Skip to main content
Salvatore's Tomato Pies

Salvatore's Tomato Pies

912 E Johnson St, Madison, WI 53703

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Salvatore's Tomato Pies a call to order. We hear their food's delish.


Build Your Own Pie

Our classic tomato pie is the base for your selection of toppings. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.


Carbonara Pie

Colby Caliente, mozzarella, mushroom, bacon, scallions, soft cooked organic eggs & arugula.


Elmer Street Special Pie

Mozzarella, smoked tomato sauce, roth grand queso, chili oil, finnochiona, Castel Vetrano olives & chili flakes.


Farmer John Pie

Smoked gouda, garlic, caramelized onion, crimini mushrooms, tomato & bacon.


Fat Uncle Tony Pie

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, red sauce & basil.


Fig & Bacon Pie

Wine poached mission figs, gorgonzola, bacon, and a balsamic red wine reduction.


Forza Pie

Nduja artisans uncured pepperoni, calabrese chili, smoked gouda, roasted ricotta, and roasted tomato.


Jalapeno Assesino Pie

Jalapeno pesto, carnitas, colby caliente, jalapeno & onion.


Vegan Supreme Pie

House-made vegan Italian sausage, Daiya mozzarella, red sauce, black olive, yellow onion, mushrooms, green pepper, banana pepper & basil.


Vegetarian Pie

Roasted beet pesto, kale, goat cheese, red wine reduction.


Wednesday Special Pie

Sausage, oyster mushroom, yellow bell pepper, roasted red pepper puree.



Market Salad

Vitruvian farm mixed greens, market vegetables, sar vecchio, seasonal vinaigrette.


Bacon & Cheese Bread

Five slices of Stalzy's baguette brushed with garlic butter then topped with Colby Caliente, smoked gouda and bacon.



Stracciatella (burrata filling), prosciutto, pomegranate seeds, arugula, lemon oil, batch bakehouse scalli.


Farro Salad

Hearty farro, roasted sweet potato, kale, brussels sprouts, apples, maple vinaigrette, Roth moody blue.


Side of Beet Pesto


Side of Dynamite Sauce


Side of Poblano Crema


Side of Red Sauce


Side of Vinaigrette



Steak Taco

Wagyu skirt steak, tomato, chimichurri, queso fresco, onion & cilantro.


Pork Taco

Braised pork shoulder, Piri Piri, pickled red onion, radish & cilantro.


Fish Taco

Wild-caught Pacific cod, cabbage slaw, dynamite sauce, onion & cilantro.


Vegan Taco

Impossimble beef chorizo, roasted poblano peppers, avocado, pico de gallo & cilantro.


SliceWIMadison53703 Salvatore's Tomato Pies
Price: $$