Big Pauly's Pizza

314 Ellicott St, Batavia, NY 14020
585-343-2447

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Big Pauly's Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
pizza
Pizza
Hand-tossed and heart baked.

Homemade Red Sauce With Cheese

Red sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$7.49

specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza

Classic White Pizza AKA "The Q"

Classic garlic sauce, a special ricotta cheese blend, broccoli, spinach and mozzarella cheese.

$10.99


Chicken Pizza

Grilled chicken, mozzarella, your choice of sauce.

$8.99


Steak Pizza

Our classic garlic sauce, 100% ribeye shaved steak, sweet peppers, onion, and mozzarella cheese.

$10.99


Greek Pizza

Our classic greek oil, spinach, tomatoes, red and green sweet pepper mix and kalamata olives. Topped with feta and mozzarella cheese.

$10.99


Hawaiian Pizza

Red sauce, ham, bacon, pineapple topped with mozzarella cheese.

$10.99


Veggie Pizza

Red sauce, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, tomatoes, sweet peppers topped with mozzarella cheese.

$10.99

munchies
Munchies

Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella Sticks with a side of pizza sauce.

$6.99


Pizza Fingers

Pizza fingers with a side of pizza sauce.

$6.99


Hodge Podge

Veggies: broccoli bites, cheese bites, zucchini, cauliflower, and mushrooms. Served with blue cheese.

$8.99


Pauly's Fresh Cut Fries

$2.99


Loaded Fresh Cut Fries

Fresh cut fries topped with bacon, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of ranch.

$5.99


Garlic Bread With Cheese

A Costanzo roll with our garlic oil and topped with mozzarella cheese served with a side of red pizza sauce.

$2.99


Onion Rings

$3.49


Mushroom Caps

Served with blue cheese.

$6.49


Pauly's Fried Dough

Shaken in powdered sugar.

$3.99


Breaded Raviolli With Red Sauce

Served with pizza sauce.

$6.49


Beer Battered Shrimp

With fresh-cut fries and cocktail sauce or toss them in our medium wing sauce for a "willbe" buffalo shrimp.

$8.99

paulys-big-salads
Pauly's "BIG" Salads

Steak Salad

Bed of lettuce, tomato, onion, shaved ribeye steak, cheddar, mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of dressing.

$8.99


Turkey Club Salad

Bed of lettuce, tomato, onions, cheddar, mozzarella cheese, turkey and bacon. Served with your choice of dressing.

$8.99


Antipasto Salad

Bed of lettuce. Served with all the veggies, tomatoes, onion, banana peppers, sweet peppers, black olives, green olives, and some meats ham, salami, and pepperoni, sprinkled with some parmesan cheese.

$8.99


Buffalo Chicken Cheddar Salad

Bed of lettuce, tomatoes, onion, and chicken, your choice of sauce and cheddar cheese.

$8.99


Grilled Chicken Salad

Bed of lettuce, tomatoes, onion, grilled chicken chunks. Topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of dressing.

$8.99


Garden Salad

Bed of lettuce, tomatoes, and onion. Served with your choice of dressing.

$2.99


Pauly's Chicken Finger Salad

Hand-dipped chicken fingers with the sauce of your choice cut up and placed into a garden salad with mozzarella & cheddar.

$9.99

chicken-wings
Chicken Wings

Regular Chicken Wings

We can only split buckets and doubles half and half with different sauces. Special instructions are only available for the split flavor of wings. No "extra's" will be honored.

$6.49


Boneless Chicken Wings

We can only split buckets and doubles half and half with different sauces. Special instructions are only available for the split flavor of wings. No "extra's" will be honored.

$6.49


Blueberry Chicken Wings

Big Pauly is proud to present blueberry wings. Be excited, be berry excited.

$5.99

calzones
Calzones

Create Your Own Calzone

Create your own add as many free toppings as you want.

$11.99

paulys-famous-fingers
Pauly's Famous Fingers

Pauly's Famous Fingers

Fresh hand-battered, not frozen! You're gonna love 'em!!! Just to make sure you have your fingers crisp and fresh we do not dip our fingers, we put sauce on the side only! Dip in any one of our many sauces. Includes fresh-cut fries, blue cheese, and celery.

$9.49

hot-subs
Hot Subs

Uncle Pauly Sub

Sausage, capicola, & sweet peppers and provolone cheese.

$6.99


Pizza Sub

Pepperoni & mozzarella cheese.

$6.99


Sausage Sub

Sausage sub topped with sweet peppers and provolone cheese.

$6.99


Meatball Sub

A mound of meatballs topped with pasta sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$6.99


Grilled Chicken Sub

Grilled Chicken Sub topped with melted Mozzarella cheese.

$6.99


Chicken Finger Sub

Pauly's famous chicken fingers on a Costanzo roll. Topped with your choice of sauce if desired and with cheese.

