Skip to main content

Cheesy Does It

133 S Broadway St, Butler, IN 46721
260-475-7954
New

Order Ahead We open Wed at 11:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
Skip to first category

House Favorites

These are the shop recommendations for a great meal experience.

1st & Dill Cheesy Garlic Bread

Ital bread, garlic & herb butter, dill pickles from Sechler's Pickles topped with a 4/Blend of mozzarella & Dill

Beast Mode Pizza

Marinara, Pepperoni, Sausage, Ital Sausage, Ham & Smoked Bacon. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese

Jumbo Bone in Wings

These are not your typical wings....These are The biggest wings that Tyson sells... Magnum Style

Cannolis

4 Cannolis with Chocolate Chip filling topped with Chocolate Drizzle

Raspberry Lemon Fizz

Starry, Raspberry syrup, lemon juice, FV creamer, whipped cream, raspberry drizzle & cherry

daily-specials

Daily Specials

2 Sausage Roll Deal

2 Giant Sausage Roll Deal(NO Substitutions, No Add on's) American Sausage, Italian Sausage, House- Marinara, 4 Blend of Mozzarella Cheese. Comes with dipping sauce *Online ONLY

$21.99

$20.89

Medium Specialty Pizza, Bread Stks & 2 Ltr Deal

Any medium specialty pizza, small bread stks & 2 Ltr( No Substitutions) *Online or Call in

$22.99

$21.84

monthly-pizza-special-

Monthly Pizza Special

A little something different each month.

Mac N Cheese Pizza

Beer cheese, penne noodles, 4-blend of mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, topped with smoked bacon

$13.99

$13.29

Mac N Cheese Pizza
appetizers

Appetizers

Let's get it started tonight!

1st & Dill Cheesy Garlic Bread

Ital bread, garlic & herb butter, dill pickles from Sechler's Pickles topped with a 4/Blend of mozzarella & Dill

$4.29

$4.08

1st & Dill Cheesy Garlic Bread

Breadsticks

We make our Breadsticks in house using our delicious pizza dough cut into sticks, baked just right. Then we cover them with our tasty Garlic Butter & topped off with Parmesan Cheese. Each Full Order comes with 8 sticks and 2 Cups of sauce.

$3.99

$3.79

Breadsticks

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Ital bread, garlic & herb butter topped with a 4/Blend of mozzarella

$3.99

$3.79

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Cheese Curds

Oven Baked Cheese Curds baked to a golden brown oozing with Mozzarella.

$5.99

$5.69

Cheese Curds

Bruschetta

Ital bread, garlic & herb butter, house-made tomato-basil-olive oil mix topped w/ a 4-Blend of mozzarella

$8.99

$8.54

Bruschetta

Pretzel Bites

Comes with a cup of beer cheese

$5.99

$5.69

Pretzel Bites

Mozzarella Stix

Comes with a cup of marinara

$5.59

$5.31

Mozzarella Stix
buildyourown-pizza

Build-Your-Own Pizza

We only use Premium Bellisimo Dough, Premium Fresh ingredients, and Misto 4 Blend Detroit Style Mozzarella Cheese.

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$7.99

$7.59

Cheese Pizza
specialty-pizzas

Specialty Pizzas

Our low-carb pizza option. The crust itself is 6 net carbs!!!

Beast Mode Pizza

Marinara, Pepperoni, Sausage, Ital Sausage, Ham & Smoked Bacon. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese

$13.99

$13.29

Beast Mode Pizza

All Star Supreme Pizza

Marinara, Pepperoni, Sausage, Ital Sausage, Ham, Onion, Green Peppers, Mushrooms Green & Black Olives. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese

$13.99

$13.29

All Star Supreme Pizza

The Red Zone Pizza

Marinara, 4oz's of Pepperoni. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella

