Skip to main content
Mystic Pizza II is currently ONLY available for PICKUP orders.
Mystic Pizza II

Mystic Pizza II

209 Providence-New London Turnpike, North Stonington, CT 06359
860-544-5225

Open until 9:45 PM

Full Hours

Delivery (20 - 35 min)

  • No minimum spend
  • Part of Slice Rewards
thin-crust-pizza
Thin Crust Pizza

Plain Thin Crust Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$16.75


One Topping Thin Crust Pizza

$18.15


Two Toppings Thin Crust Pizza

$19.55


Three Toppings Thin Crust Pizza

$20.95


Four Toppings Thin Crust Pizza

$22.35

traditional-pan-pizza
Traditional Pan Pizza

Plain Pan Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$10.00


One Topping Pan Pizza

$11.00

One Topping Pan Pizza

Two Toppings Pan Pizza

$12.00


Three Toppings Pan Pizza

$13.00


Four Toppings Pan Pizza

$14.00

specialty-thin-crust-pizza
Specialty Thin Crust Pizza

House Special Thin Crust Pizza

Pepperoni, meatball, sausage, green peppers, onions, mushrooms.

$23.85

House Special Thin Crust Pizza

Vegetarian Delight Thin Crust Pizza

Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, broccoli.

$23.35


Grecian Delight Thin Crust Pizza

Pepperoncinis, feta, tomatoes, black olives, garlic & oregano.

$22.85


Margherita Thin Crust Pizza

Plum tomato, fresh basil, garlic, fresh mozzarella. Thin crust only.

$19.50


Hawaiian Thin Crust Pizza

Ham & pineapple.

$19.55


Barbecue Chicken Thin Crust Pizza

Chicken, barbecue sauce.

$19.05


Moussaka Thin Crust Pizza

Eggplant, meatball, extra sauce.

$20.45


Seafood Delight Thin Crust Pizza

Shrimp, clams, scallops, garlic & oregano.

$25.60


Mediterranean Delight Thin Crust Pizza

Artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, spinach, tomatoes, garlic.

$22.55


Meatza Thin Crust Pizza

Sausage, meatball, pepperoni, salami & bacon.

$23.85


Chicken Gorgonzola Thin Crust Pizza

Chicken, gorgonzola, artichoke hearts.

$20.95


Texas Chicken Thin Crust Pizza

Chicken, red onion, bacon, bbq sauce.

$22.10


Buffalo Chicken Thin Crust Pizza

Buffalo chicken with blue cheese dressing on the side.

$20.00

specialty-pan-pizza
Specialty Pan Pizza

House Special Pan Pizza

Pepperoni, meatball, sausage, green peppers, onions, mushrooms.

$15.55


Vegetarian Delight Pan Pizza

Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, broccoli.

$15.05


Grecian Delight Pan Pizza

Pepperoncinis, feta, tomatoes, black olives, garlic & oregano.

$14.60


Hawaiian Pan Pizza

Ham & pineapple.

$12.50


Barbecue Chicken Pan Pizza

Chicken, barbecue sauce.

$12.00


Moussaka Pan Pizza

Eggplant, meatball, extra sauce.

$13.00


Seafood Delight Pan Pizza

Shrimp, clams, scallops, garlic & oregano.

$16.05


Mediterranean Delight Pan Pizza

Artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, spinach, tomatoes, garlic.

$14.85


Meatza Pan Pizza

Sausage, meatball, pepperoni, salami & bacon.

$15.55


Chicken Gorgonzola Pan Pizza

Chicken, gorgonzola, artichoke hearts.

$13.50


Texas Chicken Pan Pizza

Chicken, red onion, bacon, bbq sauce.

$14.25


Buffalo Chicken Pan Pizza

Buffalo chicken with blue cheese dressing on the side.

$13.00

white-thin-crust-pizza
White Thin Crust Pizza

John Gotti’s Clam Casino Thin Crust Pizza

Chopped clams, bacon, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, fresh basil.

$22.95


Marco’s Chicken Florentine Thin Crust Pizza

Baby spinach, chicken, feta, fresh mozzarella, parmesan.

$21.50


Quatro Formaggio Thin Crust Pizza

Ricotta, feta, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil. .

$21.00


Julia’s Special Thin Crust Pizza

Fresh eggplant, baby spinach, roasted red peppers, feta, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, extra virgin olive oil.

$22.95


Chicken Broccoli Thin Crust Pizza

Chicken, broccoli florets, fresh garlic, ricotta, parmesan, fresh mozzarella.

$22.35


Taco Mexicana Thin Crust Pizza

Seasoned ground beef, jalapeño, red onion, sharp cheddar cheese, sour cream, diced tomatoes, lettuce.

$22.95

party-sheet-pizza
Party Sheet Pizza
Please order 24 hours in advance.