$6.99


Chicken Club Sub

Pauly's famous chicken fingers on a Costanzo roll, with your choice of sauce, bacon and a cheese.

$6.99


Cheeseburger Sub

Hamburgers on a Costanzo roll, topped with your choice of cheese, and toppings.

$6.99


Steak Hoagie Sub

100% ribeye steak shaved and topped with mushrooms & onions.

$6.99


The Cuban Melt Sub

Ham, capicola, cheddar, & provolone cheese.

$6.99


Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub

Ham, swiss, & blue cheese.

$6.99


The Batavia Bomber Sub

100% shaved ribeye steak, banana peppers, swiss, mushrooms, onions, & hot sauce.

$6.99


Eggplant Parmesan Sub

Eggplant, pasta sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$6.99


Chicken Parmesan Sub

Pauly's famous chicken fingers on a Costanzo roll, with red sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese.

$6.99

cold-subs
Cold Subs

Veggie Sub

With your choice of cheese. Any veggie we have available you can have on your sub.

$5.99


Ham Sub

With your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Turkey Sub

With your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Turkey Bacon Sub

Turkey with bacon and your choice of cheese.

$6.99


Tuna Sub

$5.99


The Grand Salami Sub

It's just a fancy name for a big salami sub, but the name is cool, right?

$5.99


BLT Sub

Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.

$5.99


Capicola Sub

With your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Cheese Sub

You choose any of our cheeses or all of them. Mozzarella, Swiss, American, provolone, and cheddar.

$5.99


Italian Assorted Sub

Ham, salami and capicola and served with your choice of cheese.

$5.99

wraps
Wraps

Uncle Pauly Wrap

Sausage, capicola, & sweet peppers and provolone cheese.

$6.99


Pizza Wrap

Pepperoni & mozzarella cheese.

$5.99


Sausage Wrap

Sausage sub topped with sweet peppers and provolone cheese.

$5.99


Meatball Wrap

A mound of meatballs topped with pasta sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$5.99


Grilled Chicken Wrap

Grilled Chicken Sub topped with melted Mozzarella cheese.

$5.99


Chicken Finger Wrap

Pauly's famous chicken fingers on a Costanzo roll. Topped with your choice of sauce if desired and with cheese.

$5.99


Chicken Club Wrap

Pauly's famous chicken fingers on a Costanzo roll, with your choice of sauce, bacon and a cheese.

$5.99


Cheeseburger Wrap

Hamburgers on a Costanzo roll, topped with your choice of cheese, and toppings.

$5.99


Steak Hoagie Wrap

100% ribeye steak shaved and topped with mushrooms & onions.

$5.99


The Cuban Melt Wrap

Ham, capicola, cheddar, & provolone cheese.

$5.99


Chicken Cordon Bleu Wrap

Ham, swiss, & blue cheese.

$5.99


The Batavia Bomber Sub Wrap

100% shaved ribeye steak, banana peppers, swiss, mushrooms, onions, & hot sauce.

$5.99


Eggplant Parmesan Wrap

Eggplant, pasta sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$5.99


Chicken Parmesan Wrap

Pauly's famous chicken fingers on a Costanzo roll, with red sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese.

$5.99


Veggie Wrap

With your choice of cheese. Any veggie we have available you can have on your sub.

$5.99


Ham Wrap

With your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Turkey Wrap

With your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Turkey Bacon Wrap

Turkey with bacon and your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Tuna Wrap

$5.99


The Grand Salami Wrap

It's just a fancy name for a big salami sub, but the name is cool, right?

$5.99


BLT Wrap

Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.

$5.99


Capicola Wrap

With your choice of cheese.

$5.99


Cheese Wrap

You choose any of our cheeses or all of them. Mozzarella, Swiss, American, provolone, and cheddar.

$5.99


Italian Assorted Wrap

Ham, salami and capicola and served with your choice of cheese.

$5.99

paulys-pasta
Pauly's Pasta

Spaghetti

Served with 2 meatballs or 1 sausage along with Pauly's tasty red sauce comes with a side salad and a garlic bread.

$8.99


Ziti

Served with 2 meatballs or 1sausage and Pauly's tasty red sauce served with a side salad and a garlic bread.

$8.99


Cheese Ravioli

Served with red sauce. Served with a side salad and garlic bread.

$9.49


Meat Ravioli

Served with red sauce. Served with a side salad and garlic bread.

$9.49


Pauly's Super Supreme Spaghetti

Served with red sauce, 2 meatballs, 2 sausages, and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Served with a side salad and garlic bread.

$11.49


Eggplant Parmesan

Eggplant, mozzarella, over pasta with red sauce. Served with a side salad and garlic bread.

$9.99

beverages
Beverages

Soda

$1.99


Lipton Tea

$2.09

SliceRestaurants in Batavia Big Pauly's Pizza
Price: $$