaved parmesan and croutons on top of a bed of romaine, iceberg and radicchio lettuce, with a Chianti Basil vinaigrette dressing

$7.99


Spinach Salad

Fresh leaf spinach with real bacon bits, sliced red onion & eggs topped with croutons, served with hot bacon dressing.

$6.29


Caprese Salad

This simple and very fresh salad has 6 slices of fresh mozzarella, Roma tomatoes and fresh basil leaves with a balsamic glaze drizzle and extra virgin olive oil on the side.

$5.99


Cranberry Walnut Salad

This salad is made with our mix of romaine, iceberg and radicchio lettuce and topped with dried cranberries, honey maple walnuts, bacon, and feta cheese, served with our Chianti basil vinaigrette.

$8.49


Mandarin Orange Salad

This is our most talked about salad. A great mix of romaine, iceberg and radicchio lettuce with real bacon, mandarin oranges, croutons, and our simply sweet poppyseed dressing.

$6.49


Caesar Salad

The classic Caesar salad blended together with romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing with our garlic/ parmesan croutons.

$5.99


BLT Wedge Salad

Romaine lettuce sprinkled with bacon, Roma tomatoes and shaved Parmesan and served with roasted garlic Parmesan dressing.

$5.99


Italian Chef Salad

Salad Our mix of romaine, iceberg & radicchio lettuce with strips of salami, turkey & pepperoni with eggs, black olives, blue cheese crumbles, green olives, croutons, and Italian dressing.

$9.49

sandwiches
Sandwiches
All sandwiches served with your choice of chips, cottage cheese or applesauce and a pickle.

Italian Beef Sandwich

Juicy Italian beef served on a ciabatta hoagie roll with a side of au jus sauce for dipping.

$8.99


Hot Ham on Marble Sandwich

Smoked ham served on Vienna style wheat berry bread with mayonnaise & mustard on the side.

$8.29


Chicken Salad Sandwich

Try our signature homemade chicken salad sandwich with a mixture of celery & grapes served on a buttery croissant.

$8.79


Deluxe Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Made with shedded Cheddar and toasted in our wood-fired oven.

$7.29


BBQ Pork Sandwich

Natural hickory smoked pulled barbecue pork served on a ciabatta hoagie roll.

$8.79


Turkey Basil Aioli Sandwich

Oven roasted turkey on Vienna style wheat berry bread served with mayonnaise & mustard on the side.

$8.49


Tuna Salad Sandwich

A classic tuna salad sandwich served on our hearty Vienna style wheat berry bread.

$8.79


Hot Italian Sandwich

Served on our ciabatta hoagie roll with ham, pepperoni, genoa salami, banana pepper, red onion, Roma tomatoes, pepper jack & Italian dressing.

$8.79

desserts
Desserts

Cinnamon Breadsticks

Six warm, right out of the oven cinnamon breadsticks served with a side of hot vanilla icing for dipping. Fresh, delicious, addicting.

$4.99


Red Velvet Cheesecake

3 layers of chocolate infused red velvet cake, layered and iced with cream cheese frosting.

$5.79


Chocolate Overload Cake

$5.79


Giant Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$7.99


Tiramisu

Tiramisu translates to "pick me up." That's exactly what you will want to do with this modern Italian classic with light crispy ladyfingers soaked in a combination of liqueurs and espresso, then topped with mascarpone cheese and a light cocoa dusting.

$5.79


Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Creamy caramel cheesecake baked on a sweet and salty almond crust topped with a thick bed of buttery caramel and a sprinkle of more almonds. This is made with gluten-free ingredients.

$5.49

lunch-pizzas
Lunch Pizza's
Only available 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Lunch Cheese Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Hawaiian Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Sausage Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Three Cheese Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Pepperoni Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Canadian Bacon Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Grilled Chicken Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Cheddar & Bacon Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Spinach Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Tomato & Basil Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Margherita Pizza

$5.49


Lunch Sicilian Pizza

$5.49

SliceILMilan61264 Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gellato Cafe
Price: $$