Skip to main content
New Bethel Ordinary

New Bethel Ordinary

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239
317-862-5020

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give New Bethel Ordinary a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Mama Nita's Pizza
5040 US-52, New Palestine, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Chicago's Pizza With A Twist - Greenwood
997 E County Line Rd, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
The Original Chicago's Pizza
916 E Main St, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Cicis Pizza
3652 S East St, Indianapolis, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings
1267 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Luca Pizza di Roma (Greenwood Park Mall)
1251 US-31, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Chicago's Pizza
1280 US-31, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Buca Di Beppo
659 US 31 North, Greenwood, IN
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Ellison Brewing Co
501 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Greek’s Pizzeria
1601 Columbia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Giorgio's Pizza
9 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Chicago's Pizza
2245 Sheek Rd, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Buca Di Beppo
35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Pronta Pizzeria
325 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake Pizza
1011 N State Rd 135, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Cugino's Pizza
4751 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Luca Pizza Di Roma
250 IN-135, Greenwood, IN
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Toppers Pizza
910 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake Pizza
10635 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN
Open NowPickup Only
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
pizza
Pizza
The signature item of the ordinary.

Deluxe Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, onion.

$16.00


Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham Italian sausage, bacon.

$16.00


Hawaiian Pizza

Ham, pineapple, bbq sauce.

$14.00


BBQ Chicken Pizza

Grilled chicken, redo onion, bbq sauce.

$14.00


Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$12.00

appetizers
Appetizers

Breadsticks

Nacho cheese, pizza sauce, garlic buitter.

$5.99


BBQ Pulled Pork Nachos

Tortilla chips, smoked pulled pork, white queso bbq, tomato, jalapeno, guacamole.

$10.99


Potato Skins

Cheese, bacon, ranch, sour cream.

$9.99


Loaded Fries

Cheese bacon, ranch, sour cream.

$9.99


Tanderloin Strips

Han breaded, horseradish sauce, ranch.

$8.99


Chicken Strips

Hand breaded, choice of sauce.

$8.99


Fried Cauliflower

Ranch.

$6.99


Breaded Mushrooms

Ranch.

$6.99


Quesadilla

Traditional, bbq, buffalo.

$7.99


Onion Ring Tower

Petal dipping sauce.

$7.99


Mozzarella Sticks

Marinara.

$6.99


Sampler Platter

Onion rings, fried cauliflower, mozz sticks.

$8.99

soup
Soup

Ham & Bean Soup

$2.50


Chili Soup

$2.50

salads
Salads

Side Salad

House or Caesar.

$4.99


Chicken Salad

Chicken strips, cheddar, bacon, tomato.

$8.99


Chicken Caesar Salad

Grilled chicken, parmesan, croutons.

$8.99


Chef Salad

Ham, turkey, egg, cheddar, tomato, bacon.

$8.99


Wedge Salad

Iceberg wedge, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, red onion, tomato, bleu cheese dressing.

$6.99

sides
Sides

Fries

$2.59


Cottage Cheese

$2.59


Cole Slaw

$2.59


Potato Salad

$2.59


Green Beans

$2.59


Apple Sauce

$2.59

sandwiches
Sandwiches
Served with choice of two sides.

Chicken Sandwich

Hand breaded or grilled.

$9.99


Texas Toast BLT

Bacon lettuce, tomato, mayo, texas toast.

$8.99


Beef Brisket Sandwich

House smoked, side of bbq sauce.

$11.99


Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich

$8.99


French Dip Sandwich

Roast beef, swiss, hoagie bun, au jus.

$10.99


Fish Sandwich

Hand breaded.

$8.99


Pulled Pork Sandwich

House smoked side of bbq sauce.

$10.99


Cuban Sandwich

Ham, pulled pork, mustard, pickle, hoagie bun.

$10.99

burgers
Burgers
Our burgers are fresh, 1/2 pound, 100% Angus beef.

Texas BBQ Burger

Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce, onion rings.

$10.99


Patty Melt Burger

Marble rye, swiss sauteed onions, 100 islands.

$10.99


Shroom Burger

Sauteed mushrooms swiss.

$10.99


Bacon Bleu Burger

Bacon, bleu cheese crumbles.

$10.99


Build your own Burger

Bacon, bleu cheese crumbles.

$8.99

wings
Wings
Ten wings with ranch or bleu cheese and celery.

Wings

$9.99

dinner
Dinner

Open Faced Manhattan

$11.99


Fish & Chips

Beer battered pollock, fried, coleslaw.

$11.99


Spaghetti

Texas toast, house or caesar salad.

$11.99


Chicken Breast Fillets

Grilled or breaded, potato, house or caesar salad, bread, green beans.

$12.99

kids-menu
Kids Menu
12 & under.

Kid's Chicken Fingers

With fries.

$5.99


Kid's Mini Corn Dogs

With fries.

$5.99


Kid's Spaghetti

With garlic bread.

$5.99


Kid's Grilled Cheese

With fries.

$5.99


Kid's Cheese Pizza

$5.99

desserts
Desserts

Bread Pudding

Cinnamon sauce.

$4.99


Brownie Ala Mode

Brownie, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate syrup.

$5.99

beverages
Beverages

Iced Tea

$2.69


Soda

$2.69


Coffe

$1.99


Milk

$2.29


O.J.

$2.29

SlicePizza Places in Wanamaker, IN New Bethel Ordinary
Price: $$