Mozzarella Cheese Thin Crust Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$8.99
Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$10.99
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$10.99
Mozzarella Cheese Deep Dish Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$8.99
Chicago Style Mozzarella Cheese Deep Dish Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$9.98
Mozzarella Cheese Sicilian Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$14.99
Mozzarella Cheese Stuffed Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$15.99
The Star Special Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green pepper, black olive, diced tomato & mozzarella cheese.
$15.99
The "Don" Pizza
Italian beef, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & mozzarella.
$15.99
Mama Pagoni's Kitchen Sink Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & mozzarella.
$15.99
The Ulti-Meat Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, ground beef, bacon & mozzarella cheese.
$15.99
The Great White Pizza
Grilled chicken, olive oil, fresh garlic, fresh basil, spinach, red onions, diced tomatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese (no red sauce).
$15.99
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Garlic buttered crust, pizza sauce, marinated shrimp & fresh garlic topped with mozzarella!
$15.99
Margherita Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced tomato, extra virgin olive oil & fresh garlic sprinkled with oregano.
$15.99
Angela's Pesto Pizza
Basil & garlic pesto with grilled chicken on a double crust topped with pine nuts, chopped tomato & mozzarella.
$14.99
Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Grilled chicken marinated in tangy BBQ sauce with cilantro, sliced red onions & mozzarella.
$14.99
Hawaiian Pizza
Canadian bacon, ham, pineapple & mozzarella.
$14.99
Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza
Grilled chicken, buffalo ranch dressing, garlic, red onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar cheese. Baked on double crust.
$14.99
Chicken Ranch Pizza
Grilled chicken, ranch dressing, garlic, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar baked on a double crust.
$14.99
Quattro Formaggio Pizza
Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese.
$14.99
Veggie Garden Special Pizza
Spinach, green peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced tomatoes, broccoli & mozzarella.
$14.99
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Grilled chicken, Alfredo sauce, garlic & broccoli with mozzarella cheese baked on a double crust.
$14.99
All American Cheeseburger Pizza
Ground beef, bacon, cheddar, tomatoes & Italian sausage.
$14.99
The Mac Pizza
Macaroni & cheese pizza prepared with aged cheeses.
$14.99
B.L.T. Pizza
Bacon, ham & mozzarella cheese. Baked then topped with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo or try ranch dressing for a different twist!
$14.99
Jerk Chicken Pizza
Marinated jerk chicken with red onions, jalapeños, pineapple, cilantro, pineapple & fresh garlic.
$14.99
The Star Special Sicilian Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green pepper, black olive, diced tomato & mozzarella cheese.
$18.99
The "Don" Sicilian Pizza
Italian beef, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & mozzarella.
$18.99
Mama Pagoni's Kitchen Sink Sicilian Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & mozzarella.
$18.99
The Ulti-Meat Sicilian Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, ground beef, bacon & mozzarella cheese.
$18.99
The Great White Sicilian Pizza
Grilled chicken, olive oil, fresh garlic, fresh basil, spinach, red onions, diced tomatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese (no red sauce).
$18.99
Shrimp Scampi Sicilian Pizza
Garlic buttered crust, pizza sauce, marinated shrimp & fresh garlic topped with mozzarella!
$18.99
Margherita Sicilian Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced tomato, extra virgin olive oil & fresh garlic sprinkled with oregano.
$18.99
Angela's Pesto Sicilian Pizza
Basil & garlic pesto with grilled chicken on a double crust topped with pine nuts, chopped tomato & mozzarella.
$17.99
Barbecue Chicken Sicilian Pizza
Grilled chicken marinated in tangy BBQ sauce with cilantro, sliced red onions & mozzarella.
$17.99
Hawaiian Sicilian Pizza
Canadian bacon, ham, pineapple & mozzarella.
$17.99
Buffalo Chicken Ranch Sicilian Pizza
Grilled chicken, buffalo ranch dressing, garlic, red onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar cheese. Baked on the double crust.
$17.99
Chicken Ranch Sicilian Pizza
Grilled chicken, ranch dressing, garlic, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar baked on a double crust.
$17.99
Quattro Formaggio Sicilian Pizza
Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese.
$17.99
Veggie Garden Special Sicilian Pizza
Spinach, green peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced tomatoes, broccoli & mozzarella.
$17.99
Chicken Alfredo Sicilian Pizza
Grilled chicken, Alfredo sauce, garlic & broccoli with mozzarella cheese baked on a double crust.
$17.99
All American Cheeseburger Sicilian Pizza
Ground beef, bacon, cheddar, tomatoes & Italian sausage.
$17.99
The Mac Sicilian Pizza
Macaroni & cheese pizza prepared with aged cheeses.
$17.99
B.L.T. Sicilian Pizza
Bacon, ham & mozzarella cheese. Baked then topped with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo or try ranch dressing for a different twist!
$17.99
Jerk Chicken Sicilian Pizza
Marinated jerk chicken with red onions, jalapeños, pineapple, cilantro, pineapple & fresh garlic.
$17.99
The Star Special Deep Dish Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green pepper, black olive, diced tomato & mozzarella cheese.