Plain Party Sheet Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$29.99


One Topping Party Sheet Pizza

$31.99


Two Toppings Party Sheet Pizza

$34.99


Three Toppings Party Sheet Pizza

$36.99


Four Toppings Party Sheet Pizza

$38.99

pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza by the Slice

Cheese Pizza Slice

$4.25


Pepperoni Pizza Slice

$4.50

combos
Combos

Soup & Deli Sandwich Combo

$11.75


Soup & Salad Combo

Choice of cup of soup & dinner salad. Make it a bowl for an additional charge.

$11.50


Slice & Salad Combo

"Slice of heaven” with fresh garden greens. Only cheese & pepperoni available.

$11.50

appetizers
Appetizers

Chicken Tenders

Lightly battered chicken breast strips served with marinara sauce.

$11.50


Boneless Buffalo Tenders

Tossed in our own hot sauce and served with blue cheese and celery.

$11.75


Hot Chicken Wings

Served with hot sauce, blue cheese, and celery on the side.

$13.00


Buffalo Style Chicken Wings

Blue cheese, and celery on the side.

$13.00

Buffalo Style Chicken Wings

Mozzarella Sticks

Lightly breaded fried mozzarella served with marinara sauce.

$10.75


Fried Calamari

Lightly breaded native calamari served with hot pepper rings & marinara sauce.

$13.50


Homemade Onion Rings

Lightly battered, thinly sliced, and crispy fried.

$9.00


Mystic Nachos Grande

Corn tortillas layered with “Carne con queso” (meat & cheeses) garnished with black olives, tomatoes & jalapenos, served with salsa & sour cream.

$14.50

Mystic Nachos Grande

Combo Platter

Combination of wings, tenders & mozzarella sticks served with French fries & dipping sauce.

$15.00


Garlic Bread

Hearth baked bread served with garlic-seasoned butter oil.

$6.75


Four Cheese Garlic Bread

Hearth baked bread seasoned with olive butter oil, baked with fresh garlic, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar & parmesan cheese served with marinara sauce.

$9.25


French Fries

Golden-fried premium Idaho potatoes served mountain high.

$7.25


Sweet Potato Fries

Coarse cut Idaho sweet jumbo potato fries.

$8.00


Chips & Salsa

Warm tortillas served with salsa & cheddar cheese sauce.

$9.25

soups
Soups

Clam Chowder Soup

World-renowned chowder.

$6.00


Soup of the Day

Made fresh daily.

$6.00


Texas Chili

$6.00

salads
Salads
All salads are served with romaine lettuce, kalamata olives, red onions, bell peppers, cucumbers, croutons & cherry tomatoes.

Garden Salad

Romaine lettuce, kalamata olives, red onions, bell peppers, and cherry tomatoes.

$10.50


Antipasto Salad

Pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone cheese.

$13.75


Greek Salad

Feta cheese, grapeleaves, pepperoncini.

$13.50


Julienne Salad

Ham, roast beef, turkey, provolone cheese.

$13.75


Tuna Salad

White tuna, shredded cheddar & mozzarella & pickles.

$13.50


California Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken bacon, American cheese.

$15.50


Mystic Love Salad

Tricolor pasta, grilled chicken, gorgonzola, bacon bits.

$15.00


Buffalo Chicken Salad

Tender chicken strips, hot sauce, bleu cheese.

$14.50


Caesar Salad

Crispy romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, tossed with caesars dressing and topped with marinated grilled chicken & croutons.

$10.50


Chicken Caesar Salad

Crispy romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, tossed with caesars dressing and topped with marinated grilled chicken & croutons.

$15.50


Greek Chicken Salad

Tender char-broiled chicken, feta cheese, pepperoni, stuffed grape leaves & grilled pita bread.

$15.50


Tuscan Salad

Garden greens, walnuts, pecans, cranberries, apples, gorgonzola cheese, balsamic dressing.

$15.50


Mediterranean Salad

Gyro, feta cheese, kalamata olives, pepperoncini peppers, artichokes, stuffed grape leaves, yogurt-cucumber garlic dressing, delicious!! Served with warm pita bread.

$15.50


Burger with the Works Salad

Angus beef patty, grilled mushrooms, bacon topped with gorgonzola & American cheese, served without Love dressing.

$15.50


Grilled Chicken Salad

Marinated char-broiled chicken breast.

$14.00

side-orders
Side Orders

Coleslaw

Finely-shredded raw cabbage & dressing. A hit at both the picnic table and the dining room table.

$4.50


Pasta

Spaghetti or shells.

$8.00


Vegetable of the Day

$8.00


Mac & Cheese

A family favorite recipe, loved by both children and adults.

$8.00


Dinner Salad

$7.50

calzones
Calzones

The Cheeser Calzone

Made with our own "secret recipe" sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese.

$11.50


Mystic Calzone

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & ricotta.

$14.75


Chicken Athena Calzone

Chicken, spinach, feta, garlic, mozzarella & ricotta.

$14.75


Veggie Calzone

Broccoli, green peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms, spinach, mozzarella & ricotta.