$13.99

$13.29

The Red Zone Pizza

The Hot Route Pizza

House-made Blazer Hot Sauce, Herb Roasted Chicken, Onion, Sechler's Banana Peppers. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese & Ranch

$13.99

$13.29

The Hot Route Pizza

Fowl Play Pizza

Buttermilk Ranch, Herb Roasted Chicken, Sliced Tomatoes, Smoked Bacon, Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella

$13.99

$13.29

Fowl Play Pizza

Freshman Pizza

Marinara, Mushroom, Onion, Green Peppers, Green & Black Olives, Sechler's Banana Peppers. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese

$13.99

$13.29

Freshman Pizza

Tailgater Pizza

BBQ Sauce, Herb Roasted Chicken, Onion, Smoked Bacon. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella

$13.99

$13.29

Tailgater Pizza

The Big Dill Pizza

Marinara, Pepperoni, Sechler's Banana Peppers, Sechler's Dill Pickles. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese

$13.99

$13.29

The Big Dill Pizza

The Aloha Bowl Pizza

$13.99

$13.29

The Aloha Bowl Pizza

Blazer Pizza

$13.99

$13.29

Blazer Pizza

Margherita Pizza

Fresh Olive Oil Tomato & Basil Mix. Topped With a 4-Blend of Mozzarella

$13.99

$13.29

Margherita Pizza
ultra-thin-pizza

Ultra Thin Pizza

We only use Premium Bellisimo Dough, Premium Fresh ingredients, and Misto 4 Blend Detroit Style Mozzarella Cheese.

Ultra Thin Three Toppings Pizza

Choice of 3 free toppings on ultra thin crust. Topped with a 4-Blend of Mozzarella. Additional toppings cost extra.

$9.99

$9.49

Ultra Thin Three Toppings Pizza
hot-subs

Hot Subs

Delicious Hot Subs using Italian Blended Bread with our 4 blend Detroit Style Mozzarella Cheese.

QB Club Sub

We start with our Italian-blend bread, which comes with Smoked Sliced Ham, Sliced Turkey, Sliced Tomatoes, Smoked Bacon, Lettuce & Mayo. It is topped off with our 4-Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$7.29

$6.93

QB Club Sub

Teriyaki Chicken Sub

We start with our Italian-blend bread, which comes with Teriyaki sauce, Herb-Roasted Fajita Chicken, Diced Onion, Green Pepper, and Sechler's Banana Peppers. It is topped off with our 4-Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$6.49

$6.17

Teriyaki Chicken Sub

Fowl Play Sub

Ital Bread, Herb Roasted Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Sliced Tomatoes, Ranch & Mozzarella Cheese

$6.99

$6.64

Fowl Play Sub

Shack Sub

$7.29

$6.93

Shack Sub

Italian Sub

We start with our Italian blended bread and comes with Honey Smoked Ham, Genoa Salami, Classic Pepperoni, Diced Onion, Diced Green Pepper, a drizzle of Creamy Italian Dressing and topped off with our 4 Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$7.29

$6.93

Italian Sub

Philly Sub

We start with our Italian blended bread and comes with Shaved Steak, Diced Onion, Diced Green Pepper and topped off with Beer Cheese.

$6.99

$6.64

Philly Sub

Ham & Cheese Sub

We start with our Italian blended bread and comes with Honey Smoked Ham, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo and topped off with our 4 Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$6.49

$6.17

Ham & Cheese Sub

Bacon Cheddar Burger Sub

We start with our Italian-blend bread, which comes with Beef, Sliced Tomatoes, Smoked Bacon, Dill Pickles, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Mayo. It is topped off with our 4-Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$6.99

$6.64

Bacon Cheddar Burger Sub

Turkey & Cheese Sub

We start with our Italian-blend bread, which comes with Sliced Turkey, Sliced Tomatoes, Lettuce & Mayo. It is topped off with our 4-Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$6.49

$6.17

Turkey & Cheese Sub

Boss Hog Sub

Ital Bread, House-made Pulled Pork, Dill Pickles, Mozzarella & House-made Slaw.