$18.99
The "Don" Deep Dish Pizza
Italian beef, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & mozzarella.
$18.99
Mama Pagoni's Kitchen Sink Deep Dish Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & mozzarella.
$18.99
The Ulti-Meat Deep Dish Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, ground beef, bacon & mozzarella cheese.
$18.99
The Great White Deep Dish Pizza
Grilled chicken, olive oil, fresh garlic, fresh basil, spinach, red onions, diced tomatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese (no red sauce).
$18.99
Shrimp Scampi Deep Dish Pizza
Garlic buttered crust, pizza sauce, marinated shrimp & fresh garlic topped with mozzarella!
$18.99
Margherita Deep Dish Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced tomato, extra virgin olive oil & fresh garlic sprinkled with oregano.
$18.99
Angela's Pesto Deep Dish Pizza
Basil & garlic pesto with grilled chicken on a double crust topped with pine nuts, chopped tomato & mozzarella.
$17.99
Barbecue Chicken Deep Dish Pizza
Grilled chicken marinated in tangy BBQ sauce with cilantro, sliced red onions & mozzarella.
$17.99
Hawaiian Deep Dish Pizza
Canadian bacon, ham, pineapple & mozzarella.
$17.99
Buffalo Chicken Ranch Deep Dish Pizza
Grilled chicken, buffalo ranch dressing, garlic, red onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar cheese. Baked on the double crust.
$17.99
Chicken Ranch Deep Dish Pizza
Grilled chicken, ranch dressing, garlic, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar baked on a double crust.
$17.99
Quattro Formaggio Deep Dish Pizza
Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese.
$17.99
Veggie Garden Special Deep Dish Pizza
Spinach, green peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced tomatoes, broccoli & mozzarella.
$17.99
Chicken Alfredo Deep Dish Pizza
Grilled chicken, Alfredo sauce, garlic & broccoli with mozzarella cheese baked on a double crust.
$17.99
All American Cheeseburger Deep Dish Pizza
Ground beef, bacon, cheddar, tomatoes & Italian sausage.
$17.99
The Mac Deep Dish Pizza
Macaroni & cheese pizza prepared with aged cheeses.
$17.99
Jerk Chicken Deep Dish Pizza
Marinated jerk chicken with red onions, jalapeños, pineapple, cilantro, pineapple & fresh garlic.
$17.99
Sicilian 2-Topping 1/4 Sheet 9"x12" Thursday Special
Available Thursday only.
$14.99
Sicilian 2-Topping 1/2 Sheet 12"x18" Thursday Special
Available Thursday only.
$19.99
Chicken Tender Basket
Chicken tenders with a side of potato wedges.
$8.49
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
With Mama Pagoni's marinara.
$6.99
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Piping hot & bubbly. Served with marinara.
$5.49
Fresh Breadsticks
Garlic kissed. Served with marinara for dipping.
$3.49
Garlic Kissed Bread
Made fresh to order. Served with marinara.
$4.49
Cheese Pizza Bread
Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese.
$5.99
Cheese Pizza Bread with Sausage
Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & sausage.
$6.49
Cheese Pizza Bread with Pepperoni
Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.
$6.49
Onion Rings
Served with zesty sauce.
$5.99
Potato Wedges
$4.49
Traditional Chicken Wings
A pound of our plump, juicy chicken wings either hot or BBQ.
$11.49
Boneless Wings
All white meat.
$7.99
Cheese Stuffed Breadsticks
Garlic kissed, stuffed with cheese & served with Mama Pagoni's marinara.
$5.49
Mama's Dipping Stick Pizza
A dozen dipping sticks made with a garlic butter crust, topped with mozzarella & cheddar cheese, served with Mama Pagoni's pizza dipping sauce.
$11.99
Jalapeno & Cheddar Sticks
Stuffed Breadsticks with ranch dipping sauce.
$6.49
Mama Pagoni's Sampler
Fried mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders & onion rings served with ranch & marinara sauce.
$10.99
Bruschetta
Perfectly seasoned ripe plum tomatoes with fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh chopped basil leaves & drizzled with balsamic vinegar. Served on toasted sliced French bread.
$8.99
Chicken Bacon Salad
Crispy or grilled chicken tossed with cheddar cheese, bacon & tomatoes nestled on a crisp bed of lettuce.
$9.99
Garden Salad
Broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions & fresh parmesan.
$4.99
Garden Salad with Chicken
Broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions & fresh parmesan.
$10.99
Antipasto Salad
Salami, pepperoni, provolone, olives & peppers in our house dressing.
$5.49
Chef's Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, black olives, salami, ham, turkey & mozzarella.
$9.99
Wisconsin Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons & fresh parmesan tossed with Caesar dressing.
$4.99
Wisconsin Caesar Salad with Chicken
Romaine lettuce, croutons & fresh parmesan tossed with Caesar dressing.
$10.99
Create Your Own Plain Cheese Calzone
$9.99
The House Calzone
Pepperoni, sausage, onion & green pepper.
$12.49
Mama Pagoni's Special Calzone
Steak, onion, green pepper & mushroom.
$12.99
Quattro Formaggio Calzone
Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese.