$14.50

deli-sandwiches
Deli Sandwiches
Substitute salad for fries for an additional charge. Choice of white, wheat, rye bread, kaiser roll, or a wrap.

Turkey Deli Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomato & french fries.

$11.25


Ham Deli Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomato & french fries.

$11.25

Ham Deli Sandwich

Tuna Deli Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomato & french fries.

$11.25


Roast Beef Deli Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomato & french fries.

$11.25


BLT Deli Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomato & french fries.

$11.25


Mystic Reuben Deli Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomato & french fries.

$11.25

join-the-club
Join the Club
Served with french fries or pasta salad on your choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.

Turkey Club Sandwich

Freshly made with cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.

$13.75


Ham Club Sandwich

$12.50


Roast Beef Club Sandwich

$12.50


Tuna Club Sandwich

$12.50


Cheeseburger Club Sandwich

Served with lettuce, tomatoes & bacon.

$12.50

grinders
Grinders
Selected quality meats, cheeses & vegetables served on your choice of crispy or soft Italian bread, hot or cold, small or large. We use 100% pure olive oil. Cabbage may be substituted for lettuce. Grinder bread baked fresh daily.

Meatless Grinder

$8.75


Salami Grinder

$9.00


Ham Grinder

$9.30


Tuna Grinder

$9.30


Bacon Grinder

$9.30


Genoa Salami Grinder

$9.30


Turkey Grinder

Turkey, lettuce, and tomatoes.

$9.80


Roast Beef Grinder

Oven-roasted with lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese.

$9.80


Italian Combo Grinder

$9.80


Chicken Grinder

$9.80


Pepperoni Grinder

$9.80


Pastrami Grinder

$9.80


Cheeseburger Grinder

$10.30


Steak Grinder

$10.80


Fish Grinder

$10.30

parmesan-style-grinders
Parmesan Style Grinders
All hot grinders come with marinara & provolone unless specified. Grinder bread baked fresh daily. All hot grinders come with marinara & provolone unless specified.

Meatball Parmesan Grinder

$9.30


Sausage Parmesan Grinder

$9.30


Eggplant Parmesan Grinder

$9.30


Chicken Parmesan Grinder

$9.80


Veal Parmesan Grinder

$10.30

burgers
Burgers
Sandwiches below served with French fries & coleslaw. Substitute sweet potato fries for an additional charge.

Hamburger

With lettuce & tomato.

$12.75


Cheeseburger

Burger with lettuce & tomato and American cheese.

$13.00


Burger with the Works

With lettuce, tomato, onion, mushrooms, melted cheese, & bacon.

$15.00


Pizza Burger

With “Mystic Sauce” & mozzarella cheese.

$14.00


Gyro Platter

Tender strips of gyro smothered in garlic yogurt-cucumber sauce wrapped in a pita with lettuce, onions, & tomatoes.

$14.00


Chicken Souvlaki Platter

Tender chicken breast smothered in garlic yogurt-cucumber sauce wrapped in a pita with lettuce, onions, & tomatoes.

$13.50


Fried Fish Platter

Golden fried Cod fish topped with tartar sauce, lettuce, tomatoes.

$13.50

chicken
Chicken
8 oz. Skinless breast of chicken. Sandwiches below served on a kaiser roll with french fries & coleslaw. Also available as a wrap. Substitute sweet potato fries for an additional charge.

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

With lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.

$13.00


California Chicken Sandwich

With lettuce, tomato, bacon, American cheese & lite ranch dressing.

$14.00


Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Served with hot sauce, lettuce & tomato.

$13.50

fresh-seafood
Fresh Seafood
Seafood entrees served with french fries, coleslaw, our famous tartar sauce & garnished with lemon wedges. Cooked with Canola oil (no trans fats).

Fish & Chips

Lightly breaded Atlantic cod.

$16.50


Fried Bay Scallops

Fresh off the docks from Stonington, ct.

$21.50


Fried Calamari

Atlantic calamari from our native waters.

$18.50

dinners
Dinners
Add a dinner salad for an additional charge.

Baked Lasagna

Layers of meat & cheese baked to perfection served with garlic bread.

$16.00


Eggplant Parmesan

Thin slices of breaded eggplant baked with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese, served with pasta & garlic bread.

$16.00


Chicken Parmesan

Chicken breast lightly breaded, smothered with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese, Served with pasta & garlic bread.

$17.00


Spaghetti with Meatballs

Italian style meatball made with ground veal, parmesan, served with marina & garlic bread.

$14.00

Spaghetti with Meatballs
desserts
Desserts

Cheesecake

Classic cheesecake with a rich, dense, smooth, and creamy consistency.

$6.50


Rice Pudding

Old fashioned baked rice pudding.

$5.50


Cheesecake with Strawberries

Classic cheesecake with a rich, dense, smooth, and creamy consistency.

$7.75


Specialty Desserts

$6.50

beverages
Beverages

Soda

$2.75