$7.49

$7.12

Boss Hog Sub

Stromboli Sub

We start with our Italian blended bread and comes with Marinara, Classic Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Diced Onion, Diced Green Pepper and topped off with our 4 Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$6.49

$6.17

Stromboli Sub

BLT Sub

Bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$6.99

$6.64

BLT Sub

BBQ Chicken Sub

We start with our Italian blended bread and comes with Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce, Herb Roasted Fajita Chicken, Hickory Smoked Bacon, Diced Onion, and topped off with our 4 Blend Mozzarella Cheese.

$6.99

$6.64

BBQ Chicken Sub

Build Your Own Sub

$3.29

$3.13

Build Your Own Sub
sausage-rolls

Sausage Rolls

Our Giant Sausage Rolls are just that.

Giant Sausage Roll

We are known for our Giant Sausage Rolls. They include House-made Marinara Sauce, American Sausage, Italian Sausage, and our 4 blend Detroit Style Mozzarella Cheese. Side of BBQ

$11.99

$11.39

Giant Sausage Roll

Red Zone Roll

$11.99

$11.39

BYO Rolls

We are known for our Giant Sausage Rolls. They include House-made Pizza Sauce, your choice of up to 6 toppings, and our 4 blend Detroit Style Mozzarella Cheese. Side of BBQ

$13.99

$13.29

BYO Rolls
loaded-fry

Loaded Fry

Choose a loaded fry from 5 different options

Cheesy Bacon Ranch

Pub Fries, Beer Cheese, 4-Blend of Mozzarella Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Smoked Bacon topped with Ranch Dressing

$9.99

$9.49

Philly Cheese Steak

Pub Fries, Shaved Ribeye, & Beer Cheese

$9.99

$9.49

Buffalo Chicken

Pub Fries, Beer Cheese, Chicken & Blazer Sauce

$9.99

$9.49

Pizza

Pub Fries. Pepperoni, House Sauce, & 4-Blend of Mozzarella

$9.99

$9.49

Pulled Pork

Pub Fries, Pulled Pork, Beer Cheese, BBQ, & Onion

$9.99

$9.49

wings

Wings

We Oven-Bake All Of Our Wings! Our Boneless Wings By Tyson Come In A Variety Of Sizes. They Are Served By Weight. 1/2 Lb = About 7-9 Pieces. Our Bone-in Wings Are Magnum Wings. These Are The Largest Wings Tyson Sells. Get Our Wings Naked Or With Your Choice Of Sauce.

Jumbo Bone in Wings

These are not your typical wings....These are The biggest wings that Tyson sells... Magnum Style

$8.99

$8.54

Jumbo Bone in Wings

Boneless Wings

$7.99

$7.59

Boneless Wings
pasta

Pasta

Cavatini

$8.99

$8.54

Cavatini

Red Zone Pasta

$8.99

$8.54

Red Zone Pasta

Chicken Alfredo

$8.99

$8.54

Chicken Alfredo

Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese

Penne noodles, beer cheese, cheddar cheese, parmesan, 4-blend of mozzarella & house-made pulled pork

$8.99

$8.54

Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese
uncrustabowls

Un-Crust-A-Bowls

A Low-Carb option. All the pizza deliciousness without the crust.

Specialty Pizza Bowl

$9.99

$9.49

Specialty Pizza Bowl

BYO Bowl

Bowl marinara, 5 toppings & mozzarella.

$9.99

$9.49

BYO Bowl
salads

Salads

All salads come with iceberg lettuce.

Side Salad

Diced Red Onion, Diced Green Pepper, Tomato, Shredded Cheddar, Croutons, and your choice of dressing.