$12.49
Spinach Calzone
$10.98
Sausage Calzone
$10.98
Pepperoni Calzone
$10.98
Create Your Own Plain Cheese Stromboli
$9.99
The Traditional Stromboli
Pepperoni, sausage, onion & green pepper.
$11.49
Garden Stromboli
Spinach, mushrooms, diced tomato, green peppers & broccoli.
$10.99
Syracuse Stuffer Stromboli
Steak, onion, green peppers & mushroom.
$11.99
Spinach Stromboli
$10.98
Sausage Stromboli
$10.98
Pepperoni Stromboli
$10.98
Philly Steak Sandwich
With onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella & BBQ sauce on garlic bread.
$9.99
Philly Chicken Sandwich
With onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella & BBQ sauce on garlic bread.
$9.99
Hot Ham & Cheese Sandwich
On garlic kissed bread.
$8.99
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo sauce, crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar, bleu cheese or ranch.
$9.99
Grilled Chicken Caesar Sandwich
With romaine lettuce, bacon, parmesan & cheddar cheese tossed in Caesar dressing.
$9.49
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
With crispy chicken, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella on garlic bread.
$8.99
Turkey Melt Sandwich
With mozzarella, cheddar & sauteed onions.
$8.99
Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich
Thinly sliced beef.
$9.99
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Comes with Italian sausage.
$9.99
Italian Beef & Sausage Sandwich
Comes with beef & Italian sausage.
$10.99
Italian Meatball Sandwich
With red sauce.
$8.99
Italian Sub
With ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes & Italian dressing.
$8.99
Turkey Breast Sub
With provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo or Italian dressing. (Healthy)
$8.49
Ham Sub
With provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo or Italian dressing. (Healthy)
$8.49
Veggie Sub
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, mushrooms, green peppers, broccoli, red onions, provolone & Italian dressing.
$8.49
Chicken Ranch Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, cheddar cheese, bacon, tomatoes & ranch dressing.
$9.49
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, romaine lettuce, tomatoes & cheddar cheese. Bleu cheese or ranch dressing.
$9.99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, bacon, parmesan & cheddar cheese, romaine lettuce and Caesar dressing.
$9.49
Chicken Ranch Panini
Grilled chicken breast, bacon, sliced tomatoes, provolone cheese, topped off with ranch dressing.
$9.49
Turkey Panini
Thinly sliced ham or turkey, sliced tomatoes, red onions, cheddar & mozzarella cheese grilled to perfection.
$9.49
Ham Panini
Thinly sliced ham or turkey, sliced tomatoes, red onions, cheddar & mozzarella cheese grilled to perfection.
$9.49
Club Panini
Thinly sliced ham, turkey, bacon, sliced tomatoes, red onions, cheddar & provolone cheese.
$9.49
Tuscan Chicken Panini
Sliced chicken breast, roasted red peppers, sliced tomatoes, mozzarella cheese & zesty tomato pesto!
$9.49
Baked Mostaccioli
Marinara sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese & baked to perfection.
$10.99
Fettuccine Alfredo
Mama Pagoni’s creamy alfredo sauce with fresh parmesan cheese.
$12.99
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Mama Pagoni’s creamy alfredo sauce with fresh parmesan cheese.
$13.99
Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp
Mama Pagoni’s creamy alfredo sauce with fresh parmesan cheese.
$16.99
Meat Ravioli
Ravioli stuffed with meat.
$10.99
Cheese Ravioli
Ravioli stuffed with classic cheese.
$10.99
Pasta Mona Lisa with Sausage
Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers in garlic butter sauce on a bed of penne pasta.
$14.99
Pasta Mona Lisa with Chicken
Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers in garlic butter sauce on a bed of penne pasta.
$14.99
Pasta Mona Lisa with Shrimp
Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers in garlic butter sauce on a bed of penne pasta.
$17.99
Chicken Parmigiana
Whole lightly breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce on spaghetti & smothered with cheese.
$12.99
Chicken Pesto Cavatappi
With your choice of basil or sun-dried tomato cream pesto with grilled chicken.
$13.99
Lasagna in Marinara Sauce
Family favorite! Hand layered, made fresh to order with your choice of meat, cheese or spinach. Fresh to order!
$12.99
Ulti-Meat Spaghetti
Mama Pagoni's favorite meat sauce with meatballs on a bed of spaghetti.
$13.99
Build Your Own Pasta
Your choice of spaghetti, fettuccine, mostaccioli or cavatappi.
$10.99
Kid's Cutie Pie Tray
Kid's sauce & top their own pizza with up to 2 toppings.
$7.99
Kid's 2-Topping Pizza
$6.99
Kid's Chicken Strips
With potato wedges.
$6.99
Kid's Spaghetti
With marinara sauce & a breadstick.
$6.99
Chocolate Bomb
Chewy, sweet crust overflowing with hazelnut chocolate, topped with powdered sugar.
$8.99
Apple Bomb
Chewy, sweet crust stuffed with hot apple pie filling, topped with icing. It's the bomb!
$8.99
Cherry Bomb
Calzone-style crust filled with cherry pie filling & drizzled with icing.
$8.99
Soda
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
$1.59