$2.99

$2.84

Side Salad

Half Chicken Club Salad

Herb Roasted Fajita Chicken, Hickory Smoked Bacon, Diced Red Onion, Diced Green Pepper, Tomato, Shredded Cheddar, Croutons and your choice of dressing (on the side)

$7.99

$7.59

Half Chicken Club Salad

Half Tossed Salad

$5.99

$5.69

Half Tossed Salad

Whole Chicken Club Salad

Herb Roasted Fajita Chicken, Hickory Smoked Bacon, Diced Red Onion, Diced Green Pepper, Tomato, Shredded Cheddar, Croutons and your choice of dressing (on the side)

$9.99

$9.49

Whole Chicken Club Salad

Whole Tossed Salad

Diced Red Onion, Diced Green Pepper, Tomato, Shredded Cheddar, Croutons, and your choice of dressing.

$7.99

$7.59

Whole Tossed Salad

Half Chicken Caesar Salad

Chicken, Croutons, Parmesan & Caesar Dressing

$7.99

$7.59

Half Chicken Caesar Salad

Half Chef Salad

Honey Smoked Ham, Oven Roasted Turkey, Diced Onion, Diced Green Pepper, Tomato, Shredded Cheddar & Croutons with your choice of Dressing (on the side).

$7.99

$7.59

Half Chef Salad

Whole Chicken Caesar Salad

Chicken, Croutons, Parmesan & Caesar Dressing.

$9.99

$9.49

Whole Chicken Caesar Salad

Whole Chef Salad

Honey Smoked Ham, Oven Roasted Turkey, Diced Onion, Diced Green Pepper, Tomato, Shredded Cheddar & Croutons with your choice of Dressing (on the side).

$9.99

$9.49

sides

Sides

Fries

$3.19

$3.03

Fries

House Slaw

$1.99

$1.89

House Slaw

Ruffles Chips

$1.59

$1.51

Ruffles Chips
desserts

Desserts

Cannolis

4 Cannolis with Chocolate Chip filling topped with Chocolate Drizzle

$7.99

$7.59

Cannolis

Cin & Sugar Pretzel Bites

$5.99

$5.69

Cin & Sugar Pretzel Bites

Baked Cookie

$6.99

$6.64

Baked Cookie
dipping-sauceother-stuff

Dipping Sauce/Other Stuff

Dipping Sauce, Plates & Forks

Cups

$0.25

$0.24

Dipping Sauces

$1.09

$1.04

Plates

$0.25

$0.24

dirty-soda

Dirty Soda

Raspberry Lemon Fizz

Starry, Raspberry syrup, lemon juice, FV creamer, whipped cream, raspberry drizzle & cherry

$4.25

$4.04

Raspberry Lemon Fizz

D Cherry

Pepsi, vanilla syrup, cherry syrup, OG creamer, whipped cream & cherries

$4.25

$4.04

D Cherry

Apple Pie

Pepsi, apple crisp syrup, OG creamer, whipped cream & cinnamon

$4.25

$4.04

Apple Pie

Dr Raspberry

Dr Pepper, raspberry syrup, OG creamer

$3.99

$3.79

Egg Nog Rootbeer

Root beer, eggnog syrup, brown sugar cinnamon syrup, FV creamer & whipped cream

$4.25

$4.04

Egg Nog Rootbeer

Coconut Cream Pie

Root beer, coconut syrup, FV creamer

$3.99

$3.79

Coconut Cream Pie

Dr Cookies

Dr Pepper, butter cookies syrup, OG creamer

$4.25

$4.04

Dr Cookies

Creamsicle

Orange soda, vanilla syrup, FV creamer

$3.99

$3.79

Creamsicle
2-ltrs

2 Ltrs

2 Ltrs

$3.29

$3.13

2 Ltrs
fountain-drinks

Fountain Drinks

Fountain Drinks

$2.29

$2.18

Fountain Drinks

Cheesy Does It - View Menu & Order Online - 133 S Broadway St, Butler, IN 46721 - Slice

SliceINButler46721 Cheesy Does It
Price: $$